You’re alienating potential allies when you pretend the incident had nothing to do with APS policy. If a man reported Kenneth Richard Cox was being a creep in the men’s room it would have been addressed. However, since she declared herself a woman, the pool staff was afraid to do anything when women reported her. |
Exactly. And we shouldn’t discount the very real fear that people in Arlington have that if they even suggest that maybe there’s a middle ground they could have their livelihoods threatened via online mobs. |
|
+1000 |
The issue is not elementary schools, it’s middle and high schools. |
Replies in this thread should tell you how this issue is going to go. APS et al. are going to lose in court, badly, because even the courts now understand the insanity of these policies. There's a decent chance the 4th circuit reverses itself just to prevent SCOTUS from making a more sweeping and durable precedent (and to spare themselves the embarrassment). This is an 80/20 issue that even the Gen-z high schoolers are turning against. NOVA is so far out over its skis on this and it's a shame. The admins would rather stick their thumbs in the eye of the administration because it costs them nothing, but losing federal funds is going to hurt a lot more students.
You could have just let a half-dozen kids use the single-shot adult bathrooms/changing areas on an informal basis, and this would have been a total non-issue. But that wasn't enough. Just like with school re-opening, just like with masking, you people insist on turning school administrators into avatars for your own revenge fantasies against national political figures. It's a pipe dream. You're going to lose, and rather than lose gracefully you're going to lose as ugly as possible, and somehow each time it happens you manage to pick an issue to lose ugly on that's even dumber and less popular. The funds will get cut off, the school year will be disrupted, and students will bear the brunt of it, and you and the school administrations are going to pat themselves on the back, feel good about yourselves, nominate the Superintendent for a few more awards, while claiming you bear none of the blame for the damage that this exceedingly stupid fight caused. No one seriously thinks the schools are going to win this. You have to deal with reality as you find it, not as you wish it would be. |
Say that last sentence again louder for the people in the back. The private sector has already figured this out. The reason so many companies are bending the knee (Apple, Paramount, AMD, etc...) is because it's a simple calculation - pay some millions now to save billions worth of headache later. And banking on all of this dumb-assery passing in 3.5 years. APS would do well to take a lesson here - take the L now, which costs very little (but not nothing! it's still gross what the admin is doing), in order to save a much larger sum being taken away later on. tl;dr - utilitarianism |
I agree with you. I also worry about unintended consequences. How many trans kids fall into other vulnerable categories (SPED, ELL, FRL) that will be impacted by cuts in funding? Is this setting a precedent that we don't follow certain federal policies the board deems unacceptable? That might be fine now but what if the makeup of the board shifts and they decide to go rogue? |
Just remember APS’ general counsel went to the worst law school in the nation |
+1 |
I really wish APS wasn’t doing this. I hate Trump but the courts are pretty conservative right now and these lawsuits create risk of bad decisions. I think the left has to be more strategic from both a political and legal standpoint. |
Yeah, I don’t understand why they can’t issue a statement denouncing the administration, affirming their commitment to offering unisex, single stall bathroom/changing rooms for students who need them while acknowledging that they can’t disadvantage many students by losing federal funding. |
What is this referring to? |
Which one? |
Whittier. It actually closed down because it could not maintain accreditation. A million lawyers in Arlington and APS couldn’t find anyone better? |