Forum Index
»
Sports General Discussion
true but the issue is that if those kids don't come back and the "local" kids are no longer interest, the program runs the chance of putting together a below average team to compete. |
What makes you think the Joga kids will just start club hopping? And what makes you think that because they played for Joga they aren't "local" kids? |
Because that is what has already happened. And they will keep club-hopping because they have high soccer ambitions. No judgement at all, it's just a fact. |
Exactly, just a fact. No one is hating on it. I have nothing against it, they are simply better than most that tried out and most likely looking for the next step in their development whether it's local or overseas. Most are not Arlington kids and if they are they weren't part of the Arlington program for very long. |
That's just the way it goes, it's a meritocracy (mostly) and the better kids move on to higher level programs. Happens in sports, academics, business - how is this a problem? Close to 1/2 of the Mclean U15B team that won the National Championships last month is moving to Bethesda Academy - it's what happens when kids commit themselves to a sport. They need to find other kids equally committed/talented to progress. |
Very well put. And finding the right coach is another big part of it. |
I agree with you and wasn't trying to say it wasn't, just that the club needs to be prepared for the decisions they make on how many "new/outside" players to take versus sticking with those that have been with the club for many years. Players should always look for what provides them the best opportunity. |
meant to bold this one. |
Looking at the Joga SC website, it seems all the kids and people involved were black. Whenever we've gone against Arlington teams, all the boys are white. Is this why some of the parents of Arlington kids were angry their boys who have been with Arlington for 3+ years(travel) didn't get on the Academy team even their kid was on the top team in the past? Or is there more to Arlington taking outsiders. |
It's more of Arlington taking outsiders. I can tell you from seeing Joga in the past, that they are a very diverse group. Joga also does work with DC kids from city which may be some of the pics on the website. If you were to look at Joga Youtube clips of games, you find all kinds of backgrounds. |
On another note, what if these kids made it and were playing on a scholarship which is being subsidized by the other paying parents, now that is a reason to be mad. ha ha. |
You don't pick kids based on the speculation that they will "stay with the club". You pick the best kids at the tryout, period. This whole logic of "Outsiders" vs "home town kids" has a narrative that appears to be loaded. |
Strange sentiment and word - 'outsiders'. That's not how soccer works in the US. There is no boundary limitation in travel really - except maybe for State Cup eligibility or county field fees. The geography for a club is really only for rec - no one is going to take a kid from PW to Arl for a rec slot. But once it's travel, it's wide open. If you imposed geography limitations, you would destroy the competitiveness of the club. This has happened to several clubs locally where 'local' club parents attacked the 'outsiders' that they were just convinced were taking their kids spots on elite teams. Those 'outsiders' - coaches and players - left. And what was a great competitive team with 50% 'outsiders' became a middling team with 100% 'locals'. |
yeah, screw the 'poors'. UFB. |
|