Your opinion: boy punching a girl, ok or nay

[Anonymous]

She had it coming.

[Anonymous]

Boy was assaulted - actually sexually assaulted.

Girl was pushed / hit in self defense / response to being assaulted.

Using a nickname isn't bullying. It is immature.

[Anonymous]

Both are at fault with the girl holding a majority of it.

I do not condone men hitting women but if a woman thinks she's man enough to punch a man then she's man enough to get punched back no matter her size.

- a woman

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Nobody should punch another person, ever. Two wrongs don't make a right. Both are equally at fault.

Really? What would you do if you were attacked by someone? Let me guess... Call the police??LOL. You would make a great cop or soldier!

[Anonymous]

The boy was clearly assaulted and actually showed some restraint. You don't get a free pass to assault someone just because you are a girl. If they were adults, she would likely be going to jail. And you never punch someone once. He should have hit her harder with some combinations.

[Anonymous]

My son fought back against a female bully. Guess who was in more trouble?

I don't normally support a reaction like punching. But she had already scratched and punched him. He can defend himself.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Nobody should punch another person, ever. Two wrongs don't make a right. Both are equally at fault.

Really? What would you do if you were attacked by someone? Let me guess... Call the police??LOL. You would make a great cop or soldier!

If I were being attacked or mugged that would be one thing. In a playground situation like this,I tell my kid to walk away if possible, not to escalate.

[Anonymous]

Wow. Times change.

If I had ever hit a girl in this sort of situation, no matter who instigated it, my dad would have kicked my ass something awful. And the worst part would have been the unrelenting grief I would have gotten from my peers! A boy hitting a girl was something that just doesn't happen. You walk away, control the situation, move and avoid getting hit, laugh, whatever. But hit a girl? No chance.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Wow. Times change.

If I had ever hit a girl in this sort of situation, no matter who instigated it, my dad would have kicked my ass something awful. And the worst part would have been the unrelenting grief I would have gotten from my peers! A boy hitting a girl was something that just doesn't happen. You walk away, control the situation, move and avoid getting hit, laugh, whatever. But hit a girl? No chance.

Single moms raising boys is what happened.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Boy was assaulted - actually sexually assaulted.

Girl was pushed / hit in self defense / response to being assaulted.

Using a nickname isn't bullying. It is immature.

How the hell was he sexually assaulted.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Situation: boy and girl are in 6th grade, girl skinny but taller, boy more built but shorter. They are playing and boy calls girl a nickname she doesn't like (nothing bad, think Niki to a Nicole or Sammy to Samantha). Girl tells boy she likes to be called by full name and boy calls girl again by short version of her name. Girl gets angry and scratches boy leaving nail marks. Boy laughs, she gets madder and proceeds to scratch his cheek hard. Boy pushes her off him and tells her not to scratch. Girl gets madder and punches him in his privates. Boy gets mad now and punches her in the nose. Girl crying, nose bleeding. Both moms are mad. My kids saw the whole thing. My oldest said she would have punched the girl also. I'm not sure.

So your son was the one to punch just be honest here.

Tell your son to keep his mouth closed. This time it was a scratches, next time it might be a weapon.

[Anonymous]

Sixth-graders physically attacking each other, ok or nay? Nay.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Boy was assaulted - actually sexually assaulted.

Girl was pushed / hit in self defense / response to being assaulted.

Using a nickname isn't bullying. It is immature.

It absolutely is bullying once you've been asked to stop. I also suspect this isn't the first time this boy has been after this girl.

[Anonymous]

All you moms saying the boy was right and the girl should have just walked away, and he was just teasing her because he likes her should know that you are supporting rape culture.

You are in favor of a girl being conditioned she should accept whatever a guy calls her because it's just words and words don't matter. Today it's a nick name she doesn't like, tomorrow it;s calling her bitch, slut, or refferring to various parts of her anatomy, but it doesn't matter because it's just words.
You are teaching the boy that females are just property to be toyed with and they just have to take it and if they get upset too bad.

These are the lessons that matter, not standing outside in a pussy hat or making sure your son knows about your period or your daughter takes enough STEM classes, and that neither of them see Cinderella.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Boy was assaulted - actually sexually assaulted.

Girl was pushed / hit in self defense / response to being assaulted.

Using a nickname isn't bullying. It is immature.

It absolutely is bullying once you've been asked to stop. I also suspect this isn't the first time this boy has been after this girl.

No it isn't. Bullying has to be sustained over time. This was one tiff between two kids.

Labeling every little infraction as bullying does a major disservice to all who are actually bullied and makes it harder for us to address the problem.

This started as a boy being obnoxious.

As for who was right: this boy needs to learn that society judges his hit much more harshly than her physical actions and he should walk away. If I were his mom, there would be a talking to, but not a big punishment.