Georgetown, CMU, ND, UVA definitely have to be there over Barnard. Tufts is like the worst of the list. probably needs to get removed. |
Question becomes what happened to Trinity and HM ? They have such an academic rigor reputation but now being the lowest 2 among all TTs. |
UVA isn't over Texas or USC. the others probably correct. B and T probably need to go. |
I think you're missing her point. Adding more schools increases every school's %, but what's the point, to get everyone to 100%? The ranking doesn't really move. |
Keep expanding the list until every high school gets 100%. In terms of how competitive these colleges are, only two cutoff matter: The first is HYPMS. The second is T20 + T10 lacs. |
thanks for sharing. agree with others on the list being a bit too broad. the idea was to capture the very good schools - georgetown, the top state schools, CMU, ND. but in generally really good. surprised how poor some of the bottom schools did. hard to see value attending the bottom 5 unless $$ isn't an issue. Brearley should be 1 - i think Spence benefited from Barnard, Tufts. if the ranking ever gets cleaned up, my guess is Spence falls to 2. Riverdale is TT. I really do believe it. I think the data shows that it belongs. Nightingale, CGPS punch above their reputation (academic wise). Trinity poor results are due (in my opinion) to the sibling policy. I'd guess many of the weaker results are from situations where older DC is a superstar. Overall, the girls schools are pretty remarkable across the board for their college results. I wonder if it's due to bringing in superstars in 9th grade and letting some weaker kids transfer. |
what is important to us is different than many others here. In fact, what we looked at was how good the school's broad placement was. Which included even more schools - like NYU for example. We ended up being happy with what many consider a 3T school given how high of a percentage fell into our "broadly good school". |
|
I dont know what it's like coming out of public in nyc, but coming out of private, you can be in the bottom 25% of the class and get into Tufts.
And maybe this is the value in private? It puts in a bottom. You may not be going to HYP but you won't end up at (insert a college ranked 100 ) |
I said T20 + WASP. getting into Carleton is not harder than, say, BC. which is not even a T20. |
A friend of mine has a daughter that grinded it out in a upper middle class nyc suburb. all sorts of EC. 4.0 GPA. good ACT score. Tufts was the best school she got into. (and loves it, which is important!). tough 4 years. versus being middle of the pack at a 2T school and getting into Tufts or being in the bottom quartile at a TT and getting into Tufts. the optionality of a better college with the "floor" of tufts is worth $300k to me if the alternative is a miserable 4 years fighting for each .01 on GPA at a top suburban school. Others make a different choice. |
Sibling policy for Trinity. |
Are we using last year’s T20 or this year’s? There are a lot more than 20 schools in this year’s T20. Some of them are not that competitive out of NYC schools. |
Depends on what you do with the $300k from my experience. Many Ivy grads have to grind well into their 40's to make it worth it. Not everyone is going to reach the top of the pyramid in their field. |
The other side of that coin, though, is that when you’re at one of these schools (I’m a trin grad, kids at dalton), you’re not competing with other schools. Your competition is almost solely internal: your extremely competitive, remarkably gifted (and sometimes extraordinarily well-connected) classmates. So, while the floor may be higher (it truly is, in my grad year, mid students with b’s and c’s got into michigan and emory, etc.), the bar to clear for admissions to top colleges is also significantly higher, which leads to an ungodly amount of stress and pressure. A lot of kids who, had the gone to a public school and thrived, could have potentially gotten into ivy+ rather than some of the places they ended up. These are the tradeoffs. I really did not enjoy school so much, however I did adore my college experience. |
it's just over 5% of our net worth (for two kids to private high school). so while theoretically i understand the save $300k and put it into the stock market and give the kids $1mm when they graduate (although i think the math is less than $1mm but i get your point) - in reality that's not how it works for the majority of people putting their kids in private school. do we love writing the $150k a check. Nope. but it's a one time (actually 4x) event. we move on. it's not really changing our lifestyle either way. we don't really spend our earnings completely anyway. and it's the floor of Tufts that was the discussion, the Ivy potentially - that was just the cherry on top if it happened to be the case. |