1923, Season 2

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I don't understand why Alex had to die. Did she think they would take the baby and leave him in a cot to die if she went to surgery? Did she think she had to stay with him until morning to nurse him before the milk goats went on sale? Did she just not want to live after those amputations?

I think this was it. She didn’t want the surgery - it wasn’t the life she wanted to live. Which is so sad bc that baby now is motherless.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:So they decided to pretend Elizabeth wasn’t pregnant? She’s leaving for Boston and not a word about the baby?

Yep they probably had the ending written out and stuck her second pregnancy in last minute to drive up the feelz and forgot about continuity. Sloppy!

[Anonymous]

So is there one more episode coming? They said it would be 8? This was only episode 7.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Such a pointless show. I feel like a sucker for watching the whole stupid series and the spin offs. Ugh!

We're going to be suckered again as there is rumored to be another prequel "1944". I'll watch even if I'll be kicking myself.

https://www.msn.com/en-us/entertainment/news/1923-finale-sets-the-stage-for-the-next-yellowstone-prequel-1944/ar-AA1CqDDZ?ocid=sapphireappshare

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:So is there one more episode coming? They said it would be 8? This was only episode 7.

It was episodes 7 and 8 for a two hour show

Why did Spencer blame Whitfield for Alex's death? Admittedly, he got what he deserved but the one thing he could not be blamed for was her death.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:So is there one more episode coming? They said it would be 8? This was only episode 7.

It was episodes 7 and 8 for a two hour show

Why did Spencer blame Whitfield for Alex's death? Admittedly, he got what he deserved but the one thing he could not be blamed for was her death.

He brought all this destruction though. Cara had to write to him to come home because of this “war.” If Spencer had never had to get home, he and Alex would be happily off in Europe together.

[Anonymous]

Cara feeding a premature infant on the feeezing cold porch was ridiculous. As well as telling Elizabeth she will find another man. But zero mention of Elizabeth’s baby.

[Anonymous]

I think the issue with these shows is it's all about Taylor Sheridan and how he sees the world: you have to be hot or badass to be worthy, and that is it. It's even a higher standard for women: a man can be disabled and live on (like Josef in first 1883) but as a woman? No. It's better to die a really stupid death and leave your child motherless than be an amputee. The contrast with Elizabeth was huge: here she was leading this hard life, actually enduring it, shooting a gun to save a man's life, but she wasn't badass enough therefore she wasn't worthy of existing in the Sheridan universe. I feel like he's a stunted, mean little man and it shows. Doubt he will ever grow up or at least set aside his ego and let better writers write his shows. This was his worst to date.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:There was more disgusting sexual violence too. Horrible.

Those scenes were unwatchable. Horrible.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Everyone firing at the ranch for hours then Spencer just comes and saves them all single handed. Lol
+1 on and off the train to pick Alex so easy.

Team Dutton also didn’t seem to have much ammunition stockpiled in their pockets to do so much shooting with rifles. That see very off to me. You didn’t see much reloading either.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I don't understand why Alex had to die. Did she think they would take the baby and leave him in a cot to die if she went to surgery? Did she think she had to stay with him until morning to nurse him before the milk goats went on sale? Did she just not want to live after those amputations?

She basically said that she did not want to live if she would be unable to move freely. There was a comment about having stumps and people comparing her to wild mustangs.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I don't understand why Alex had to die. Did she think they would take the baby and leave him in a cot to die if she went to surgery? Did she think she had to stay with him until morning to nurse him before the milk goats went on sale? Did she just not want to live after those amputations?

She basically said that she did not want to live if she would be unable to move freely. There was a comment about having stumps and people comparing her to wild mustangs.

I bet her son would have preferred his mother alive. She goes through all of that just to give up at the end? Utter bs.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I don't understand why Alex had to die. Did she think they would take the baby and leave him in a cot to die if she went to surgery? Did she think she had to stay with him until morning to nurse him before the milk goats went on sale? Did she just not want to live after those amputations?

She basically said that she did not want to live if she would be unable to move freely. There was a comment about having stumps and people comparing her to wild mustangs.

I bet her son would have preferred his mother alive. She goes through all of that just to give up at the end? Utter bs.

It was beyond dumb. She's a highly intelligent and educated woman, witty and funny and that is her #1 quality, not her legs or her physical ability to do anything. It was a missed opportunity to be mentally strong and see her son grow up. Not to mention that people without legs can actually ride horses and do plenty in life. But she was also delirious and not thinking straight, and the Duttons, dummies that they are, didn't speak up to stop this foolishness. Or perhaps they are just so selfish and superficial they were grossed out by the idea of amputation and happier with her dead than than at the ranch needing accomodations.

[Anonymous]

All five deaths in finale explained.

https://screenrant.com/1923-season-2-finale-major-character-deaths-list/

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I don't understand why Alex had to die. Did she think they would take the baby and leave him in a cot to die if she went to surgery? Did she think she had to stay with him until morning to nurse him before the milk goats went on sale? Did she just not want to live after those amputations?

She basically said that she did not want to live if she would be unable to move freely. There was a comment about having stumps and people comparing her to wild mustangs.

I bet her son would have preferred his mother alive. She goes through all of that just to give up at the end? Utter bs.

It was beyond dumb. She's a highly intelligent and educated woman, witty and funny and that is her #1 quality, not her legs or her physical ability to do anything. It was a missed opportunity to be mentally strong and see her son grow up. Not to mention that people without legs can actually ride horses and do plenty in life. But she was also delirious and not thinking straight, and the Duttons, dummies that they are, didn't speak up to stop this foolishness. Or perhaps they are just so selfish and superficial they were grossed out by the idea of amputation and happier with her dead than than at the ranch needing accomodations.

Yeah I blame the Duttons too. At the end of life, your body and mind are shutting down as part of the dying process. Of course she was ready to just fall asleep in that bed. Shocking that Spencer didn't make even a half-hearted attempt to change her mind. I mean there are plenty of other opportunities to die on that ranch if life becomes too much later on!