Riverdale has really strong matriculation nowadays - rivals or is better than Horace Mann. But I know someone who was completely unhooked but really strong student at one of these schools - probably top 20% and ended up at Vassar. It’s the hooks that makes the admissions, not the school. |
Maybe it's because children of smart parents are usually also smart. William went to StA for art history or some such. Not exactly a challenging major to begin with, so the bar was probably pretty low. In any case, they don't have legacy or family $$$ contributions to the unis there, unlike here. |
Columbia Grammar, not the most rigorous, sometimes has super strong admit years - multiple kids in at one Ivy, etc. |
Maybe. Now look at Stuy or Hunter or Regis or Tech etc etc |
I’m not upset with the kids or their parents, they have figured out the system and are playing the game. What I find appalling is the elite colleges who claim to want socioeconomic diversity, racial diversity, cultural diversity, regional diversity, etc etc, but then take all these kids from one school. An elite upper class private in NYC. |
Wealthy, smart kids concentrate in the same place. What did you expect? |
Curious, most of these colleges require As for admission. Do all these kids have As at Dalton? Looks like it must be pretty easy to get As if all these kids are getting them. Grade inflation at Dalton appears to be out of control. |
One of the Dalton students who has posted on there has a parent on the board of the endowment of a HYP school. |
That the colleges practice what they preach and select kids from other schools. There is no way these kids are any different in their abilities, extra-curriculars, interests, grades, or character than a lot of other kids at different schools. |
One dalton kid has parent on board of HYP and donated a center in their name
These schools are also taking 15-20% of kids who are first gen - so they are walking the walk but the ROI on these NYC kids is pretty good |
Matriculations only impressive if they had Northeastern, UVA, Tufts, and Duke with 10 kids each. That's all that counts. |
Dalton doesn't seem to publicly list their profile with grade distributions but here is the one for Trinity - https://trinityschoolnyc.myschoolapp.com/ftpimages/390/download/download_4530575.pdf |
Billionaire kids getting access to private tutors since elementary school, and anything else they want, maybe are different? |
These TT private schools are hard. They're no joke. A grind that a lot of parents don't want for their kids. Kids who enter in younger grades are often counseled out long before HS. You can apply to get in for MS and then again for HS. But truthfully, they don't take a kid for HS unless they're extraordinary (ie know they won't have issues placing them for college). Not sure of numbers now, but acceptance rates into these top NYC privates are single digits. Hooked helps, that's true. At privates. Not true at Regis, Stuy, Hunter, etc. |
One family did the former, another family did the latter. |