Gaza war and College Campus Protests

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:If the violent people in masks are really Jewish agitators, why don't the other protesters de-mask them and show the world who they really are?

It is an antisemitic trope to imply that protestors need to mask in order to avoid retribution from the pro Israel American community for voicing their views.

I’d love to discuss this more. Doxing is a real thing with real consequences. I personally know of a periodontist in MA who was fired for removing an illegally posted hostage poster in Nov 23 after a photo was taken of her and posted by pro Isreal supporters.

https://amp.cnn.com/cnn/2023/10/15/business/palestinian-americans-activists-doxxing

I don’t know who the masked people are at the student rallies. But I could see if I was one of them I would want to hide my face for fear of retribution which I know has been taken in the past.

How exactly is that antisemitism?

[Anonymous]

They're hiding who they are because many are paid agitators, and they are harassing Jews and spewing hate.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:If the violent people in masks are really Jewish agitators, why don't the other protesters de-mask them and show the world who they really are?

It is an antisemitic trope to imply that protestors need to mask in order to avoid retribution from the pro Israel American community for voicing their views.

I’d love to discuss this more. Doxing is a real thing with real consequences. I personally know of a periodontist in MA who was fired for removing an illegally posted hostage poster in Nov 23 after a photo was taken of her and posted by pro Isreal supporters.

https://amp.cnn.com/cnn/2023/10/15/business/palestinian-americans-activists-doxxing

I don’t know who the masked people are at the student rallies. But I could see if I was one of them I would want to hide my face for fear of retribution which I know has been taken in the past.

How exactly is that antisemitism?

If the poster was put up illegally, call the non-emergency police number. Don't look like a Hamas-sympathizing a-hole by removing it yourself.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:If the violent people in masks are really Jewish agitators, why don't the other protesters de-mask them and show the world who they really are?

It is an antisemitic trope to imply that protestors need to mask in order to avoid retribution from the pro Israel American community for voicing their views.

I’d love to discuss this more. Doxing is a real thing with real consequences. I personally know of a periodontist in MA who was fired for removing an illegally posted hostage poster in Nov 23 after a photo was taken of her and posted by pro Isreal supporters.

https://amp.cnn.com/cnn/2023/10/15/business/palestinian-americans-activists-doxxing

I don’t know who the masked people are at the student rallies. But I could see if I was one of them I would want to hide my face for fear of retribution which I know has been taken in the past.

How exactly is that antisemitism?

If the poster was put up illegally, call the non-emergency police number. Don't look like a Hamas-sympathizing a-hole by removing it yourself.

+1

Talk about disingenuous.

The poster wasn't removed b/c it was "illegally posted". The poster was removed b/c the periodontist didn't want people to sympathize with the hostages.

100% deserved to be fired.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:If the violent people in masks are really Jewish agitators, why don't the other protesters de-mask them and show the world who they really are?

It is an antisemitic trope to imply that protestors need to mask in order to avoid retribution from the pro Israel American community for voicing their views.

I’d love to discuss this more. Doxing is a real thing with real consequences. I personally know of a periodontist in MA who was fired for removing an illegally posted hostage poster in Nov 23 after a photo was taken of her and posted by pro Isreal supporters.

https://amp.cnn.com/cnn/2023/10/15/business/palestinian-americans-activists-doxxing

I don’t know who the masked people are at the student rallies. But I could see if I was one of them I would want to hide my face for fear of retribution which I know has been taken in the past.

How exactly is that antisemitism?

If the poster was put up illegally, call the non-emergency police number. Don't look like a Hamas-sympathizing a-hole by removing it yourself.

+1

Talk about disingenuous.

The poster wasn't removed b/c it was "illegally posted". The poster was removed b/c the periodontist didn't want people to sympathize with the hostages.

100% deserved to be fired.

Someone deserved to lose their job because they removed a poster?

Nah - I wouldn’t have done it, but justifying someone’s life being upended for the act of removing a poster (regardless what that means to you) is 100,000x more outrageous than what she actually did. The people that doxxed her are scumbags, and you’re a scumbag for trying to justify it.

And if you can’t see why removing a poster in Massachusetts that involves people in Israel doesn’t affect anyone at all at the level of someone losing their job, further shame on you. Some people refuse to justify the outrageous history of Israel’s atrocities, knowing that nobody puts up posters for the countless victims of Israel barbarity over the years.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:If the violent people in masks are really Jewish agitators, why don't the other protesters de-mask them and show the world who they really are?

It is an antisemitic trope to imply that protestors need to mask in order to avoid retribution from the pro Israel American community for voicing their views.

I’d love to discuss this more. Doxing is a real thing with real consequences. I personally know of a periodontist in MA who was fired for removing an illegally posted hostage poster in Nov 23 after a photo was taken of her and posted by pro Isreal supporters.

https://amp.cnn.com/cnn/2023/10/15/business/palestinian-americans-activists-doxxing

I don’t know who the masked people are at the student rallies. But I could see if I was one of them I would want to hide my face for fear of retribution which I know has been taken in the past.

How exactly is that antisemitism?

If the poster was put up illegally, call the non-emergency police number. Don't look like a Hamas-sympathizing a-hole by removing it yourself.

Call the non-emergency police line? Are you serious?

The longer this goes on, the more individuals become convinced that Zionists truly are irredeemable. No other group seems to consistently find ways to reach new lows, to find new ways to take strident positions that just naturally seem to repel the concept of “doing what’s right”.

Making sure that someone loses their job, possibly their career and livelihood because they removed a poster? Man, what in the actual F is your defect?

DP

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:If the violent people in masks are really Jewish agitators, why don't the other protesters de-mask them and show the world who they really are?

It is an antisemitic trope to imply that protestors need to mask in order to avoid retribution from the pro Israel American community for voicing their views.

I’d love to discuss this more. Doxing is a real thing with real consequences. I personally know of a periodontist in MA who was fired for removing an illegally posted hostage poster in Nov 23 after a photo was taken of her and posted by pro Isreal supporters.

https://amp.cnn.com/cnn/2023/10/15/business/palestinian-americans-activists-doxxing

I don’t know who the masked people are at the student rallies. But I could see if I was one of them I would want to hide my face for fear of retribution which I know has been taken in the past.

How exactly is that antisemitism?

If the poster was put up illegally, call the non-emergency police number. Don't look like a Hamas-sympathizing a-hole by removing it yourself.

+1

Talk about disingenuous.

The poster wasn't removed b/c it was "illegally posted". The poster was removed b/c the periodontist didn't want people to sympathize with the hostages.

100% deserved to be fired.

Someone deserved to lose their job because they removed a poster?

Nah - I wouldn’t have done it, but justifying someone’s life being upended for the act of removing a poster (regardless what that means to you) is 100,000x more outrageous than what she actually did. The people that doxxed her are scumbags, and you’re a scumbag for trying to justify it.

And if you can’t see why removing a poster in Massachusetts that involves people in Israel doesn’t affect anyone at all at the level of someone losing their job, further shame on you. Some people refuse to justify the outrageous history of Israel’s atrocities, knowing that nobody puts up posters for the countless victims of Israel barbarity over the years.

So much confusion in this post.

1. She was absolutely free to put up her own poster re: Palestinian victims of Israel.

2. I 100% support people bearing the consequences of their public actions. What if she'd ripped down a George Floyd poster after he was murdered? Or a poster of school shooting victims because she opposed gun control? What about the Jan. 6 protesters who didn't enter the Capitol?

All firing offenses, IMO.

To me, if you act like an a** in public, then you deserve to bear the consequences of your actions.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:If the violent people in masks are really Jewish agitators, why don't the other protesters de-mask them and show the world who they really are?

It is an antisemitic trope to imply that protestors need to mask in order to avoid retribution from the pro Israel American community for voicing their views.

I’d love to discuss this more. Doxing is a real thing with real consequences. I personally know of a periodontist in MA who was fired for removing an illegally posted hostage poster in Nov 23 after a photo was taken of her and posted by pro Isreal supporters.

https://amp.cnn.com/cnn/2023/10/15/business/palestinian-americans-activists-doxxing

I don’t know who the masked people are at the student rallies. But I could see if I was one of them I would want to hide my face for fear of retribution which I know has been taken in the past.

How exactly is that antisemitism?

If the poster was put up illegally, call the non-emergency police number. Don't look like a Hamas-sympathizing a-hole by removing it yourself.

Call the non-emergency police line? Are you serious?

The longer this goes on, the more individuals become convinced that Zionists truly are irredeemable. No other group seems to consistently find ways to reach new lows, to find new ways to take strident positions that just naturally seem to repel the concept of “doing what’s right”.

Making sure that someone loses their job, possibly their career and livelihood because they removed a poster? Man, what in the actual F is your defect?

DP

DP.

QQ, what if one of your employees put up a poster in public stating that HIV is god's punishment for homosexuals?

Would you fire them?

I sure as heck would.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:They're hiding who they are because many are paid agitators, and they are harassing Jews and spewing hate.

DP Oh my god, it is beyond exhausting how “harassment” and “spewing hate” are words so fluidly weaponized by individuals like you to silence individuals who object to atrocities. It’s almost like there’s a coordinated campaign to propagandize against anyone who dares to speak up against evil doing.

Where have we seen this before?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:If the violent people in masks are really Jewish agitators, why don't the other protesters de-mask them and show the world who they really are?

It is an antisemitic trope to imply that protestors need to mask in order to avoid retribution from the pro Israel American community for voicing their views.

I’d love to discuss this more. Doxing is a real thing with real consequences. I personally know of a periodontist in MA who was fired for removing an illegally posted hostage poster in Nov 23 after a photo was taken of her and posted by pro Isreal supporters.

https://amp.cnn.com/cnn/2023/10/15/business/palestinian-americans-activists-doxxing

I don’t know who the masked people are at the student rallies. But I could see if I was one of them I would want to hide my face for fear of retribution which I know has been taken in the past.

How exactly is that antisemitism?

If the poster was put up illegally, call the non-emergency police number. Don't look like a Hamas-sympathizing a-hole by removing it yourself.

Call the non-emergency police line? Are you serious?

The longer this goes on, the more individuals become convinced that Zionists truly are irredeemable. No other group seems to consistently find ways to reach new lows, to find new ways to take strident positions that just naturally seem to repel the concept of “doing what’s right”.

Making sure that someone loses their job, possibly their career and livelihood because they removed a poster? Man, what in the actual F is your defect?

DP

DP.

QQ, what if one of your employees put up a poster in public stating that HIV is god's punishment for homosexuals?

Would you fire them?

I sure as heck would.

In that case, sure.

But how in the F do your eyes see analogy in those two scenarios?

What is wrong with you?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Six humans were kidnapped, maimed, raped, tortured and held captive for 11 months and then were executed point blank. I’m not sure anyone is gleefully trying to make anything “about them”. Please grow a heart.

What occurred to those six souls is plenty bad enough at "kidnapping and eventually killed", we really don't need you adding unsubstantiated allegations like maiming, rape, torture, etc.

One had his arm blown off.

I read that his arm was amputated following a grenade injury at the time of the kidnapping. Not meaning to minimize that injury our his subsequent loss of life at all, but I also don't think you can label that maiming or torture. If you do, where do you draw the line? Has Israel not been committing maiming and torturing (in addition to killing) non-stop since 10/7, and consistently since its inception.

Wait, who maimed him exactly? Oh, accidentally while being kidnapped by monsters?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:If the violent people in masks are really Jewish agitators, why don't the other protesters de-mask them and show the world who they really are?

It is an antisemitic trope to imply that protestors need to mask in order to avoid retribution from the pro Israel American community for voicing their views.

I’d love to discuss this more. Doxing is a real thing with real consequences. I personally know of a periodontist in MA who was fired for removing an illegally posted hostage poster in Nov 23 after a photo was taken of her and posted by pro Isreal supporters.

https://amp.cnn.com/cnn/2023/10/15/business/palestinian-americans-activists-doxxing

I don’t know who the masked people are at the student rallies. But I could see if I was one of them I would want to hide my face for fear of retribution which I know has been taken in the past.

How exactly is that antisemitism?

If the poster was put up illegally, call the non-emergency police number. Don't look like a Hamas-sympathizing a-hole by removing it yourself.

Call the non-emergency police line? Are you serious?

The longer this goes on, the more individuals become convinced that Zionists truly are irredeemable. No other group seems to consistently find ways to reach new lows, to find new ways to take strident positions that just naturally seem to repel the concept of “doing what’s right”.

Making sure that someone loses their job, possibly their career and livelihood because they removed a poster? Man, what in the actual F is your defect?

DP

DP.

QQ, what if one of your employees put up a poster in public stating that HIV is god's punishment for homosexuals?

Would you fire them?

I sure as heck would.

In that case, sure.

But how in the F do your eyes see analogy in those two scenarios?

What is wrong with you?

Both scenarios involve totally inappropriate (and inhumane) public behavior.

You just agree with one POV, but not the other.

So, to answer your question, there's nothing wrong with me. The problem is that you don't have a principled position, whereas I do.

FWIW, I would also 100% fire a pro-Israel advocate who removed a poster commemorating Palestinian casualties.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:They're hiding who they are because many are paid agitators, and they are harassing Jews and spewing hate.

DP Oh my god, it is beyond exhausting how “harassment” and “spewing hate” are words so fluidly weaponized by individuals like you to silence individuals who object to atrocities. It’s almost like there’s a coordinated campaign to propagandize against anyone who dares to speak up against evil doing.

Where have we seen this before?

Yes, we saw it in Nazi Germany. In pogroms all over Europe. In the U.S. when it came to racial discrimination. We are now hearing it from you.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:If the violent people in masks are really Jewish agitators, why don't the other protesters de-mask them and show the world who they really are?

It is an antisemitic trope to imply that protestors need to mask in order to avoid retribution from the pro Israel American community for voicing their views.

I’d love to discuss this more. Doxing is a real thing with real consequences. I personally know of a periodontist in MA who was fired for removing an illegally posted hostage poster in Nov 23 after a photo was taken of her and posted by pro Isreal supporters.

https://amp.cnn.com/cnn/2023/10/15/business/palestinian-americans-activists-doxxing

I don’t know who the masked people are at the student rallies. But I could see if I was one of them I would want to hide my face for fear of retribution which I know has been taken in the past.

How exactly is that antisemitism?

If the poster was put up illegally, call the non-emergency police number. Don't look like a Hamas-sympathizing a-hole by removing it yourself.

+1

Talk about disingenuous.

The poster wasn't removed b/c it was "illegally posted". The poster was removed b/c the periodontist didn't want people to sympathize with the hostages.

100% deserved to be fired.

Someone deserved to lose their job because they removed a poster?

Nah - I wouldn’t have done it, but justifying someone’s life being upended for the act of removing a poster (regardless what that means to you) is 100,000x more outrageous than what she actually did. The people that doxxed her are scumbags, and you’re a scumbag for trying to justify it.

And if you can’t see why removing a poster in Massachusetts that involves people in Israel doesn’t affect anyone at all at the level of someone losing their job, further shame on you. Some people refuse to justify the outrageous history of Israel’s atrocities, knowing that nobody puts up posters for the countless victims of Israel barbarity over the years.

So much confusion in this post.

1. She was absolutely free to put up her own poster re: Palestinian victims of Israel.

2. I 100% support people bearing the consequences of their public actions. What if she'd ripped down a George Floyd poster after he was murdered? Or a poster of school shooting victims because she opposed gun control? What about the Jan. 6 protesters who didn't enter the Capitol?

All firing offenses, IMO.

To me, if you act like an a** in public, then you deserve to bear the consequences of your actions.

As to the first two examples in #2, wake us up when George Floyd or school shooting victims (especially gross of you to choose that, given what I’m about to write) have a history within a billion miles of what Israel has done to the people who committed the 10/7 acts.

And as to your final point - the PROBLEM is that irredeemable, vengeful Zionists like you ALSO demand to dictate what those consequences should be.

Do you get it? What if the dentist or whatever was removing a 10/7 hostage poster that was affixed to their own property without permission. You are not demanding excessive “justice”, or to define the extent of the punishment, for them … having removed a poster?

Man, what is wrong with you. Seriously.

[Anonymous]

it’s all fine and dandy until someone get fired for being at a pro israel rally… then all hell will break loose.