If this virus had the same effect on the population as a whole as it does on kids (i.e. few, if any, symptoms for the vast, vast majority), covid would’ve been in the news a few times and would then have been ignored. We wouldn’t have imposed any restrictions, and nobody would have spent money developing a vaccine. So, given that covid doesn’t pose any meaningful risk to kids, what’s the point of vaccinating them? Is there any other vaccine that we give to a group that isn’t at risk from the disease in question? |
|
Here we go again. Hundreds of kids in the United States have died from COVID. A substantial percent of them were otherwise healthy. Many, many more are suffering from long-term side effects. While they are generally at less of a risk than adults, it is simply incorrect to say that they aren’t at a meaningful risk. |
PP here - by "they" I was referring to the FDA. They recognized they needed a larger pool and are now calling for one. If the risk was negligible they wouldn't have bothered. |
Any mandate is going to result in significant lawsuits. |
The FDA is expanding the trial size, so I think they understand the desire to get this population vaccinated. If you want to hold off on your 9 year old, that's your choice. I know plenty of parents with 9-11 year olds that can't wait to get their kids vaccinated. |
|
|
The issue is whether the risks of the vaccine would outweigh the benefit in this subpopulation. “The Science” says we don’t know. You make think you know, but that’s like, just your opinion, man. It’s entirely inconsistent to claim that “antivaxxers” are irrational to have qualms about clinical trials showing vaccine efficacy, and then say the vaccine should be approved for under 12s when the clinical trials are inconclusive on risk/benefit just because you want to vaccinate your kids. |
+1 I have 9 and 11 year old daughters. We did preventative full cardio workups for them last week (echocardiogram and EKG) and their cardiologist said he would definitely recommend the shot for kids under 12 if it were his kids. We were already planning on it, but it was good to hear from a heart specialist in terms of risk vs. benefit. |
Did the heart specialist cite the papers/studies that are the basis for this recommendation that you vaccinate your children? I'm concerned primarily about long-run risks, and the fact that the mRNA methodology is quite new. Without historical experience, how do we know that the mRNA approach is safe in the long-run? Please cite the papers/studies that indicate that long-run risk is minimal. |
I’m the PP you’re responding to. I didn’t say anything about the risk-benefit analysis. I was simply responding to the misleading statement that COVID doesn’t pose a meaningful risk to kids. And while I have my opinions, I agree it is ultimately up to the FDA to make a determination of the risk-benefit analysis. |
If a cardiologist (that's what educated people call "heart specialists") states their professional recommendation, I don't ask him to parse the studies, because I didn't go to medical school. I choose a competent professional and then follow their judgement. If you want to find some osteopath who says that he "knows" that vaccines will make your heart beat slower, well, that's indicative of your own judgement. |
There is a lot of judgement in this response. Also not sure what the slam is on osteopathy (close relative is German osteopath that has a waitlist of patients at all times and it’s quite normal practice in Germany)…. Anyway, I believe in vaccinations of course but I do worry about MDs that are providing opinions - which is perfectly fine! - but that people take those are somehow the word of God on Covid, and I think there is still a lot of unknowns out there. So I think it’s helpful to inquire and look to MDs for advice, but there are a lot of differing opinions out there, and only time and data and research will really tell us anything more concrete. It’s getting comfortable with some unknowns, that’s where I think we are…. |
Yeah I want my kid to get back to a normal life- no masks, no quarantines for exposure to a virus, normal activities. Doesn’t really matter what the idiot adults do, kids still need the vaccine to regain normalcy. |