Dp. I’m a firm believer that ‘a man is not a plan’- I’ve seen many families suffer when you put all your income in one persons basket. It’s just not smart for a variety of reasons. BUT the mom load is real. More people need to buy houses on one salary, the McMansion culture is ridiculous and exists nowhere else in the world. One parent should work part time. We need to stop putting dual income pressure on families. |
It’s not McMansions, it’s the price of land with okay commutes. And education and medical costs. Granite countertops aren’t moving the needle. |
I was a PT nanny all throughout undergrad and noticed a lot of the working moms and even stay at home moms were frustrated! One time a dad apologized the house was a mess because Kate his wife who works FT couldn’t get to it! These were families who could afford to hire a nanny. I made sure I was crystal clear to my boyfriend that I wanted to stay at home with my kids. Culturally it’s also very acceptable for Muslim women to stay at home with the kids so this wasn’t a big deal with most of the men I dated. I actually work PT now and it’s hard to balance that! It’s hard being a woman in the US unless you have a lot of money and can hire lots of help or have a husband who truly does half of the housework. My dh doesn’t do much unless I nag him and after awhile I get tired of asking. I can’t think of a single mom I know who isn’t tired.
|
I’m going to tell my daughter that if she wants to do 50% or more of house/childcare, she needs to focus on gunning her career as hard as she can in her 20’s so that she will have the skills and connections to make an alternate path while her kids are young. If she wants to outsource, she has to make or marry enough money to do that (actually we could also give it to her). If she wants a male partner to do 50% or more, she’s going to have to really prioritize that when she’s dating because it’s hard to find. |
We've done dh working a high pressure job with high potential, and me wah PT and now with older kids FT. It's working out just fine. My brother and sil are 50% earning, 50% caregiving and entirely equal in all ways. It's working out just fine. I don't think there is a one scenario fits all depending on individual needs, wants and specific jobs. |
Key is being comfortable in your marriage and communication. We chose for me to be SAHM. I was making $100K+ 25 years ago. I had a great career and we could have easily afforded a great nanny. But we didn't think it was fair to our kids to have two parents in high powered careers and have us both traveling extensively. And I wanted to be with the kids---we waited until 30s to have them, so I had worked and made my choice. I knew my spouse would go further in his career (I had no desire to go into management, I just loved my job). So I stayed at home. Spouse advanced quickly, and it is easier to do if you have no worries about picking kids up, having to take day off/work from home (25 years ago) because it's "your day to be with the sick kid" or having to say "nope I cannot travel that week, because my wife has to travel for work so I'm on kid duty after hours." Everyone is happier because it's "calmer at home". The kids don't have to be in bed at X time because they have to get up at 6am to get to daycare by 7am. Evenings and mornings were much more enjoyable for all. But I would not have done that if I were not considered an equal by my spouse. Then again, I wouldn't have had kids with a partner who didn't value that. |
There is a huge range of jobs between "Big Law" and "govt lawyer". DP: but I suspect her husband could have found a higher paying job than "govt lawyer" had she been a SAHP. Or as you said, you adjust your standard of living accordingly |
I agree, it is so tough. I chose to do the SAHM model b/c I burned outs, but I am stressed now because DH does not appreciate it / is disrespectful (he initially said he respected it), and I don’t think my overall stress has decreased (although my relationship with my kids is much better than when I was working). I am now struggling to return to work / find a job after a long absence. I think if spouse is really truly on board with decision to either work or SAH, either situation can be manageable (although being a working mom is definitely super intense and hard), but if spouse is not, either situation sucks. That’s just my anecdotal take as I’m feeling a bit depressed right now. |
Being a stay at home mom is very acceptable in Muslim culture, but somehow we are backwards. We are raised to only work if we need the income. I think it’s great we have choices. The biggest problem comes when you work and your husband isn’t pulling his weight. That happens a lot. I know there are a lot of women on here with great husbands but the majority of women are tired and would like a partner. They don’t want a helper or occasional babysitter and that’s what some men end of being. It truly sucks and there isn’t a lot you can do to see what kind of dad the guy will be. Men change. It easier to clean up when you don’t have kids and younger. There is also all the mental energy we need to put into having kids. I’m burned out at a PT working mom, but I also get tired as a stay at home mom. Having choices is great but a lot of use are still tired when the kids are younger, special needs etc.
|
My nephew was in aftercare and when my sister would pick him up, he was literally sitting alone under a play structure, without a book or friends, bored and tired. She finally pulled him out because they did *nothing* with the kids. I’m not sure why these places advertise “activities” when they don’t even play a round of Uno with the kids. |
WTF are you talking about? McMansion culture? This is DC. You get 1500 square feet for $1 million. |
Haha you raise a good point that when other cultures think a wife should be SAH, it's viewed as backwards/regressive but if a white suburban American mom does it it's aspirational. |
I worked at a Montessori school that offered aftercare. By 3 pm we are tired as f***. They play outside for an hour or longer, have snack and play with toys. Teachers can’t do group activities all day. We get tired. |
No that wasn’t my point at all. My point was we don’t get as worked up about what is right or wrong. Most Muslim women have the choice to stay at home and it’s non issue with their husbands. A lot of Muslim women start working when the kids get older and a lot of the religious ones volunteer to organize the kids activities at the mosque. It’s awesome we have choices and I do feel more supported in my community. Some of us work and some of us do not. It rarely comes up in conversation. Maybe religious people have less anxiety about a spouse dying, divorce etc |
It sounds like this is school by school. My kid is at an APS school and he doesnt go to aftercare, but we often play at a park nearby after school and so I see what is going on a lot of days when we walk back. They are almost always outside and the kids look like they are having a blast. Well staffed. Again this is coming from someone that has adjusted work hours to not do after care because that works best for our family, but we should all recognize that not all aftercare is the same! I would definitely be comfortable sending my APS kid to this one if that made sense for our family schedule wise/I couldnt' flex my schedule. |