Is this really a good trade-off for your tween, though? My mom was like this. She grew up poor, was in 4H, and made most of her own clothes. Then she went to medical school, married my dad who went to law school, and sent us all to UMC public school. My mom thought that in-season clothes and accessories were beyond ridiculous and money was better spent on other things. The thing is, that’s really the only time in your life it really matters. When I was 14, 15, 16, I would have given up almost anything to look like the other kids and wear the kinds of clothes that the other kids had. |
Yes! Although I do kind of like the idea of some kind of suburban version of a junior Carrie Bradshaw with a Stanley cup that matches every outfit and hundreds of pairs of Ugg boots. |
No one cares. |
This. |
| I can afford to go on vacations (nothing crazy though) but my kids prefer to be at home and with their friends. I might as well save my money. We do small local trips. I am saving my money for when I retire and can take all the trips I want. |
I notice you leave off the new cars ($35,000) and expensive wardrobes ($1,000x person, 4 person family) which absolutely do add up to a $5,000 Galapagos trip. |
My mom also grew up poor, raised us UMC, and thought in-season clothes and accessories were wasteful. But she raised her daughters so that we wouldn’t have “given almost anything” to look exactly like 14-15-16 year olds. I don’t think your mom’s failure was in her values, it was not raising you with them. |
These aren’t my adult values. I’m not in eighth grade anymore. I also went to med school and work with opiate addicts. No one gives a crap what I wear now. But in those years it matters. Kids teased me and made fun of me. It was a lot harder to fit in most social groups. No one wants to be the weird kid who looks different in eighth grade. |
It’s normal to want to look like a 14-15-16 year old when you are a 14-16 year old. It’s not some jacked up value system for a teen to want that. |
Its one thing to want to look similar and have certain items. Its something else entirely to want an entire wardrobe of $120 leggings and multiple $50 water bottles just because some moronic parents are stupid enough to do it and their kids are mean enough to brag about it. |
+1 Thank goodness this seems to be an area where the kids are alright; all the tweens in my nieces year are obsessed with thrifting right now, and the Stanley cup thing something embarrassing their moms do. |
| Many people spend money they don't have on constant vacations. I have a relative who travels constantly instead of saving up for his kids' college educations. The day his first kid goes to college, I think he may change his tune. |
Lol at these numbers - “Regular” new cars are running $50k+ these days and $1k per person wardrobe is not buying much if you’re working in person in a corporate office or have a kid in an extracurricular like dance. And good luck with that trip to the Galapagos for only $5k. |
DP, you do realize that the PP’s were literally advocating for your first sentence. “To want to look similar and have certain items.” That’s it. Don’t know why you’re strawmanning about dozens of cups and leggings and and and. There are a few collectors on social media who have 50+ pairs of LLL or Stanleys or whatever, but most regular people have 1-2. Yes, MANY kids do feel left out if their parents have decreed that they can’t have those things simply because THE PARENTS want to use their kids to prove a point. |
I guess. But if you are going to send your kid to a school where most kids have multiple pairs of $120 leggings and $50 water bottles, maybe you could ask your teen if they would prefer to dress like their peers for all four years of high school OR if they would rather make their prom dress from a Butterick and take a four day trip to London with their parents one time. |