She doesn’t have to. You’ve made it clear to her you will do what she wants when she wants you to so why should she ask? Consider the example you’re setting for your own children and insist upon better for yourself next year. I’m sorry but a No One will do it for you. |
|
OP, This is my gift to you:
|
|
It's sweet and lovely to get flowers and a card and homemade gifts from my kids on Mother's Day, I love it. However, as their mom, taking care of them is not a freaking sacrifice I'm making that they will need to be endlessly grateful to me about for the rest of their lives. We also celebrate Children's Day (it really is a thing) and I think it balances things out and makes these holidays about appreciating the presence of everyone in the family, not just mom. I detest the idea of mother's day as a day to express gratitude for "mother's sacrifices" I don't experience mothering as a sacrifice...It's an honor to be a mom, but I suspect I feel that way because of freedom of choice and bodily autonomy.
I think it would be awesome to make Children's Day (it always falls on the first Sunday in June) a holiday that is as recognized as Mother's Day and Father's Day. Imagine if a couple weeks after Mother's Day, our mothers or MILs celebrated/appreciated our role as their children. Might make Mother's Day feel more balanced instead of like a day of being expected to fawn over a parent whose prime parenting years ended decades ago. |
|
Then do not do it. You are grown, do what you want.
You are more afraid of their reactions than your own disappointment. Deal with it. |
Why does she have to give up the day. Let her do what she wants and you do what you want. A therapist can help you unwind this. You have kids of your own but cannot figure out how to live your own life? |
Resent yourself. These are choices you are making. |
This deserves it’s own thread. |
| I need more details on the DH who implied you were going to a winery but momnapped you and drove to your MILs. We need details!@ |
This is me and I’m happy I saw the light too! |
| I struggled with this early on. Now DH and I pick another day to celebrate my Mother’s Day. Either Saturday or the following week. It’s lovely and I don’t mind at all. My mom can have actual Mother’s Day. Maybe it was easier to navigate because it’s my mom and not MIL who causes the issues. But highly recommend being flexible about when you celebrate and also setting explicit expectations for DH. |
I have no words… |
|
My mother, who seldom bought records, bought one called "No Charge", which is the story of a little boy handing his mother a bill for his chores, and her countering with all she has sacrificed for him with the refrain " no charge". I hated that song.
My kids managed to remember to text. I got some chocolate. I'm happy. |
And what do the points scored by enabling his mother get you? I don’t disagree that not caring is liberating but I wouldn’t be impressed by your DH in the slightest if, by the time he has tweens, he doesn’t have boundaries with his own mother. |
Oof. Score points? PP try to come off emotionally intelligent but then showed true colors. |
I get the appreciation of my husband and thankfulness that I understand his mother puts him in a terrible position, and he is still a caring son (which I admire - I don’t get all these wives who think their husbands should tell their moms to eff off.) He is a caring and thoughtful spouse, and if I had a tantrum about Mother’s Day, I would “win” and get my way. But why? |