Based on what? |
41% acceptance rate LOL https://usnews.com/best-colleges/university-of-rochester-2894/applying This school should be ranked in the 50s |
|
Check out the ranking at the end of this essay.
https://lesshighschoolstress.com/blog/ It's based on different factors than US News, Forbes, etc., and some surprising (apparently underrated) names show up near the top. The Claremont colleges do particularly well. So do women's colleges, and universities located in warmer climates. |
Yield is also below 20%. Kids don't want that school. What happended to the school? |
Yield rates have been going down for a lot of schools because students are applying to so many colleges via Common App. They are only going up for schools that are in the tippy top and those who heavily use ED. |
Adding: And for less-expensive in-state public schools. |
anyways the school is overrated at #36 on USN&WR with all these number. Compare it to the same ranked Boston College and lower ranked schools like Georgia Tech, Northeastern, BostonU, Tulane. Overrated. |
| DP. Agree Rochester is underrated. Rigorous and intense, but excellent. |
|
Agree. The whole rating system creates a false devaluing of schools, especially regional schools. It's a huge country with a lot of colleges. Ranking them is a silly exercise. |
Ranking is useful when there are a lot of colleges like 2500+ Thanks to the information, my three kids found great schools fit them well. |
The choice isn't ranking vs. nothing. I very much prefer the Princeton Review approach that selects under 400 schools it considers strong and then rates schools on a variety of features, and gives qualitative description of the schools. This helps people find a "good" school on the aspects they care about without getting into this horse race mentality that where one school is ten spots above another because they have 1% more research grant funding and 1% more Pell grant recipients or whatever--distinctions that matter so little about whether the school will be a good fit for your student. |
Why do you think a 41% acceptance rate means a school is “overrated”? If no one wants to go there, how can it be overrated? |
What about other 2100 schools Those were ranked lower and eliminated. You were interested in top 400 schools. My kids were interested in top 50 schools. |
But the PR doesn't think there are top 50 schools--or doesn't orient that way. They list them in alphabetical order not by their average rating. You can look at what is highest rated on the variables that interest you rather than thinking that you can identify a precise order among institutions that are very different from one another. The schools that are included (the number varies--it's 388 right now I think) are all the ones that meet their benchmark. It's a different philosophy and method than rank-ordering, it's benchmarking for inclusion and then rating. |