Forum Index
»
Real Estate
Try and keep up... 'white' isn't an identity. Nor would you want to live in a world where it is one. The damage you people do when you're trying to be "correct" is not zero. |
|
Let me explain some basic grammar, since perhaps you didn't learn it at your kids" Waldorf or your own six years at Sarah Lawrence:
Capitalize countries and continents. Hence, someone is Israeli, or Palestinian, or Asian, or European. Capitalize religions. Someone can be Jewish or Episcopalian. Or B'hai. Capitalizing Black, in reference to people who are of African-American or Caribbean heritage, when referring to that specific identity, falls under this domain. But when you *don't* capitalize white, you are not saying it's "the norm." I mean, sure no doubt it was the norm in the UMC suburb that raised you, but not for the rest of us. When you don't capitalize white it becomes a descriptor. Like blond. Like black or brown when you're using the words as a neutral descriptors, which is, by the way, a perfectly acceptable way to use them. When you do capitalize white, you are legitimizing people who believe there is actually a white "race." A white identity. It's really just a hop, skip, and a few bonfires from there to all the stuff you spend a great deal of time insisting you despise. |
|
And yes, I know Washington Post's style guide does it now. Ran that by some friends of mine who are not white or American... And they're horrified.
There's so much damage liberals can do when they think they're being equitable, or worse, "kind." You only have to look at the responses here, the attacks on people who don't share their opinions, or who dare criticize them in any way, to see how thin their veneer of mindfulness is. Takoma Parkers pride themselves on being kind, but they also want to think they're champions, protecting the less fortunate with lawn signs and sustainable shopping. |
Do you live in Takoma Park? You’re kind of Exhibit A for intolerance over issues that real people aren’t even aware of, and didn’t ask for, like “LatinX.” If you’re from TKPK, then OP needs to know this exists here even if the rest of us don’t debate it in school lines or on the sidewalks when we’re walking our dogs. - progressive, almost crunchy person |
Another one who clearly does not live in Takoma Park |
That's not what I said... I didn't say "white" is an identity. But "white" uncapitalized implies that it's the norm against which others are Black, Asian, et cetera. Plenty of folks are concerned about that implication, like the MacArthur Foundation (https://www.macfound.org/press/perspectives/capitalizing-black-and-white-grammatical-justice-and-equity), the Center for Study of Social Policy (https://cssp.org/2020/03/recognizing-race-in-language-why-we-capitalize-black-and-white/), U Chicago and Black scholar Eve Zorn (https://zora.medium.com/im-a-black-scholar-who-studies-race-here-s-why-i-capitalize-white-f94883aa2dd3) and this guy (https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2020/07/22/why-white-should-be-capitalized/). See also the National Association of Black Journalists (https://nabjonline.org/news-media-center/styleguide/). All of which is confusing to the layperson and sort of underscores that the whole debate is taking place at a level that's way above practical concerns about equity and systemic oppression. |
| This is from 2020 people..let it die! |
Golly, well, now the white dude has chimed in to mansplain that I'm just too sensitive. One reason you think so is ... How can I say this? Oh, yeah. It's because people don't hold you to the same standard. You've never had to navigate the toxic soup of TP playdates and PTA meetings. Have you? The examples I brought up weren't ones that actually upset me... they're ones I feel comfortable talking about in a hostile forum full of people who can't stand to hear anything critical about themselves. You think I'd share the actually terrible things that happened? With this kind audience? Hah. Like you, I don't have a problem sharing opinions. It's just one of my opinions is that this lovely, liberal, affluent bubble, much like all lovely liberal affluent bubbles everywhere, is built on the same bland indifference seen in McClean or Greenville--the biggest difference that I see, is residents here also want to be patted on the back for being the right kind of people. A lot. Many of us find that tiresome. I understand why you get along well with them... I wonder if your wife does. |
DP. Good lord, are you a troll pretending to be a TKPKer? |
I'm a White/white woman who lives in TKPK and I think you're too sensitive, too. Your long, angry screeds are just odd. |
PS, I'm also progressive |
|
So, there are Black people and white people these days?
That's what woke is these days? Just straight up denigration of non Blacks? LOL. |
Ikr? The tone deafness from people like this is astonishing, isn't it? "I moved here because I don't want to live a materialistic life in my new build 4k square foot farmhouse with a four-car garage. I just want to send my kids to a good public school. But, you know, only the magnet version. After all, my family has devoted ourselves to the public good and we just want to be mindful? What's the problem?" To be clear, I'm not judging you for your house, or your school choices, or your four-car garage, or your money. I judge you for congratulating yourself for being such a good person, when you are just another person who is trying to justify their inequitable choices. |
And I love the way you have to tell us that. Over and over again. |
Your first mistake was talking about "new builds' in Takoma Park. The historic commission would never in a million years let you raze an existing SFH and do that, unless you're on the outskirts of the historic district and that's not a big part of the city. And four-car garages, that simply doesn't exist here, what are you smoking? You have zero credibility. You certainly don't know Takoma Park. You must be a troll. |