
I don't see what this has to do with the question. A magnet school that is publicly funded by taxpayers, but restricts access, is not an example of the free market in operation. You seem to confuse statism and elitism with a market economy - a very un-American attitude. I hope the people demand this school serve the community. |
The school does not restrict access. Any 8th grader in participating counties/city in the N. Virginia is free to apply and be evaluated "holistically" by the admission committee including 3 subjective components in addition to grades and test scores. According to your logic, UVA and W&M should be open to anyone in the area or Virginia. Free market means free to compete on merit and ability. |
You seem to have confused the idea of a free market with your own view as to how a meritocracy operates. They are not remotely the same thing. |
Sports teams? All-state band? School play? Tons of stuff that schools do depends on talent/merit--why should ACADEMIC ability be different? |
Your analogies suck. Four full years at a taxpayer-supported public high school is a bit different in scope and impact than getting a part in a school play. |
Your response sucks. The point is they are all publicly funded school or school related programs. You react as if TJ doesn't provide any service. It educates 1,800+ students each year just like any other public high school and it does a good job. You think other high schools are not funded publicly? Get real. |
+1 |
+1 |
Asians should receive the benefits of Affirmative Action since they are a racial minority and they suffer racial discrimination. It's hypocritical to treat them as if they are the majority. |
OH PUH-LEAZE. Is there an emoticon for the "tiny little violin" finger and thumb motion? |
I propose EQUAL TREATMENT FOR ALL -- namely, no racial discrimination in favor of ANY race whatsoever, no matter what their real or imagined grievances. |
Agreed. The Asians are the smallest racial minority of all the minority groups and least able to fight different types of discriminations compared to blacks and Hispanics and therefore most deserving of affirmative action. |
You never provided any support for the silly argument that TJ was an example of a free market, so you lost the argument. You simply prefer that public resources be allocated in a way that you find meritorious. |
I'm Asian-American. We are American too. My parents immigrated to the US legally. They are also American citizens. Your family also immigrated to the US at some point. |
Different poster. PP did not say TJ was an economic entity, the poster merely pointed out an example of you deriving a benefit from operation of a free market where free competition is allowed. It was illustrating the hypocrisy of deriving benefits from removal of artificial barriers (whether economic or educational) while complaining of similar condition for an educational institution. TJ does not restrict entry using artificial barriers except for applicants convincing the admissions committee using objective/subjective criteria that are applied to all applicants. There is a geographical restriction which is understandable since it is a N. VA regional public school. You are not advocating that we eliminate all public educational institutions that are deemed better than average are you? Make them all equal? That sounds more like communism. Very un-American attitude! |