Stop laser-focusing on "CRT" then and articulate exactly what it is that you want to go away. Stop throwing tantrums and use your words. |
Legally the most recent PP is right. Voters decide the elections that pick people who set statewide and local school standards and that's the most control we have. However voters can decide to put into place a governor who will sign off on a bill allowing parents to pick an alternate book for one containing sexually explicit material. McAuliffe was clearly not that governor. Maybe Youngkin is. And maybe Virginia voters think parents should at least be able to do that. I can think of plenty of wonderful, valuable books that I personally think are great to read...but in college or later. |
Yes, astroturfing is not new. Education is just the new focus for it. I guess now we will see what Youngkin will bring to the table now for schools. Was it all talk? Will the GOP actually help our kids after exploiting them? |
Please show me where in the SOLs there is direction to teach about Ibrahim X and white privilege? Remember, we criticize teachers for teaching to the test remember — that was the last popular parent agitation, anyway. So it should be easy for you to cite precisely where in the SOLs the CRT stuff is taught. |
Parents should decide *all* of what is taught in schools. The school board members are supposed to operate based on continued feedback from parents. They are not supposed to just get hired based on campaign promises and then run off to implement their own agendas without any regard to what parents want. You seem to have a severe misunderstanding of representative government. We don't elect representatives to think for us, we elect them to carry out our will. Sure, the representative has the power and the duty to make his/her own judgments, even in cases where such judgments do not have popular support, but this in no way negates the fact that it is at least partly, if not the majority, the duty of a representative to carry out the will of his/her constituents. Therefore to say that parents should not be able to decide what schools teach, is to completely distort the nature of representative democracy. |
I never before equated showing up at the ballot box and casting a vote with throwing a tantrum. Youngkin pretty clearly laid out in his closing argument that he wanted Virginia standards to teach US history, warts and all, without making kids do things like "privilege walks," be separated out by race in classrooms, and similar kinds of activities that parents are reacting to. People voted for that. |
You do understand that school boards don’t set curriculum, right? Before this CRT nonsense it was whining about Common Core. Everyone complained teachers taught to the test. The test is based on the Standards of Learning. So unless you can show me where CRT is discussed in the SOLs, you can sit the rest of this conversation out. |
Hopefully. I can't wait for parents to realize that they can make English classes unworkable by rejecting every book and choosing their own. I personally plan on rejecting every book when I get the power because why not? Of course, everyone realizes how insane it would be to give parents that power so it will never happen. |
Already done. I voted and now McAuliffe is going away. You mad?
|
DP. Since people are usually reacting to what's provided in administrator and teacher training, including the PP you responded to, it makes more sense to go look at the teacher training materials. You're being purposefully disingenous to say you have to find it in the SOLs. FWIW I am a huge fan of the proposed changes to the social studies SOL and the way they round out VA's history teaching to include more important figures - I wish they'd gone further, in fact. However I'm not a huge fan of DiAngelo or Kendi. For example this website from the VDOE Education Equity group directly quotes Kendi 3x: https://www.virginiaisforlearners.virginia.gov/anti-racism-in-education/ |
Ok, we do decide by electing the school board. The school board has meeting and then makes decisions. You seem to not agree with the school board, but the majority voted for them and they seem to be making decisions in line with the views of the majority of their constituents. |
Where has that happened in VA? |
What an asinine example. Parents want to be heard and be able to influence how their kids are taught by schools. They are not asking for mob rule or individual power to veto book choices. The example you gave would be the other extreme of parental control, which no one is asking for. We are simply rejecting the extreme that McAuliffe and the leftists are pushing for: no parental control. We want something in the rational middle, a school board that responds to parents' demands instead of thinking that they know what's best and should therefore disregard what the parents want 100% of the time. |
I haven't heard that it has. The examples I've seen have been US-based, but in places like CA. However it was very clear that our existing VDOE leadership and many of our existing school board members were operating from the same world view - see the EdEquity page above - and people didn't want these kinds of horror stories to start. To be clear, some of these things are not because, say, Kendi himself would recommend them in Stamped For Kids. They're because teachers are given vague directions on "cultural competency" or "anti-racism" and they end up implementing these ideas. Since all McAuliffe was doing was insisting "CRT isn't taught here" instead of saying, "I hear your concerns and I will make sure that we teach about implicit bias and systemic racism without re-enacting the horror stories of 8 year olds having to talk about all the ways they are vicitimized or privileged on the basis of race," what were concerned voters to do? So far the only SB member I've heard say something about teaching the warts of history without reducing kids to skin color was Megan McLaughlin, who said that she understood privilege to be a complex mass of factors. |
Not PP ...I am not mad but I am amused by the level of "discussion" on this board. I guess articulating your viewpoint is not your strong suit. |