St. Albans lax

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Being familiar with both Prep and STA, I would think the academic top 10-15% of each school would match up well with each other. What does appear to be true, however, is that STA has done significantly better in Ivy League, and its equivalent, college admissions. And I don't think the reason is solely because Prep families prefer Notre Dame and Georgetown.

I would agree with this. The top 10% are very similar at both schools. However, the bottom 75% or so at STA are much stronger than the bottom 75% at Prep. There are few to no kids at STA that aren't very academic kids. The college admissions also reflect this--the top 10 or so are similar but the bottom 75% admits at STA are much stronger than the bottom 75% at Prep.

It’s not the bottom 75%, that’s a gross exaggeration. These schools are far more similar academically and in regards to student intelligence and drive than some would like to admit. I would say the bottom 25% at Prep is less academically inclined than the bottom 25% at STA. Other than that their student bodies are rather similar in regards to intelligence, academic interest, focus, and drive

I'll give STA its due for academics, but to claim Prep is in the same league and better than Landon is simply not true. The top 10-15 % of kids at all three schools are likely similar. The depth of great students at STA is simply greater than at Landon or Prep. I believe Landon is a better academic school than Prep overall, but I will accept that they are equal for the sake of the previous poster.

Sorry, but this is incorrect. Prep is superior academically to Landon. It is closer to STA academically. Kids who can't handle STA's academics transfer to Landon, Bullis, and St. Andrews. They don't go to Prep because it is fairly equal in academic rigor.

Sorry to you. You are full of shit.

To me, the point of HS for kids is to learn about themselves, mature into adults and learn to be intellectually curious. The goal is to get into the best University your child can get into and where he fits in. Full stop. Not sure getting B's at STA (or any of the more "rigorous academic" schools) helps if you can get A's at another school and maybe evolve in other areas. Get great grades, wherever that is...in particular w standardized scores becoming optional more and more.

Of course, be great at Lacrosse w good grades and you go to any school you want...

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Being familiar with both Prep and STA, I would think the academic top 10-15% of each school would match up well with each other. What does appear to be true, however, is that STA has done significantly better in Ivy League, and its equivalent, college admissions. And I don't think the reason is solely because Prep families prefer Notre Dame and Georgetown.

I would agree with this. The top 10% are very similar at both schools. However, the bottom 75% or so at STA are much stronger than the bottom 75% at Prep. There are few to no kids at STA that aren't very academic kids. The college admissions also reflect this--the top 10 or so are similar but the bottom 75% admits at STA are much stronger than the bottom 75% at Prep.

It’s not the bottom 75%, that’s a gross exaggeration. These schools are far more similar academically and in regards to student intelligence and drive than some would like to admit. I would say the bottom 25% at Prep is less academically inclined than the bottom 25% at STA. Other than that their student bodies are rather similar in regards to intelligence, academic interest, focus, and drive

I'll give STA its due for academics, but to claim Prep is in the same league and better than Landon is simply not true. The top 10-15 % of kids at all three schools are likely similar. The depth of great students at STA is simply greater than at Landon or Prep. I believe Landon is a better academic school than Prep overall, but I will accept that they are equal for the sake of the previous poster.

Sorry, but this is incorrect. Prep is superior academically to Landon. It is closer to STA academically. Kids who can't handle STA's academics transfer to Landon, Bullis, and St. Andrews. They don't go to Prep because it is fairly equal in academic rigor.

Sorry to you. You are full of shit.

Lovely language, shows your true character. Maybe if you went to a academically stronger school or truly understood what that looked like then you would have a greater vocabulary to draw from in order to express yourself more appropriately. STA and Prep are far more similar than Landon academically. The only thing Landon and Prep have in common is that they are both stronger athletically than STA. Facts, they're important.

[Anonymous]

STA and Prep are far more similar than Landon academically. The only thing Landon and Prep have in common is that they are both stronger athletically than STA. Facts, they're important.

I have always thought STA had the stronger academic persona amongst the IAC schools.

I have also always been under the belief Landon and Prep are very similar when it comes to academic reputation - one happens to be Catholic, the other is not.

Not trying to start a pissing match either.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

STA and Prep are far more similar than Landon academically. The only thing Landon and Prep have in common is that they are both stronger athletically than STA. Facts, they're important.

I have always thought STA had the stronger academic persona amongst the IAC schools.

I have also always been under the belief Landon and Prep are very similar when it comes to academic reputation - one happens to be Catholic, the other is not.

Not trying to start a pissing match either.

Yes, STA is the strongest but Prep is right behind it and very similar. I would say STA and Prep are the same at the top and middle, but it’s the bottom group at Prep that might have a wider range than STA. Landon is one tier below. STA and Prep are also very sought-after and have fairly low acceptance rates. Landon is popular, but not at the same level as STA and Prep. Landon has been known to still have spots available in certain grades in the summer months, hence the emails they send out announcing they have availability and trying to recruit boys for these open spots.

STA average SAT score is 1410
Prep average SAT score is 1386
Landon average SAT score is 1320

Prep faculty with advanced degrees 85%
STA faculty with advanced degrees 80%
Landon faculty with advanced degrees 70%

Prep ranked #1 for lowest acceptance rate for private schools in Maryland.

41% of Prep’s 2021 class attended top 40 USNWR national universities.
33% of Landon’s 2021 class….

Facts are facts.

[Anonymous]

Good lacrosse>good academics.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

STA and Prep are far more similar than Landon academically. The only thing Landon and Prep have in common is that they are both stronger athletically than STA. Facts, they're important.

I have always thought STA had the stronger academic persona amongst the IAC schools.

I have also always been under the belief Landon and Prep are very similar when it comes to academic reputation - one happens to be Catholic, the other is not.

Not trying to start a pissing match either.

Yes, STA is the strongest but Prep is right behind it and very similar. I would say STA and Prep are the same at the top and middle, but it’s the bottom group at Prep that might have a wider range than STA. Landon is one tier below. STA and Prep are also very sought-after and have fairly low acceptance rates. Landon is popular, but not at the same level as STA and Prep. Landon has been known to still have spots available in certain grades in the summer months, hence the emails they send out announcing they have availability and trying to recruit boys for these open spots.

STA average SAT score is 1410
Prep average SAT score is 1386
Landon average SAT score is 1320

Prep faculty with advanced degrees 85%
STA faculty with advanced degrees 80%
Landon faculty with advanced degrees 70%

Prep ranked #1 for lowest acceptance rate for private schools in Maryland.

41% of Prep’s 2021 class attended top 40 USNWR national universities.
33% of Landon’s 2021 class….

Facts are facts.

Except 58% of Landon graduates matriculated at the top 50 USNWR National Universities and Liberal Arts Colleges.
41% of Landon Students are POC. Landon does not have a dormitory.
I suspect Prep's website hasn't been updated in a while because they still list their wrestling team as tops in the area, which hasn't been true since shortly after Kubic left.
Landon's average class size 14, Prep's average class size 16.
The Lowest Acceptance Rate is because of their boarding program. Lots and Lots of kids apply to their boarding program, and they can only let in a few.

I will admit Landon's admissions were less competitive for a while, but that is no longer true. There were no new sophomores in the past year, the yield has also been higher than expected in the past few years.

The SAT is far from the only measure of academic rigor. Prep admits kids in 9th grade. Landon admits them in 3rd grade. You have no idea what a third grader's SAT's are going to look like in six years.

Last time I saw Prep's Matriculation list, it was similar to Landon's, likely a little worse, but I am giving Prep a little benefit of the doubt on their kids who could have gone to more competitive schools but elected to go to BC, Georgetown, and Holy Cross. ND is an elite National U, so no loss there.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

STA and Prep are far more similar than Landon academically. The only thing Landon and Prep have in common is that they are both stronger athletically than STA. Facts, they're important.

I have always thought STA had the stronger academic persona amongst the IAC schools.

I have also always been under the belief Landon and Prep are very similar when it comes to academic reputation - one happens to be Catholic, the other is not.

Not trying to start a pissing match either.

Yes, STA is the strongest but Prep is right behind it and very similar. I would say STA and Prep are the same at the top and middle, but it’s the bottom group at Prep that might have a wider range than STA. Landon is one tier below. STA and Prep are also very sought-after and have fairly low acceptance rates. Landon is popular, but not at the same level as STA and Prep. Landon has been known to still have spots available in certain grades in the summer months, hence the emails they send out announcing they have availability and trying to recruit boys for these open spots.

STA average SAT score is 1410
Prep average SAT score is 1386
Landon average SAT score is 1320

Prep faculty with advanced degrees 85%
STA faculty with advanced degrees 80%
Landon faculty with advanced degrees 70%

Prep ranked #1 for lowest acceptance rate for private schools in Maryland.

41% of Prep’s 2021 class attended top 40 USNWR national universities.
33% of Landon’s 2021 class….

Facts are facts.

Except 58% of Landon graduates matriculated at the top 50 USNWR National Universities and Liberal Arts Colleges.
41% of Landon Students are POC. Landon does not have a dormitory.
I suspect Prep's website hasn't been updated in a while because they still list their wrestling team as tops in the area, which hasn't been true since shortly after Kubic left.
Landon's average class size 14, Prep's average class size 16.
The Lowest Acceptance Rate is because of their boarding program. Lots and Lots of kids apply to their boarding program, and they can only let in a few.

I will admit Landon's admissions were less competitive for a while, but that is no longer true. There were no new sophomores in the past year, the yield has also been higher than expected in the past few years.

The SAT is far from the only measure of academic rigor. Prep admits kids in 9th grade. Landon admits them in 3rd grade. You have no idea what a third grader's SAT's are going to look like in six years.

Last time I saw Prep's Matriculation list, it was similar to Landon's, likely a little worse, but I am giving Prep a little benefit of the doubt on their kids who could have gone to more competitive schools but elected to go to BC, Georgetown, and Holy Cross. ND is an elite National U, so no loss there.

Interestingly, Prep also has 58% to top 50 USNWR Universities and Liberal Arts Colleges. The difference is Prep has a greater percentage going to top 40 National Universities.

Yes, you are right, Landon does not have a dormitory, just local day students. Not sure what point you are trying to prove, but having a dormitory makes Prep more comparable to STA, so thanks for proving the point further. Most people would far prefer their sons to attend high school with a population of fellow students from around the world than just kids who live in the local DMV.

Your argument that Landon admits 3rd graders as a reason for why their SAT scores are lower is immediately disproven when you consider STA admits 4th graders and they have the highest average SAT scores of the three schools.

Prep's acceptance rate is not low due to its boarding program which constitutes 25% of the school. Their acceptance rate is low due to the high number of applicants for both day and boarding, but mostly day students which make up 75% of the community.

Again, facts are important.

[Anonymous]

All this discussion about which school is better is great, but kind of pointless because they are all good schools. Also, take it to the general private schools thread.

For lacrosse, in Spring 2022, Prep should be better than Landon and both will be much better than STA. STA should be more competitive than in the recent past but still mid-IAC at best.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:All this discussion about which school is better is great, but kind of pointless because they are all good schools. Also, take it to the general private schools thread.

For lacrosse, in Spring 2022, Prep should be better than Landon and both will be much better than STA. STA should be more competitive than in the recent past but still mid-IAC at best.

#1

[Anonymous]

*+1

[Anonymous]

^^ Agreed. As said earlier, play great lacrosse and great grades and you can go anywhere. Won't matter where you go to HS.

[Anonymous]

Prep is not similar to StA because StA doesn’t have a large chunk of its student body driving as Freshman.

[Anonymous]

Yes, STA is the strongest but Prep is right behind it and very similar. I would say STA and Prep are the same at the top and middle, but it’s the bottom group at Prep that might have a wider range than STA. Landon is one tier below. STA and Prep are also very sought-after and have fairly low acceptance rates. Landon is popular, but not at the same level as STA and Prep. Landon has been known to still have spots available in certain grades in the summer months, hence the emails they send out announcing they have availability and trying to recruit boys for these open spots.

The very top at STA and Prep may be similar - but STA has far more students at that level than Prep. STA has a quarter of the class at the level of only the very best few students at Prep, and the bottom at STA is much, much higher than the bottom 1/3 (or more) students at Prep. But none of this matters if a kid is a top recruit.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Prep is not similar to StA because StA doesn’t have a large chunk of its student body driving as Freshman.

This line is so old and tired. Oh, and so untrue. Please come up with new material.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Yes, STA is the strongest but Prep is right behind it and very similar. I would say STA and Prep are the same at the top and middle, but it’s the bottom group at Prep that might have a wider range than STA. Landon is one tier below. STA and Prep are also very sought-after and have fairly low acceptance rates. Landon is popular, but not at the same level as STA and Prep. Landon has been known to still have spots available in certain grades in the summer months, hence the emails they send out announcing they have availability and trying to recruit boys for these open spots.

The very top at STA and Prep may be similar - but STA has far more students at that level than Prep. STA has a quarter of the class at the level of only the very best few students at Prep, and the bottom at STA is much, much higher than the bottom 1/3 (or more) students at Prep. But none of this matters if a kid is a top recruit.

You can tell yourself that all day long, but it is not true. The schools are far more similar than parents at STA like to admit, but it is true.