| She’s from Queen’s. How else is she “supposed” to speak? If her parents are immigrants she learned English from her friends! This is so dumb and frankly racist against Asians. |
pp needs canceled. |
LOL what is this crap. This is like when one non-white person is racist against another non-white person and 100% of the time the media spins it as being white people's fault. I understand systemic racism, but the mental gymnastics in the olympics of suffering is really starting to make me crazy. |
Actually the statement that the Black and Indigenous experiences shape the experiences of other people of color is unequivocally true. It is also true that we have different experiences and all are valid. The third statement is just divisive and demeaning. |
|
OTOH, I get how people might be mad that she’s making $ on a persona that uses typical AAVE and urban ‘tropes.’ OTOH, I have no idea if that’s her ‘lived experience’ or whatever, or what’s an act. Nor do I really care since it’s not my lane.
I’m sure OP is white (or, at least, not black) and needs to sit out this fight. My daughter’s teacher is Nigerian. Like many other posters, both my kids go to a very diverse school and bring home language and terms and pronunciations that are foreign to me. I’m not about to teach my daughter how to pronounce things ‘correctly,’ because that’s hugely problematic. Her teacher’s way of speaking is correct! If people say she’s ‘appropriating’ something I would be annoyed |
BIPOC absolutely includes Asians. Asians are one of the POC groups in BIPOC. |
It's also racist to assume her immigrant parents were incapable of influencing how she speaks English. |
|
I think the criticism is focused on the fact that it isn't how she normally speaks (as some are suggesting, based on her growing up in Queens). It is because in her comedy roles only, she adopts an exaggerated persona that some feel is inherently mocking of black culture in it's delivery. She doesn't speak that way in other non comedic contexts. It would be like someone adopting an exaggerated accent of an immigrant group for their comedy routine.
To be clear, i don't have an opinion whether this is a problem, I'm just conveying what I've read in terms of other's criticism. |
Isn’t she acting like countless Asians from queens rather than mocking black people? Key word: acting. |
I have no idea, that's one reason why I don't have an opinion on this. |
You can say it all you want. You can come up with a ‘project’ and make up a new acronym, wear it in your sleeve and shout it from the rooftops. Does not make it true. |
This sneer was clearly written by a person who has no idea about the lived experience of children of immigrants in America. |
+1000000 |
Agree. |
Please back up this statement with evidence. If it is unequivocally true, there must be a vast evidence base. |