| How much does a grade 5-8 teacher get paid? How many kids in the average class? How much goes to cover admin/facilities/subsidies for fin aid at a place like this? |
You found that post heart-warming? We are not wealthy but donate for FA so others can benefit from the school, which we love. PP might want to consider that more $ to tuition means less available for families like ours to donate for her family’s FA. |
Question - do independent college counselors outside of schools have access to Naviance ? |
No. Naviance is a school specific data base. |
Thanks. Do the Sidwell counselors use Naviance themselves ? |
Whether it is helpful or not, it is a tool that they use. The question was why don't they make that tool available outside of the tight control of the CCO. Someone said it was because past students are too easily identifiable. And then someone responded that because Sidwell's scattergrams aggregate 4 years of data, specific alumni students really can't be identified. |
They do. Students and their parents can look at Naviance scattergrams in a meeting with the counselor upon request. IME, the counselors are reluctant to have families look at scattergrams when they think it is too early in the process of a student creating their list, and the counselor will push back against that request. And when they do eventually let you look at them, they will only let you look at a very small number of colleges' scattergrams when those colleges are on your list. So among other things, the counselors won't let students look at and use scattergrams as a tool to create their list in the first place. |
why not? Seems helpful as you choose some on the list. What help is it after the fact?? Maybe this is why some are unhappy with Sidwell’ cco |
Maybe ordinary students don’t get in to those colleges these days, from any school? Things change. Being a regular student at Sidwell isn’t a ticket to a top 20 school anymore. Maybe that’s a reality check and a good thing. |
This is false. The parent-student meeting can be filled with looking at as many scattergrams as they want. And, the student can go back and meet and look at any other scattergrams they want at any point during the process. Just my opinion, but so much has changed with COVID, that the scattergrams and any other metrics other than the 2021 CDS is relatively useless. |
It never was. Even 50 years ago. |
You are very wealthy. Be real. |
It’s not false, because it was our experience this year with DC’s counselor. Perhaps the counselors are inconsistent, which is a point that seems to have come up as an issue over and over again in these discussions. |
+1 |
| SFS could increase transparency by using Naviance. Show the data: # of applications, # of admissions, # who attend. |