Good Lord. Educate yourself. Not gonna do it for you. |
Is it a mental illness? No. Is it an unhealthy manipulative behavior and an indicator of dysfunction? Absolutely. Not hard to get information on this and I’d you are seeing a therapist and being honest with them then surprised you haven’t learned more about this. |
She was unkind because she didn't share personal information with you? If that's your attitude then I think she made the right call. |
And I think you're too quick to jump onto the label. There is a difference between people pleasing and people with big hearts or generous spirits. Just because someone values pleasing others doesn't mean that they are dysfunctional or unhealthy. The difference is that a people pleaser acts out of fear while a big heart person acts out of knowing what makes them happy and how they achieve gratification. So unless you know a lot more about this person whom you are pseudo-diagnosing, I would say that you're probably wrong because you're so quick to label that you're not looking at any other factors. |
Right. Manipulation to control outcomes = people pleasing. |
|
I come from a moderately functional family and while my family has issues, we thankfully did not have very large ones such as alcoholism, physical or verbal abuse or mental illness.
The effect of this on me was two-pronged: on one hand I was wary of people with obvious dysfunction as I had a theoretical understanding of how scary such situations can be and I did not want to be sucked in the world of toxicity and dysfunction. I was scared of alcoholics and obviously abusive people as no one had treated me poorly in my immediate family. So, a part of me did judge them and not want to associate with them as I did not want to be hurt or drawn in. On the other hand, my easy and loving family life made me very naive as to the workings of true evil and dysfunction. I also had no skills to decipher between good genuine people versus broken dangerous people such as narcissists or personality disorders. I was love bombed and I married my current narcissi tic husband. I truly had NO idea what I was dealing with as I had no experience in determining his intentions. |
| Like PP I also come from a fairly functional family and ended up with a DH who love bombed. What I think of all this so-called dysfunction now, in my 50s, is that I completely avoid anyone claiming to be a "victim". I've learned that the perpetual victims are people with millions of issues creating their own problems. They'll never work through anything and will simply suck you dry with their endless complaining. Their families have red flags all over that they hide until you're married and with kids. I've also found out that it's not my job to fix other people. I'm not their therapist or psychologist. I think dysfunctional people love attaching themselves to functional people and then running them to the ground. The only way not to end up being ran to the ground is to not engage and/or disappear, which is why the more-or-less functional people avoid the dysfunctional like a plague. |
| I think people who grew up with parents like Emily Gilmore and her mother in law, just think this is the way to be in their circle and they honestly just aren't smart enough to learn how to deal with problems not having many so they resort to cruel behavior as a way of saying others have cooties and they don't. Because they are afraid of having to deal with problems they don't know how to deal with. |
it’s not drama to the person experiencing it—it’s their normal life and the only way they know to be, usually. |
This. Often there is too much drama, chaos, and neediness, plus misdirected anger. -child of 2 alcoholics |
I agree with this post and the post above listing four (very good) reasons for an empathy deficit. It is really hard for people from functional families to understand the damage that dysfunctional families do to people. My husband comes from a somewhat dysfunctional family, but after he experienced my parents and sister’s behavior (they of course lashed out at him) he was like “they’re insane.” It really took his shock at their behavior, his family’s shock at their behavior, and our Rabbi’s shock at their behavior leading up to our wedding to make me realize that the level of aggression and contempt I experienced for my entire life was not only not normal, it was toxic and intolerable. Going low/no contact and having firm boundaries has been so healthy for me. People with normal families don’t get that though. They’re like “call them up and talk it out.” They don’t understand that some people thrive of gaslighting, triangulation, and enmeshment. You can’t just sort things out with someone who thrives on the chaos they create. They will constantly suck you back in and drain you of your life force. |
Not really. I avoid talking about my family with pretty much everyone. I don’t need to. Most close friends know and my husband and kids know, so I’m not rehashing with anyone. If someone asks about my family I’ll say I’m not close to my sister and I don’t even mention my father. I talk about my mom in general terms because we see her a 5-7 times a year, but we’re not emotionally close. |
See, this is a statement of judgment and maybe even of contempt. Others should not have to feel bad for not going through what you went through. And remember, people can sense contempt even through smiles and "niceness", it always comes out in little passive aggressive remarks like the bolded above. |
|
I think about random groups of people as much as I think about the wheat industry: I don’t. Between work and parenting, I have so many balls to juggle that I could do nothing else and still not have enough time for those two things.
So the only other things I spend time on involve recharging: spending time with friends and family. Draining people don’t make good friends and family. A person can’t recharge with a draining person. So it’s not that I judge people, it’s more that I’m looking for specific qualities. |
But that has nothing to do with anyone else. Some people like drama, many people do not. Change is possible. https://adultchildren.org/wp-content/uploads/Literature/The_Problem_EN-US_A4.pdf https://adultchildren.org/wp-content/uploads/Literature/The_Laundry_List_EN-US_A4.pdf https://adultchildren.org/wp-content/uploads/Literature/The_Other_Laundry_List_EN-US_A4.pdf https://adultchildren.org/wp-content/uploads/Literature/The_ACA_Promises_EN-US_A4.pdf https://www.amazon.com/Loving-Parent-Guidebook-Softcover-Spiralbound/dp/1944840141/ |