I agree with this. The two top names we are considering for our second DD have both been called "old lady" names on DCUM and they both happen to be mine or DH's grandmother's name. We'll still probably use one of them
|
| So those with Lucys, are they just Lucy or is it short for Lucille or Lucia? Just curious because I haven't heard any Lucilles or Lucias. |
|
Interesting about that, because it's true that we have named our son (middle name) after DH's great grandpa and it's becoming pretty popular. Did the same with daughter's middle name and ditto. I guess that makes sense tho - you want to honor your family and those names are not around enough to have connotations so we make new ones.
For our group, it's definitely been much of the same: Girls: Grace, Isabelle, Olivia, Harper Boys: Elijah, Jack, Lucas (older now), Noah, Jacob |
|
Will someone please explain me what's so bad about picking a popular name?
Do you really think nobody will ever move away? Some names are popular here, others are popular somewhere else... in the end they'll all get mixed up. My name, DD's name and DH's name are in this popularity list and we were all 3 born in 3 different countries. What's the fuss all about? I just don't get it. |
|
I don't see anything wrong with popular names, although I think what parents are trying to avoid is their little Sophia having to be referred to as Sophia K., while her friend is Sophia H. and their other classmate is Sofia R. Didn't many of us grow up in the era of having 4 Jennifers/Jenny's in our classes? I sure did.
However, I also think that popular names are popular because they are, mostly, nice, good names. So you have to balance a name that you like and is nice with how many other kids your child might encounter with the same name. Which is why so many people try to find a name that's nice and good and recognizable but ISN'T so popular. |
I had an insanely popular name growing up and I hated it. Others will say it didn't bother them at all. If you don't mind your child being one of 6 Sophia's in her class, then go for it and name your daughter Sophia (a name I really like, by the way). To each his own. |
| OK - so thinking of my mom's group of friends we have a Louise, Maryanne, Leslie, Diane, Berta (yikes!), Patricia and Amelia. I guess Amelia will always be around, but I don't know if I'm ready for the rest. |
I think it's just a matter of preference, and I agree: to each his own. Here's the best analogy I can come up with: A classic name is like a classic piece of clothing. Some people like to fill their wardrobe with classic pieces that will never go out of style. So names like William or Elizabeth are the equivalent of a simple black cashmere sweater, for example. But some people might prefer to go to specialty stores to ensure they have clothes that stand out and say a little bit more about their personalities. You certainly don't want to do go to all this effort to find a unique sweater only to have your neighbor (or multiple neighbors) show up wearing the same one. It totally defeats the purpose. Sure, you don't want to dress like a total freak (think: Apple), but you still don't want to feel like a sheep, or worse, a yuppy. |
Pick what you like and what 'goes' with your last name. Don't forget the last name when picking out the first! We like 'traditional' names and tend to name after family members....so if they are on anyone's popular list..I could give a rat's a** .
I'd be careful with 'trendy' names that have no established name history...those are the first to become the trailer park names or to switch to the other gender. |
|
I read in one of my baby names books that to our babies' generation, Linda would probably sound like a very pretty and unique name. When I thought about it--and removed from my mind all the Lindas I knew who I wasn't so found of--I had to agree. It's a pretty name. Linda...Sophia...they're not all that different without the connotations.
And sorry if your name is Linda. My name isn't very current either.
|
|
PP, my mom is Amelia, and she hated her name growing up, so much that she still goes by a rather silly diminutive. When the current crop of Amelias sprouted, she was terribly confused. Couldn't believe that such an antique of a name was making a comeback.
Let's see... mom's generation's names... Sue, Lynn(ette), Pat/Patty/Patricia, Carol, Linda, Barbara, Janet, Valerie... I think all those are pretty safe for the moment! |
Well there you go. I have my future daughter's name picked out now: Berta. Guaranteed to be the only one! |
|
girls: Sophia/Sophie, Lucy, Lilly, Isabella, Nora, Ava, Ella, Stella, Mia/Lia.
boys: Max, Jack, Joe. I met two 1 year old Joe's on the playground yesterday alone -- one short for Josiah, one short for Joseph. |
i like it a lot - i only know one Naomi and she's 8. |
We have 4 close friends with daughters named Lucy: one in our NW DC neighborhood, one in NoVa, one in Bethesda, and one in Chicago. |