Where do you consider MCPS high schools on a scale of good-bad

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I live in Potomac and I'm very worried about real-estate not keeping up and its impact on the schools. These days people are abandoning the burbs for closer in areas that are quickly becoming more desirable.

I'd worry about that too, honestly. Younger people typically don't want to live in areas as car-dependent as Potomac and also can't afford it. That's reflected in the Potomac elementary schools, which are undercrowded.

Yep, younger familiar want to live closer in.

Nope, I would say majority of people want to live closer in. But sometimes, people sacrifice "closer in" so that they can get a newer house in a nice neighborhood with good schools for the right price. In this area, consider yourself lucky if you can pick 2 out of these 3 factors: schools, commute, house. I picked schools and house. FYI- where I live in Clarksburg, a lot of young professional families are moving in and have chosen the same. People will pick different things depending on their situation.

If you could have those things, closer in, you'd pick that over the same things farther out, wouldn't you?

Me, personally, yes. Others may feel differently; however even if most would prefer all 3, the bottom line is, MOST people can't afford to check off all 3 boxes in this area. My HHI isn't too shabby at $260K a year and I still can't afford all 3.

The statement was that younger families want to live closer in, not that they are all financially able to do so.

Of course they do. Just like I do too at 43. But in life, what you want doesn't necessarily mean it's possible based on what you have.. My young 32 yr old friend in VA wanted to live in ARlington but ended up in Herndon, so what.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I live in Potomac and I'm very worried about real-estate not keeping up and its impact on the schools. These days people are abandoning the burbs for closer in areas that are quickly becoming more desirable.

I'd worry about that too, honestly. Younger people typically don't want to live in areas as car-dependent as Potomac and also can't afford it. That's reflected in the Potomac elementary schools, which are undercrowded.

Yep, younger familiar want to live closer in.

Nope, I would say majority of people want to live closer in. But sometimes, people sacrifice "closer in" so that they can get a newer house in a nice neighborhood with good schools for the right price. In this area, consider yourself lucky if you can pick 2 out of these 3 factors: schools, commute, house. I picked schools and house. FYI- where I live in Clarksburg, a lot of young professional families are moving in and have chosen the same. People will pick different things depending on their situation.

If you could have those things, closer in, you'd pick that over the same things farther out, wouldn't you?

Me, personally, yes. Others may feel differently; however even if most would prefer all 3, the bottom line is, MOST people can't afford to check off all 3 boxes in this area. My HHI isn't too shabby at $260K a year and I still can't afford all 3.

The statement was that younger families want to live closer in, not that they are all financially able to do so.

Sure, not everyone can afford to live close in, but there are many that can and do. The population of DC proper is up what 40% from 20 years ago?

Also, many places that people want to live now from around Shaw, Union Market, or Petworth were sketchy a decade or two ago.

Whether people want to admit it or not, the metro area is changing.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I live in Potomac and I'm very worried about real-estate not keeping up and its impact on the schools. These days people are abandoning the burbs for closer in areas that are quickly becoming more desirable.

I'd worry about that too, honestly. Younger people typically don't want to live in areas as car-dependent as Potomac and also can't afford it. That's reflected in the Potomac elementary schools, which are undercrowded.

Yep, younger familiar want to live closer in.

Nope, I would say majority of people want to live closer in. But sometimes, people sacrifice "closer in" so that they can get a newer house in a nice neighborhood with good schools for the right price. In this area, consider yourself lucky if you can pick 2 out of these 3 factors: schools, commute, house. I picked schools and house. FYI- where I live in Clarksburg, a lot of young professional families are moving in and have chosen the same. People will pick different things depending on their situation.

If you could have those things, closer in, you'd pick that over the same things farther out, wouldn't you?

Me, personally, yes. Others may feel differently; however even if most would prefer all 3, the bottom line is, MOST people can't afford to check off all 3 boxes in this area. My HHI isn't too shabby at $260K a year and I still can't afford all 3.

The statement was that younger families want to live closer in, not that they are all financially able to do so.

Sure, not everyone can afford to live close in, but there are many that can and do. The population of DC proper is up what 40% from 20 years ago?

Also, many places that people want to live now from around Shaw, Union Market, or Petworth were sketchy a decade or two ago.

Whether people want to admit it or not, the metro area is changing.

Well let's just say, i have the money and I'd rather stay where i'm at rather than move to any of these places. Proximity to cool restaurants isn't on the top of my list. Schools are.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I live in Potomac and I'm very worried about real-estate not keeping up and its impact on the schools. These days people are abandoning the burbs for closer in areas that are quickly becoming more desirable.

I'd worry about that too, honestly. Younger people typically don't want to live in areas as car-dependent as Potomac and also can't afford it. That's reflected in the Potomac elementary schools, which are undercrowded.

Yep, younger familiar want to live closer in.

Nope, I would say majority of people want to live closer in. But sometimes, people sacrifice "closer in" so that they can get a newer house in a nice neighborhood with good schools for the right price. In this area, consider yourself lucky if you can pick 2 out of these 3 factors: schools, commute, house. I picked schools and house. FYI- where I live in Clarksburg, a lot of young professional families are moving in and have chosen the same. People will pick different things depending on their situation.

If you could have those things, closer in, you'd pick that over the same things farther out, wouldn't you?

Me, personally, yes. Others may feel differently; however even if most would prefer all 3, the bottom line is, MOST people can't afford to check off all 3 boxes in this area. My HHI isn't too shabby at $260K a year and I still can't afford all 3.

The statement was that younger families want to live closer in, not that they are all financially able to do so.

Sure, not everyone can afford to live close in, but there are many that can and do. The population of DC proper is up what 40% from 20 years ago?

Also, many places that people want to live now from around Shaw, Union Market, or Petworth were sketchy a decade or two ago.

Whether people want to admit it or not, the metro area is changing.

Well let's just say, i have the money and I'd rather stay where i'm at rather than move to any of these places. Proximity to cool restaurants isn't on the top of my list. Schools are.

There's always a small minority of people who go against the grain. However, the vast majority don't, and real-estate prices are a function of demand.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I live in Potomac and I'm very worried about real-estate not keeping up and its impact on the schools. These days people are abandoning the burbs for closer in areas that are quickly becoming more desirable.

I'd worry about that too, honestly. Younger people typically don't want to live in areas as car-dependent as Potomac and also can't afford it. That's reflected in the Potomac elementary schools, which are undercrowded.

Yep, younger familiar want to live closer in.

Nope, I would say majority of people want to live closer in. But sometimes, people sacrifice "closer in" so that they can get a newer house in a nice neighborhood with good schools for the right price. In this area, consider yourself lucky if you can pick 2 out of these 3 factors: schools, commute, house. I picked schools and house. FYI- where I live in Clarksburg, a lot of young professional families are moving in and have chosen the same. People will pick different things depending on their situation.

If you could have those things, closer in, you'd pick that over the same things farther out, wouldn't you?

Me, personally, yes. Others may feel differently; however even if most would prefer all 3, the bottom line is, MOST people can't afford to check off all 3 boxes in this area. My HHI isn't too shabby at $260K a year and I still can't afford all 3.

The statement was that younger families want to live closer in, not that they are all financially able to do so.

Sure, not everyone can afford to live close in, but there are many that can and do. The population of DC proper is up what 40% from 20 years ago?

Also, many places that people want to live now from around Shaw, Union Market, or Petworth were sketchy a decade or two ago.

Whether people want to admit it or not, the metro area is changing.

Well let's just say, i have the money and I'd rather stay where i'm at rather than move to any of these places. Proximity to cool restaurants isn't on the top of my list. Schools are.

There's always a small minority of people who go against the grain. However, the vast majority don't, and real-estate prices are a function of demand.

I wouldn't call the vast number of families who live in the suburbs a small minority.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

I wouldn't call the vast number of families who live in the suburbs a small minority.

Montgomery County has urban areas. And it has close-in suburbs. And it has way-out-there suburbs. People increasingly want to live in close-in areas, which is why the close-in areas are expensive.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

I wouldn't call the vast number of families who live in the suburbs a small minority.

Montgomery County has urban areas. And it has close-in suburbs. And it has way-out-there suburbs. People increasingly want to live in close-in areas, which is why the close-in areas are expensive.

Exactly

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

I wouldn't call the vast number of families who live in the suburbs a small minority.

Montgomery County has urban areas. And it has close-in suburbs. And it has way-out-there suburbs. People increasingly want to live in close-in areas, which is why the close-in areas are expensive.

Exactly

Again, nothing new. Always has been the case. Andta lot of families make sacrifices that make the most sense for them, hence lots of people are still moving further out.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

I wouldn't call the vast number of families who live in the suburbs a small minority.

Montgomery County has urban areas. And it has close-in suburbs. And it has way-out-there suburbs. People increasingly want to live in close-in areas, which is why the close-in areas are expensive.

Exactly

Again, nothing new. Always has been the case. Andta lot of families make sacrifices that make the most sense for them, hence lots of people are still moving further out.

Not always... not too long ago, MCPS closed schools closer in as families moved out to the 'burbs for more room. Now, probably due to commute time and/or people wanting "walkability", people are wanting to move closer in. And this is why now the outer burb schools are not as crowded, too.

There was an article on this with a map showing which schools closed during the 80s/90s.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

I wouldn't call the vast number of families who live in the suburbs a small minority.

Montgomery County has urban areas. And it has close-in suburbs. And it has way-out-there suburbs. People increasingly want to live in close-in areas, which is why the close-in areas are expensive.

Exactly

Again, nothing new. Always has been the case. Andta lot of families make sacrifices that make the most sense for them, hence lots of people are still moving further out.

Not always... not too long ago, MCPS closed schools closer in as families moved out to the 'burbs for more room. Now, probably due to commute time and/or people wanting "walkability", people are wanting to move closer in. And this is why now the outer burb schools are not as crowded, too.

There was an article on this with a map showing which schools closed during the 80s/90s.

I remember the 60s and 70s too! However, there have been many more articles about the great inversion. More and more people are abandoning the burbs for more urban living. This is why the population of DC is up over 40% in recent years and the changes in demand are effecting the market now and will impact schools in the coming years.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

I wouldn't call the vast number of families who live in the suburbs a small minority.

Montgomery County has urban areas. And it has close-in suburbs. And it has way-out-there suburbs. People increasingly want to live in close-in areas, which is why the close-in areas are expensive.

Exactly

Again, nothing new. Always has been the case. Andta lot of families make sacrifices that make the most sense for them, hence lots of people are still moving further out.

It's always been the case if you look over centuries, but in the last 100 years or so in the US, it was not at all the case. And particularly not after World War II.

Are people still living a long way out because that's what they can afford? Yes. But that's the point. They would prefer to live closer in, but they can't afford to.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:
Not always... not too long ago, MCPS closed schools closer in as families moved out to the 'burbs for more room. Now, probably due to commute time and/or people wanting "walkability", people are wanting to move closer in. And this is why now the outer burb schools are not as crowded, too.

There was an article on this with a map showing which schools closed during the 80s/90s.

Schools closed during the 1980s because enrollment dropped, because of the baby bust.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

I wouldn't call the vast number of families who live in the suburbs a small minority.

Montgomery County has urban areas. And it has close-in suburbs. And it has way-out-there suburbs. People increasingly want to live in close-in areas, which is why the close-in areas are expensive.

Exactly

Again, nothing new. Always has been the case. Andta lot of families make sacrifices that make the most sense for them, hence lots of people are still moving further out.

Not always... not too long ago, MCPS closed schools closer in as families moved out to the 'burbs for more room. Now, probably due to commute time and/or people wanting "walkability", people are wanting to move closer in. And this is why now the outer burb schools are not as crowded, too.

There was an article on this with a map showing which schools closed during the 80s/90s.

I remember the 60s and 70s too! However, there have been many more articles about the great inversion. More and more people are abandoning the burbs for more urban living. This is why the population of DC is up over 40% in recent years and the changes in demand are effecting the market now and will impact schools in the coming years.

Exactly, since 2000 DC's population has gone from 572k to 693k (20%) whereas Potomac MD population seems frozen in time at 45k. This is unlike the close in suburbs like Bethesda that are up around 10% in that same period.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:
Not always... not too long ago, MCPS closed schools closer in as families moved out to the 'burbs for more room. Now, probably due to commute time and/or people wanting "walkability", people are wanting to move closer in. And this is why now the outer burb schools are not as crowded, too.

There was an article on this with a map showing which schools closed during the 80s/90s.

Schools closed during the 1980s because enrollment dropped, because of the baby bust.

Where are you living that you think schools in far out burbs in this area will need to close due to underenrollment? Have you heard of Clarksburg? Have you heard that they are planning on building a new HS in Gaithersburg to address overcrowding in RM, QO and Gaithersburg HS? Have you heard that they're expanding Seneca Valley HS to address overcrowding in upcounty schools? Have you heard of the newly built Hallie Wells MS? And the planned building of another new elementary school to accommodate the new families moving to the new Cabin Branch development?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

I wouldn't call the vast number of families who live in the suburbs a small minority.

Montgomery County has urban areas. And it has close-in suburbs. And it has way-out-there suburbs. People increasingly want to live in close-in areas, which is why the close-in areas are expensive.

Exactly

Again, nothing new. Always has been the case. Andta lot of families make sacrifices that make the most sense for them, hence lots of people are still moving further out.

Not always... not too long ago, MCPS closed schools closer in as families moved out to the 'burbs for more room. Now, probably due to commute time and/or people wanting "walkability", people are wanting to move closer in. And this is why now the outer burb schools are not as crowded, too.

There was an article on this with a map showing which schools closed during the 80s/90s.

I remember the 60s and 70s too! However, there have been many more articles about the great inversion. More and more people are abandoning the burbs for more urban living. This is why the population of DC is up over 40% in recent years and the changes in demand are effecting the market now and will impact schools in the coming years.

Exactly, since 2000 DC's population has gone from 572k to 693k (20%) whereas Potomac MD population seems frozen in time at 45k. This is unlike the close in suburbs like Bethesda that are up around 10% in that same period.

Potomac residents don't want new development. It's not an area where there's a lot of building unlike Bethesda. And residents want it that way.