I just saw it tonight. My husband thinks Cap didn’t actually marry Peggy. He thinks Cap went back for his dance and bowed out like a gentleman because he always does the right thing and didn’t want to mess with the past/future. |
I'm pretty sure I would have liked it less had I not been sitting next to my 12Yo. He was enthralled and dancing in his seat. I watched him more than the movie. Priceless. |
As far as Gamora,
Don’t you think because she came thru the time portal with Thanos then when Tony snapped and all those who came thru disappeared, then she was included too? |
They explained all of this in the movie when they were discussing how time travel worked, especially in the scene with Dr. Strange and the ancient one in New York and in the big scene where they all discuss how time travel works.
Here is what I think happened: 1) Cap went back in time to 1945 and lived his whole life with Peggy. This created a branching universe that doesn't lead back to the present time where they sent captain america back in time. 2) In this alternate universe, when the timeline got to 2014 or whatever in New York, he replaced the infinity stone that he had (he kept it this whole time) immediately after the avengers stole it, so that their timeline would have it for protection against bad guys. 3) Once Peggy died and he was an old man, he warped back to the current timeline / universe, but he was old, because he had lived his entire life out in an alternate universe where he didn't go into the ice and he married Peggy. There are an infinite number of realities and timelines. You can bring things from one reality and/or timeline into another, but you can't change something once it has happened in that timeline. If you do, you just branch it off into another timeline/reality. This is why black widow is still dead. Nothing they can do can change that. The best they could do would be to pull a living black widow from another timeline into their timeline, similar to what happened with Gamora or Thanos. This also explains how even when they pulled thanos from the past into their timeline, everything he had already done like snapped the world, wasn't undone. It also explains why they couldn't just go and kill thanos when he was a baby, as that wouldn't fix anything, it would just spawn another alternate universe/timeline. |
Congratulations to Endgame for hitting #1 in all time worldwide box office!
I suspect that Endgame will at least get a nomination for Best Picture if not the win a la Return of the King - more for a seeing perhaps the most ambitious project in cinematic history through to an audience and critical pleasing conclusion. (IIRC only Hulk got below 70% on Rotten Tomatoes.) So - a re-release at which it'll get another few million to pad the results, but I suspect Avatar 2 will see a re-release of the OG Avatar which might put the Na'vi back on top. I suspect the title will switch back and forth like some of the Maryland-D**e basketball games of old (I'm a UVA fan but hate that school in Durham as much as any good Terrapin.)
Following up my own post (and thank you to my fan ![]() Black Widow prequel - coming out May 2020 And yes the Eternals will be appearing! - November 2020 Shang-Chi aka break all Chinese box office records and apologizing for turning an actual Asian character into a White woman - My 45th birthday! - February 2021 Doctor Strange sequel - May 2021 - journey into horror (!) along with Scarlet Witch. Thor: Love and Thunder - November 2021 (anti-SJWs, assemble!) Of course the actual canon does have the actual freaking hammer saying: "Whosoever holds this hammer, if he be worthy, shall possess the power of Thor." so this might end up being an issue only the truest ignorami care about, sort of like Rue being Black in The Hunger Games. I'm starting to wonder if this will be some sort of romantic comedy with extra asskicking, given past wishes for the MCU to delve into other genres. I guessed right about the Eternals being the next set of villains (or heroes?) pulling all the strings, although the Evil Mastermind of Phases 4-5 or 4-6 won't be revealed just yet. Captain Marvel 2, Guardians 3, and Black Panther 2 were confirmed - also a Blade reboot. Of course, Natalie Portman being Thor means the Asgardians of the Galaxy will (should?) happen, and the soundtrack will compete with Wonder Woman 1984 for true awesomeness. Instead of Kamala Khan being Captain Marvel we see Natalie Portman being the target of anti-SJW rage. But no Ant-Man and it looks like the GLA movie will be only a faint glimmer of hope in my eyes. I can't see Ant-Man going away entirely - he'll show up in the comic relief movies. I was wrong about Hulk. Black Widow or Thor may yet feature large numbers of womenfolk. I suspect it's too late to shoehorn more women into Black Widow, but Thor may deliver on this promise. Guardians/GLA mashup was more a wish than a prediction. Presence of an Eternals movie does not guarantee an Deviants evil mastermind. Fantastic Four are getting integrated (no surprise) but the X Men getting integrated into the MCU comes as a bit of a surprise. You'll need a few years to get folks to forget the Fox movies, though. |
Not digging Natalie Portman as Thor. She’s a wonderful actress, but too waif-like. As some who’s had a small frame their entire life, there’s no way she gets jacked enough to look credible. They better go with the cancer storyline. |