This Is Us, Season 4

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I think the flash forward is only 9 months. Randall told Kevin that their 40th was only 9 months away. Now i hate Toby and feel bad for Kate. And why in the flash forward are Kevin and Randall not speaking?

My theory is that Kevin's fiancee is deja's birth mom. We know he likes african American women and it would really mess with randall and beth if they got together.

I don’t think so.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I think the flash forward is only 9 months. Randall told Kevin that their 40th was only 9 months away. Now i hate Toby and feel bad for Kate. And why in the flash forward are Kevin and Randall not speaking?

My theory is that Kevin's fiancee is deja's birth mom. We know he likes african American women and it would really mess with randall and beth if they got together.

He dated one African American woman. But nice try.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I think the flash forward is only 9 months. Randall told Kevin that their 40th was only 9 months away. Now i hate Toby and feel bad for Kate. And why in the flash forward are Kevin and Randall not speaking?

My theory is that Kevin's fiancee is deja's birth mom. We know he likes african American women and it would really mess with randall and beth if they got together.

I don’t think so.

It might make more sense if its Beth. Would explain why him and Randall aren't talking anymore lol. Too much wine in the pantry or something.

Seriously though no I don't think the shrimp carrying was realistic what with the dishes and glasses already on the table.

And I hope Toby stands up to Kate. She is just too much.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I think the flash forward is only 9 months. Randall told Kevin that their 40th was only 9 months away. Now i hate Toby and feel bad for Kate. And why in the flash forward are Kevin and Randall not speaking?

My theory is that Kevin's fiancee is deja's birth mom. We know he likes african American women and it would really mess with randall and beth if they got together.

Hmm... except we saw Kevin’s future kid at the end of last season and he did look at all biracial. I know the genetics can be strange or It could
Be a different kid, but

[Anonymous]

Whose house were they at during the flash forward? That wasn’t Randall’s house. My theory is that flash forward took place in Bradford.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Whose house were they at during the flash forward? That wasn’t Randall’s house. My theory is that flash forward took place in Bradford.

It was the Pearson family cabin

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I think the flash forward is only 9 months. Randall told Kevin that their 40th was only 9 months away. Now i hate Toby and feel bad for Kate. And why in the flash forward are Kevin and Randall not speaking?

My theory is that Kevin's fiancee is deja's birth mom. We know he likes african American women and it would really mess with randall and beth if they got together.

No, Kevin's son that we saw in the 10-year flash forward is clearly white and looks a lot like young Kevin does. I think this rules this theory out, and the Zoe-returning theory.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:The flash-forwards seem like they're 10 years in the future -- everyone is gray. I wonder if they're going to have this play out over a decade.

My understanding is it’s only 9 months

It was definitely only 9 months because when they zoomed in on the police forms Kate was signing when the police returned Rebecca to them, the forms were dated August 31, 2020.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:The flash-forwards seem like they're 10 years in the future -- everyone is gray. I wonder if they're going to have this play out over a decade.

My understanding is it’s only 9 months

It was definitely only 9 months because when they zoomed in on the police forms Kate was signing when the police returned Rebecca to them, the forms were dated August 31, 2020.

She also signed the documents "Kate Pearson" perhaps hinting at a divorce? Not sure if she ever took Toby's name in the first place but I think they zoomed in on this for a reason.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:The flash-forwards seem like they're 10 years in the future -- everyone is gray. I wonder if they're going to have this play out over a decade.

My understanding is it’s only 9 months

It was definitely only 9 months because when they zoomed in on the police forms Kate was signing when the police returned Rebecca to them, the forms were dated August 31, 2020.

There are two different flash forwards. The one in 2020, and the one that ended last season, which seemed 10 years in the future -- Rebecca's hair was long, everyone else was gray.

[Anonymous]

Where was Miguel when Rebecca failed to return to the Phila house? Shouldn't he be on top of this?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Where was Miguel when Rebecca failed to return to the Phila house? Shouldn't he be on top of this?

He was already at Randall's house. I thought that seemed weird too. Would she really go to a movie by herself (and on Thanksgiving?). Wouldn't they have been together?

[Anonymous]

I noticed Toby was at the 10 year (?) flash forward (the one that ended Season 3), but Kate wasn't, band Kate was at the 40th birthday flash forward, but Toby wasn't.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I think the flash forward is only 9 months. Randall told Kevin that their 40th was only 9 months away. Now i hate Toby and feel bad for Kate. And why in the flash forward are Kevin and Randall not speaking?

My theory is that Kevin's fiancee is deja's birth mom. We know he likes african American women and it would really mess with randall and beth if they got together.

No, Kevin's son that we saw in the 10-year flash forward is clearly white and looks a lot like young Kevin does. I think this rules this theory out, and the Zoe-returning theory.

Which flash forward was that? I was under the impression the cabin flash forward is a year into the future. *
I also can't remember which birthday Season 1, how old were they?

*Which brought up a q for me, what if a cast member dies or something before the flash forward becomes real time? 10 years is one thing but if they plan to have the show next year you gotta be careful.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Where was Miguel when Rebecca failed to return to the Phila house? Shouldn't he be on top of this?

He was already at Randall's house. I thought that seemed weird too. Would she really go to a movie by herself (and on Thanksgiving?). Wouldn't they have been together?

He was going to have Thanksgiving with his kids, that was mentioned in the previous episode I'm pretty sure.