Correct was like that but if you think about it. It’s ironic that some immigrant families still enroll their children in after-school and weekend tutoring programs here in the U.S.. Speaking as an Asian who dislikes grind culture, it’s almost amusing to see practices I once considered mind-killing practices now taking hold in the U.S. Essentially there is no escape for these poor children. |
maybe they want their kids to retain ties to language and culture. why is that a bad thing? White liberals sending their kids to mandarin or spanish immersion school but somehow it’s bad for immigrant families to send their kids to weekend heritage language/culture schools? Russians, French, Germans, Muslims; all immigrants do this if they settle in a place that has large enough of an ethnic community to support it. |
If you believe it is enriching to your family, no one will stop you. No reason to seek validation or outright generalize every immigrant or race. People can see in their eyes who's doing what |
If elite colleges stop looking at these enriching "EC", sports, math competition, foreign languages, your community probably will drop it in no time. |
|
i highly doubt anyone is sending their kids to weekend heritage language schools
because it “looks good” for college. If anything, the time required is a detriment to actually pursuing other EC activities that can be a bona fide admissions hook, like travel sports. |
| 25% pell grant. top 3 strongest freshman class by test score and class rank. they are also going test required next year and have no legacy admissions. optimizing for true merit |
https://hub.jhu.edu/2025/12/01/johns-hopkins-demographic-makeup-class-of-2029/ |
Or math classes right? otherwise how can they be genius
|
Seriously? My Indian kid (I count as Asian) spent 10 minutes a day on homework until Calc BC. That was only because the teacher was awful. Kid was admitted to multiple HYPSM btw — mostly because of LORs. |
lol there are true intelligent people that some grinding people would never understand |
+1 Agree that most kids probably do competitions for getting into college. But we do need to blame colleges for that. All the former AOs who became consultants and told kids to win competitions! We also need colleges to provide great advising for students who want to contribute to society in meaningful ways. I don’t think HYPSM do this well at all. |
No, JHU uses holistic admissions. SFFA revealed that Aisan applicants are also better on average to white applicants on non-testing measures like extracurricular activity. |
**the ones who are applying to Harvard. |
Yes, it's a common stereotype that seems to play out in the fact that they have better test scores and higher levels of extracurricular achievement accounting for income, hence their overrepresentation at top colleges. This outperformance is despite the fact that only East Asians hold a noticeable intelligence advantage over whites, yet Asians other than East Asians also outperform whites: https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.1406402111#:~:text=All%20Asian%20ethnic%20groups%20outperform,greater%20academic%20effort%20than%20whites. |
Yeah, Aisan applicants are better to white applicants on any activity.
|