How to tell TX and FL officials to relocate migrants to here in Montgomery?

[Anonymous]

But they should all go to Chevy Chase and Bethesda. That is A-OK with me. How many empty bedrooms and basements are there in these towns, being air conditioned, a total waste. Send them on up.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:DC resident here and I’ll see what our Mayor can do to bus them to your County.

That’s actually what has been happening. DC working with MD based groups to move the migrants to MD and out of the city.

Yes, our government has been asking for them and getting them, and now we are having trouble paying for them.

Here's a good overview from last year

https://montgomerycountymd.granicus.com/MetaViewer.php?view_id=169&clip_id=17067&meta_id=168560

A bit misleading. MoCo is not accepting all transfers from DC.

From that memo:

Nuclear families with children who entered the U.S. after April 2022 and
can validate their A-number (asylum/alien) are submitted for eligibility determination to the DC
Office of Migrant Services. Single men and women are directly directed to shelters in DC, while
extended families (including, for example, grandparents, aunts, and children over 24 years old)
are referred to the Montgomery County Respite Center to prevent family separation.

Also, these folks coming to MoCo have their A number, which I assume, means that they had their cases heard by a judge.

You can get into the weeds all you want, but what is undeniably true is that DC is trying to pull a TX and bus the migrants to MD.

? I didn't deny that, but it's families and children only, not all.

DC are trying to send all. Montgomery County is only agreeing to accept families with children.

That is the dumbest policy I have heard of from MOCO (in a long time) has a lot of stupid ideas. Why would we only agree to accept the most costly migrants that are going to be a drain on county finances. Children and elderly people don't work or pay taxes to MOCO. So they won't be self-sufficient and MOCO will also need to provide social services for them. Around 64% of school funding is derived from local tax revenue. Every migrant child costs the county around $13,300 a year for schooling.

DC should deal with its own migrant issue and Moco shouldn’t be agreeing to take any.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:It appears that no matter what any president (or governor) does to try to stop the flow of migrants it works at first but eventually the numbers increase again. That is because whatever they encounter on their trip to the border and whatever they encounter once they get there or into the US is not worse than the life they are trying to leave. People in the US who don't understand this and appear to think they are coming here to ruin our lives are very ignorant and entitled.

I do understand their lives suck down there. That does not mean they get to break the law to come here.

Simple concept. Not so simple if it's you and your family, children, who are suffering and in danger. Hardly anybody in the US knows what that is like. What would you do if it were you? Wait around for years or maybe never for a legal chance at a better life?

Not our problem, the penalties for illegal immigration need to be very strict to discourage other people from attempting it. They should be deported and receive a lifetime ban from immigrating to the US, if they are caught crossing the border outside a legal port of entry. We cannot save the entire world from unfortunate circumstances and wanting a higher paying job is not a valid reason to move the US. I don't think they are trying to ruin our lives, but the US cannot take millions of fake asylum seekers every year. This is completely unworkable and it creates a significant burden for US taxpayers. You are ridiculous, I am not being entitled I am having a discussion about out current (dysfunctional) immigration policy. If anything the entitled people are the ones moving here illegally that expect the US government to give them housing and food (covered by US taxpayers).

What about the ones coming here who want to work, pay their own way, pay taxes, live without fear, have decent schools for their kids and opportunities to live a decent life and have a future? You are ridiculous if you believe the right wing brainwashing that tells you most immigrants just want to live off the government.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:It appears that no matter what any president (or governor) does to try to stop the flow of migrants it works at first but eventually the numbers increase again. That is because whatever they encounter on their trip to the border and whatever they encounter once they get there or into the US is not worse than the life they are trying to leave. People in the US who don't understand this and appear to think they are coming here to ruin our lives are very ignorant and entitled.

It really doesn't matter "why" people are coming here. That shouldn't be their choice.

Easy for you to say due to your fortunate accident of birth.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Ok troll.

100% sincere, not a troll. I live in Montgomery myself (Chevy Chase View, specifically) and I know that many of my immediate neighbors and most people in the county support immigrants and hate what TX and FL is doing to them. So we need to lobby those officials in TX and FL to send them here, where they receive the help they need.

Most people in the County supporting immigrants does not mean that we want to pay yet higher taxes for even more social services for immigrants. Look, certain schools in MoCo are now largely focused on bringing up the bottom (typically the immigrants from Central America, many who are illiterate in their native tongues). I moved to MoCo for the schools, yet ended up having to pay for private, at extreme cost, to simply insure that my kids got some teacher attention.

Speak for yourself. I would happily pay higher taxes for programs that brought more migrants here as took care of them. And I support raising your taxes too, because I and those who care about these people shouldn’t have to do it alone. You can afford to chip in some more, too.

With just what you’re spending on a private each year ((to keep your precious little darlings away from brown children)) you could help dozens of people from other countries who came here with nothing. That’s how much your taxes should be raised - by whatever you’re paying in tuition each year. You can clearly afford it.

I would prefer that money to go into a fund for reparations rather than people who have no ties here and often break laws along the way. Not to mention we don't have any background info on these people or medical histories.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:It appears that no matter what any president (or governor) does to try to stop the flow of migrants it works at first but eventually the numbers increase again. That is because whatever they encounter on their trip to the border and whatever they encounter once they get there or into the US is not worse than the life they are trying to leave. People in the US who don't understand this and appear to think they are coming here to ruin our lives are very ignorant and entitled.

I do understand their lives suck down there. That does not mean they get to break the law to come here.

Simple concept. Not so simple if it's you and your family, children, who are suffering and in danger. Hardly anybody in the US knows what that is like. What would you do if it were you? Wait around for years or maybe never for a legal chance at a better life?

NP here and I totally get this and I don’t blame any migrant on a personal level for trying to do whatever they can for their family. I’m sure in their shoes I’d do the same thing.

However immigration is just a bandaid to a much bigger issue of certain countries being run by drug lords. We can keep letting people into our country in theory, but then there will just be new children being born there and new arrivals fleeing this same violence. So we’re forever treating the symptom of the violence and 100 years from now our grandkids will still be having the same immigration debates.

Why can’t more be done to help these people fight back and get actual leadership that isn’t corrupt?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:It appears that no matter what any president (or governor) does to try to stop the flow of migrants it works at first but eventually the numbers increase again. That is because whatever they encounter on their trip to the border and whatever they encounter once they get there or into the US is not worse than the life they are trying to leave. People in the US who don't understand this and appear to think they are coming here to ruin our lives are very ignorant and entitled.

I do understand their lives suck down there. That does not mean they get to break the law to come here.

Simple concept. Not so simple if it's you and your family, children, who are suffering and in danger. Hardly anybody in the US knows what that is like. What would you do if it were you? Wait around for years or maybe never for a legal chance at a better life?

Not our problem, the penalties for illegal immigration need to be very strict to discourage other people from attempting it. They should be deported and receive a lifetime ban from immigrating to the US, if they are caught crossing the border outside a legal port of entry. We cannot save the entire world from unfortunate circumstances and wanting a higher paying job is not a valid reason to move the US. I don't think they are trying to ruin our lives, but the US cannot take millions of fake asylum seekers every year. This is completely unworkable and it creates a significant burden for US taxpayers. You are ridiculous, I am not being entitled I am having a discussion about out current (dysfunctional) immigration policy. If anything the entitled people are the ones moving here illegally that expect the US government to give them housing and food (covered by US taxpayers).

What about the ones coming here who want to work, pay their own way, pay taxes, live without fear, have decent schools for their kids and opportunities to live a decent life and have a future? You are ridiculous if you believe the right wing brainwashing that tells you most immigrants just want to live off the government.

So you think we should allow effectively unlimited immigration and let 10M+ people move here annually? I am not against immigration, but there needs to be a reasonable limit and severe consequences for breaking immigration laws.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:It appears that no matter what any president (or governor) does to try to stop the flow of migrants it works at first but eventually the numbers increase again. That is because whatever they encounter on their trip to the border and whatever they encounter once they get there or into the US is not worse than the life they are trying to leave. People in the US who don't understand this and appear to think they are coming here to ruin our lives are very ignorant and entitled.

I do understand their lives suck down there. That does not mean they get to break the law to come here.

Simple concept. Not so simple if it's you and your family, children, who are suffering and in danger. Hardly anybody in the US knows what that is like. What would you do if it were you? Wait around for years or maybe never for a legal chance at a better life?

NP here and I totally get this and I don’t blame any migrant on a personal level for trying to do whatever they can for their family. I’m sure in their shoes I’d do the same thing.

However immigration is just a bandaid to a much bigger issue of certain countries being run by drug lords. We can keep letting people into our country in theory, but then there will just be new children being born there and new arrivals fleeing this same violence. So we’re forever treating the symptom of the violence and 100 years from now our grandkids will still be having the same immigration debates.

Why can’t more be done to help these people fight back and get actual leadership that isn’t corrupt?

US has provided those countries a ton of aid, but the government is corrupt and/or the drug lords are stronger. Look at how the mayors in MX are gunned down. There's a news story of this happening just this past week.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:It appears that no matter what any president (or governor) does to try to stop the flow of migrants it works at first but eventually the numbers increase again. That is because whatever they encounter on their trip to the border and whatever they encounter once they get there or into the US is not worse than the life they are trying to leave. People in the US who don't understand this and appear to think they are coming here to ruin our lives are very ignorant and entitled.

I do understand their lives suck down there. That does not mean they get to break the law to come here.

Simple concept. Not so simple if it's you and your family, children, who are suffering and in danger. Hardly anybody in the US knows what that is like. What would you do if it were you? Wait around for years or maybe never for a legal chance at a better life?

NP here and I totally get this and I don’t blame any migrant on a personal level for trying to do whatever they can for their family. I’m sure in their shoes I’d do the same thing.

However immigration is just a bandaid to a much bigger issue of certain countries being run by drug lords. We can keep letting people into our country in theory, but then there will just be new children being born there and new arrivals fleeing this same violence. So we’re forever treating the symptom of the violence and 100 years from now our grandkids will still be having the same immigration debates.

Why can’t more be done to help these people fight back and get actual leadership that isn’t corrupt?

Good luck trying to repair the cultural and political rot that was Spanish colonialism. You might as well try to reverse the earth’s magnetic field. Every former Spanish colony if different degrees of failed state. And Spain is barely functional itself.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Ok troll.

100% sincere, not a troll. I live in Montgomery myself (Chevy Chase View, specifically) and I know that many of my immediate neighbors and most people in the county support immigrants and hate what TX and FL is doing to them. So we need to lobby those officials in TX and FL to send them here, where they receive the help they need.

Oh sweetie, your immediate neighbors who support immigrants and hate what TX and FL are doing to them would be the first to turn to insist those buses be turned back to DC. You are dealing with limousine liberals who talk the talk but do not walk the walk.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:It appears that no matter what any president (or governor) does to try to stop the flow of migrants it works at first but eventually the numbers increase again. That is because whatever they encounter on their trip to the border and whatever they encounter once they get there or into the US is not worse than the life they are trying to leave. People in the US who don't understand this and appear to think they are coming here to ruin our lives are very ignorant and entitled.

I do understand their lives suck down there. That does not mean they get to break the law to come here.

Simple concept. Not so simple if it's you and your family, children, who are suffering and in danger. Hardly anybody in the US knows what that is like. What would you do if it were you? Wait around for years or maybe never for a legal chance at a better life?

NP here and I totally get this and I don’t blame any migrant on a personal level for trying to do whatever they can for their family. I’m sure in their shoes I’d do the same thing.

However immigration is just a bandaid to a much bigger issue of certain countries being run by drug lords. We can keep letting people into our country in theory, but then there will just be new children being born there and new arrivals fleeing this same violence. So we’re forever treating the symptom of the violence and 100 years from now our grandkids will still be having the same immigration debates.

Why can’t more be done to help these people fight back and get actual leadership that isn’t corrupt?

US has provided those countries a ton of aid, but the government is corrupt and/or the drug lords are stronger. Look at how the mayors in MX are gunned down. There's a news story of this happening just this past week.

MX is a narco state. It is owned by the drug industry.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Was thinking about this earlier today and was wondering why Texas and Florida have only sent bus loads of migrants to DC, and not to Montgomery County.

Montgomery is exactly the kind of place Texas and Florida SHOULD be sending them. There’s a well-funded array of social services to handle the needs of newly arrived migrants. The population is overwhelmingly progressive and would welcome more immigrant POC with open arms. County taxpayers would willingly pay higher taxes for programs that served new arrivals, and would similarly approve of zoning changes to allow more subletting of domiciles and higher density housing.

How does one get in touch with the state government officials in TX and FL who are involved in relocating migrants? Because I would want them to start sending busses here rather than DC. We are much better equipped to serve them than DC.

You’re trolling, but the entire point of having planes land in blue areas with no advance notice, and therefore no planning or preparation for an influx of undocumented immigrants, is to create a crisis for those blue areas. People sneaking across the border aren’t sending their itineraries in advance of their arrival, so DeSantis and Abbott are making the point that bleeding heart liberals should have to walk a mile in their shoes in terms of dealing with the humanitarian crisis. They don’t give a shit about the human suffering inflicted on the people they dump elsewhere.

I’m a progressive who thinks it’s entirely fair to spread out undocumented immigrants throughout the country while they’re pursuing possible amnesty, instead of making border towns absorb them all — but it’s just plain cruel to deposit them someplace where no one is expecting them, no preparations have been made, and it’s not even during business hours for local aid organizations. They’ve dropped off immigrants from South American countries in cities in the NE in the midst of bitter winter weather, without regard for the immigrants’ lack of winter apparel. It’s inhumane, and it’s been done this way specifically to stick it to the libs, but the undocumented immigrants don’t deserve to be used as pawns.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:But they should all go to Chevy Chase and Bethesda. That is A-OK with me. How many empty bedrooms and basements are there in these towns, being air conditioned, a total waste. Send them on up.

Totally unsuited for them. They’d be surrounded by people who don’t speak their language or share their culture. They can’t even get familiar food there. Langley Park and Silver Spring and Gaithersburg are much better locations.

[Anonymous]

Come on. Stop the bus before it reaches DC or come to DC to pick a few up.

[Anonymous]

Why are people talking about Florida and Ron DeSantis? The only undocumented immigrants Florida gets are from Cuba and they are welcomed with open arms. What am I missing here?