This is really hopeful! But the oldest men in that study are 46. I will be very interested what the study looks like by the time the men are late 50s. Here's hoping for good news!!!! |
I'm a woman who'd never be a SAHM, because my mom was and I experienced what happens as a kid when your Dad gets diagnosed with brain cancer and all of a sudden your SAHM has to scramble to figure out working so you don't lose the house. My sister was just a baby when this happened. My grandmother helped us out to the extent she could. Dad ended up okay but it could have gone differently. Life really does throw curveballs, you can't plan for everything but I at least can make sure I'm not in that position. |
Fixed it for you. |
Insurance policies can cover dire situations. Sah, for my family, was worth the risk of the types of disaster scenarios pps have brought out. Being with my young children every day and being there before and after school and to care for them when they were sick means more to me and dh than any amount of money. This isn't a knock on anyone else's choices. We both felt having an at home parent was our top priority and the best way to ensure our children grew up in the home and family we desired for them. That is what we valued the most. It went well and the kids are great. |
Her point stands, though. |
Insurance only goes so far, unfortunately. I remember a horrible moment where my Dad pointed out that we had Insurance for if he died but the insurance didn't remotely cover the cost of "Dad's brain isn't working". The pressure on my Dad and the horrible feeling of failure he had when he couldn't fill that role through no fault of his own. I never want anyone I love to feel like that. |
Ha! I became a SAHM (or worked very part time anyway) for kind of a similar reason. My cousin died when her kids were in elementary school, and they had this whole community of people that stepped up and made sure that they didn’t fall behind at school and still got to their extracurriculars and everything. I was working at the time and felt like I didn’t know anyone who also knew my kids and family. There just wasn’t enough time to devote to those relationships. I took a few years and built up our network of friends and family that were involved in our lives and involved with our kids. |
I have insurance like that, and so does DH. I don’t know if it existed when you were a kid though. |
| Life is give and take, every choice has positives and negatives. Pick one you can live with. Its not like people are marrying young in teen years and can't think for themselves. Most people are marrying around 30 and are mature enough to make decisions. |
Are you saying others should raise your kids when you are not able to provide for them in case of your husband's death? This is the crazier s..t I've ever read on this forum |
The 90s were a different time, sure. Dad had just started a new job too so there were fights with health insurance and such. It was rough. |
|
Nothing is definitive if girls are educated and husbands are supportive. Most of my friends bounced back professionally after raising kids for a decade, even two. Not as successful as they would've been without long gaps but doing well and not resentful.
That being said, times have changed so not an ideal choice but to each its own. |
| Yes all women should be educated and have a career just like all men. This is to increase options. SAHM for at least a few years when the kids are small is a great option to plan for since many women find that their maternal instinct kicks into high gear when they get pregnant and have children. |
|
You seem short sided, OP. It is like a kid trying to figure out what kind of doctor she wants to become. Why don’t you get into college and med school first? Then you can figure out what kind of grades and test scores you have to see what type of residency you can get into.
If you never get married and have kids, you won’t need to stay home. |
That sounds traumatic for the whole family. Fortunately, brain cancer is rare and my family made it through my being home without any major financial distress. My father also had a life altering medical emergency and condition starting when I was 11. I was traumatized by that, for sure. It is also part of the reason I wanted to spend every day with my young kids. I would do it again. |