Dr Sneha Philip mystery - did she die in 9/11 attacks?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:He wanted proof of her being alive on 9/11 because then he could collect the fund money. They ruled that she went missing 9/10 and wound not be eligible for the fund.

I think that he said from day 1 that Sneha had never come home on 9/10. Her brother is the one who initially told the reporter that Sneha was last seen run towards the Trade Center to help people because no one was interested in talking about someone who had disappeared on 9/10 and he wanted to get the word out that Sneha was missing. I can understand that.

If her husband was soley interested in proving that Sneha was alive on 9/11 in order to collect money, why did he go through hours of surveillance video from 9/10? I really think he was trying to find out what the heck had happened to her. Was Sneha the one using the Amex card or did a thief use it? If it was Sneha, was she with someone? If she was with someone, who was she with and where did they go together?

All very legitimate questions from someone seeking answers to the disappearance of their wife.

[Anonymous]

Sneha and her husband had been married for less than a year and half when she disappeared. She had been fired from her one job and was on rocky terms with her new job. She may have had a substance abuse and/or problem with alcohol. She had legal problems and had been in court in the morning of Sept 10.

Maybe she went to a friend's house that night, feeling down and wanting to numb her pain and she simply overdosed on something by accident that night. The druggie friend did what druggie friends do and dumped her body somewhere (a dumpster?). The next morning the city was in chaos with debris everywhere. No one was noticing things about random dumpsters.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:He wanted proof of her being alive on 9/11 because then he could collect the fund money. They ruled that she went missing 9/10 and wound not be eligible for the fund.

had the fund even been set up yet when he started looking? I'm thinking it came a few months later. He had nothing to gain or lose with her being dead one day vs another, did he?

[Anonymous]

Sneha's family and her husband are all still close today. He eventually got remarried but still stays in touch with Sneha's family. That says a lot.

The grainy video of the woman in the lobby of the apartment building on the morning of 9/11.... they all seem to think that the woman could be Sneha.

Certainly the noise of the impact would have made anyone turn and go outside to see what had happened. Maybe she really did run to the trade center.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Sneha and her husband had been married for less than a year and half when she disappeared. She had been fired from her one job and was on rocky terms with her new job. She may have had a substance abuse and/or problem with alcohol. She had legal problems and had been in court in the morning of Sept 10.

Maybe she went to a friend's house that night, feeling down and wanting to numb her pain and she simply overdosed on something by accident that night. The druggie friend did what druggie friends do and dumped her body somewhere (a dumpster?). The next morning the city was in chaos with debris everywhere. No one was noticing things about random dumpsters.

Wasn't there a story like that about a year ago? A married blonde doctor (dermatologist?) with children liked to go into the city on weekends to party, but she overdosed. Her drug friends left her body in a lobby or something. Anyone else recall this?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Sneha and her husband had been married for less than a year and half when she disappeared. She had been fired from her one job and was on rocky terms with her new job. She may have had a substance abuse and/or problem with alcohol. She had legal problems and had been in court in the morning of Sept 10.

Maybe she went to a friend's house that night, feeling down and wanting to numb her pain and she simply overdosed on something by accident that night. The druggie friend did what druggie friends do and dumped her body somewhere (a dumpster?). The next morning the city was in chaos with debris everywhere. No one was noticing things about random dumpsters.

Wasn't there a story like that about a year ago? A married blonde doctor (dermatologist?) with children liked to go into the city on weekends to party, but she overdosed. Her drug friends left her body in a lobby or something. Anyone else recall this?

Yes. I read about it here on DCUM as a matter of fact.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Sneha and her husband had been married for less than a year and half when she disappeared. She had been fired from her one job and was on rocky terms with her new job. She may have had a substance abuse and/or problem with alcohol. She had legal problems and had been in court in the morning of Sept 10.

Maybe she went to a friend's house that night, feeling down and wanting to numb her pain and she simply overdosed on something by accident that night. The druggie friend did what druggie friends do and dumped her body somewhere (a dumpster?). The next morning the city was in chaos with debris everywhere. No one was noticing things about random dumpsters.

Wasn't there a story like that about a year ago? A married blonde doctor (dermatologist?) with children liked to go into the city on weekends to party, but she overdosed. Her drug friends left her body in a lobby or something. Anyone else recall this?

Yes. I read about it here on DCUM as a matter of fact.

Gorgeous 38 yr old doctor, mom of 3 found dead in NYC building lobby
http://www.dcurbanmom.com/jforum/posts/list/504263.page

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Sneha's family and her husband are all still close today. He eventually got remarried but still stays in touch with Sneha's family. That says a lot.

The grainy video of the woman in the lobby of the apartment building on the morning of 9/11.... they all seem to think that the woman could be Sneha.

Certainly the noise of the impact would have made anyone turn and go outside to see what had happened. Maybe she really did run to the trade center.

Except she left BEFORE the attacks happened. So that's not why she left.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Sneha's family and her husband are all still close today. He eventually got remarried but still stays in touch with Sneha's family. That says a lot.

The grainy video of the woman in the lobby of the apartment building on the morning of 9/11.... they all seem to think that the woman could be Sneha.

Certainly the noise of the impact would have made anyone turn and go outside to see what had happened. Maybe she really did run to the trade center.

Except she left BEFORE the attacks happened. So that's not why she left.

IF the time stamps are accurate.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Sneha's family and her husband are all still close today. He eventually got remarried but still stays in touch with Sneha's family. That says a lot.

The grainy video of the woman in the lobby of the apartment building on the morning of 9/11.... they all seem to think that the woman could be Sneha.

Certainly the noise of the impact would have made anyone turn and go outside to see what had happened. Maybe she really did run to the trade center.

Except she left BEFORE the attacks happened. So that's not why she left.

that's assuming the time stamp on the video was correct. It may not have been, especially if it had to be manually changed every time the power went out or the time changed to/from daylight savings time etc.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Sneha's family and her husband are all still close today. He eventually got remarried but still stays in touch with Sneha's family. That says a lot.

The grainy video of the woman in the lobby of the apartment building on the morning of 9/11.... they all seem to think that the woman could be Sneha.

Certainly the noise of the impact would have made anyone turn and go outside to see what had happened. Maybe she really did run to the trade center.

Except she left BEFORE the attacks happened. So that's not why she left.

IF the time stamps are accurate.

It's pretty basic and surely they would have looked at that. Especially the private investigator.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Sneha's family and her husband are all still close today. He eventually got remarried but still stays in touch with Sneha's family. That says a lot.

The grainy video of the woman in the lobby of the apartment building on the morning of 9/11.... they all seem to think that the woman could be Sneha.

Certainly the noise of the impact would have made anyone turn and go outside to see what had happened. Maybe she really did run to the trade center.

Except she left BEFORE the attacks happened. So that's not why she left.

IF the time stamps are accurate.

It's pretty basic and surely they would have looked at that. Especially the private investigator.

How soon was the PI brought in? If there had been power outages on 9/11 and after 9/11, maybe the time stamp got altered.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Sneha's family and her husband are all still close today. He eventually got remarried but still stays in touch with Sneha's family. That says a lot.

The grainy video of the woman in the lobby of the apartment building on the morning of 9/11.... they all seem to think that the woman could be Sneha.

Certainly the noise of the impact would have made anyone turn and go outside to see what had happened. Maybe she really did run to the trade center.

Except she left BEFORE the attacks happened. So that's not why she left.

Also if the woman from the security tape from her apartment building is she, it was taken about the same time the first plane hit. T2 didn't collapse until almost an hour later. So if she really had run toward the towers, more than likely there would have some glimpse of her footage of her somewhere in the dozen and dozens of store cameras, people on the street and news media filming and taking photos.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Sneha's family and her husband are all still close today. He eventually got remarried but still stays in touch with Sneha's family. That says a lot.

The grainy video of the woman in the lobby of the apartment building on the morning of 9/11.... they all seem to think that the woman could be Sneha.

Certainly the noise of the impact would have made anyone turn and go outside to see what had happened. Maybe she really did run to the trade center.

Except she left BEFORE the attacks happened. So that's not why she left.

Also if the woman from the security tape from her apartment building is she, it was taken about the same time the first plane hit. T2 didn't collapse until almost an hour later. So if she really had run toward the towers, more than likely there would have some glimpse of her footage of her somewhere in the dozen and dozens of store cameras, people on the street and news media filming and taking photos.

Did many people die other than those who had actually been in the towers at the time? I can't remember hearing about any.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Sneha's family and her husband are all still close today. He eventually got remarried but still stays in touch with Sneha's family. That says a lot.

The grainy video of the woman in the lobby of the apartment building on the morning of 9/11.... they all seem to think that the woman could be Sneha.

Certainly the noise of the impact would have made anyone turn and go outside to see what had happened. Maybe she really did run to the trade center.

Except she left BEFORE the attacks happened. So that's not why she left.

Also if the woman from the security tape from her apartment building is she, it was taken about the same time the first plane hit. T2 didn't collapse until almost an hour later. So if she really had run toward the towers, more than likely there would have some glimpse of her footage of her somewhere in the dozen and dozens of store cameras, people on the street and news media filming and taking photos.

Did many people die other than those who had actually been in the towers at the time? I can't remember hearing about any.

Lots of people on the street and in nearby buildings died. People on the street were hit by falling bodies and debris, I specifically remember reading about people in nearby buildings dying in elevators and I think on top of WT7 I think. I assume when the towers fell more people were hit by debris but by the time they were found (or not found) they were buried under a pile of rubble so how would anyone know if they were in the building or on the sidewalk?