
NP. Receiving gift money doesn’t mean the adult kids can’t/don’t support themselves, or don’t pay taxes. |
I'm all for it too, I just think it should be in the form of higher capital gains taxes, because if you have capital gains you also have the liquidity to pay the taxes. That makes more sense than making death an event with a much higher tax rate. I mean 15% for long term capital gains and 50% for estates is nuts to me. I think the big exemption is just because it's not a very practical tax and people would rebel if everyone had to pay it. Few people could pass down houses, etc. If you die during a stock market dip, you're screwed. Etc. But yeah, a side effect of that is all this extra income to adult children without additional taxes, which definitely adds to the sting if you're watching it happen. |
I am in the same boat but also feel strongly that money which has already been taxed, sometimes twice (Income and cap gains) should not be taxed a third time via a gift to my offspring. If there is any loophole to close it's the step up in cost basis upon death - exclude businesses and farms. |
They’re not paying taxes on part of their income (the gift money) which they are in fact using to support themselves, in whole or in part. |
I feel the money that you already paid taxes on, sometimes twice (income and cap gains) should not be taxed a third time when you give it to me to: clean your house, or cut your hair, or serve your food, or write your will, or perform your colonoscopy, etc. |
+1 |
If you die during a stock market dip, you’re not screwed - you’re dead. Same as if you died at any other time. Income is income. All forms of income should be treated (and taxed) equally. |
This is my sister and her family: she and her husband started investing well in real estate starting in the 1980s in a very high COL area. Fast forward to present day - all of her residential properties are now occupied by her children and their children. They work in their careers, but they don't pay rent or mortgages. She gets to live near them, because otherwise they would have had to leave that area long ago. |
Not adults! The “normal” human behavior is for adults to take care of their aging parents. I know 40-something’s who get allowances from their 70 year old parents. 😝 Most of these people are stunted professionally because they relied financially on their parents. |
Because family takes care of family. Just because my kids hit some magical age does not mean that we still don't want to help them out. They still have jobs, meaningful careers they love and live within their means. I mean the poor kid probably didn't have parental help with college---are you proposing we tax kids on the money their parents use to pay for their college? No, it's just called helping your kids with what you have. Yes, some will have more, some less. But you can go from poor to rich, get an education and focus your efforts on improving you. I grew up LMC, worked my ass off to do well in school and get into good schools and also do well in college so I could get a job and pay off my student loans. In 1999 I was 6 years out of graduate school, had paid off all of our loans (almost $80K), bought a first home and well on our way to saving for retirement. I was making 6 figures with my bonus (in 1999 that was an excellent salary). None of that was luck. It was just excelling at school an at our jobs. I knew the path out of low income lifestyle was education and that nothing would be handed to me, so I had to work for it all. That meant not partying as much in college as many kids, it meant working FT on any break to have enough money to attend college. It meant spending hours searching for internships and jobs (in early days of internet---it took a lot more work/planning). Nothing was handed to me or my spouse. We simply worked hard and were always looking for ways to better ourselves. |
Or even better, simply have a "family Credit card". For us it's the one we got for each kid when they turned 16 and started driving. All 3 kids have one, along with me---it's my account with them as secondary. Once kids are out of college, they put purchases on that card that we are paying for (plane tickets home or vacations with us or trips to the grandparents). And yes, education and medical can both be paid directly without being considered a gift. |
Thank you!! |
So…a family-owned property is inhabited by family members? How terrible. |
I happen to know who in my circle is supported financially by their parents. They are not shy about sharing this information. But once they share it, I am now aware that everything they do is only possible because of their parent’s hard work & business acumen — not their own.
It does change my perception of them, I can’t lie. It’s an American thing. We value self made people. Whether you like it or not, those people will always be respected more. |
Do they have limits on it?! |