Dr Sneha Philip mystery - did she die in 9/11 attacks?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I wish her well

If she is alive

[Anonymous]

Totally makes sense that she would walk away from all that time invested in med school and her marriage to live a secret lesbian lifestyle. She seemed to be free to go out without her husband and everything. Not sure many women would walk away from a dual doctor income life, which includes going out and dropping money at Century 21, to live as an arty lesbian with no more contact with a family that you're close to....?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Totally makes sense that she would walk away from all that time invested in med school and her marriage to live a secret lesbian lifestyle. She seemed to be free to go out without her husband and everything. Not sure many women would walk away from a dual doctor income life, which includes going out and dropping money at Century 21, to live as an arty lesbian with no more contact with a family that you're close to....?

No offense, but your post is pretty dumb. For one thing, she probably wouldn't be able to enjoy that sweet, sweet "dual doctor income" for much longer because (in addition to her marriage possibly falling apart) she seemed to have trouble holding onto her jobs.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Totally makes sense that she would walk away from all that time invested in med school and her marriage to live a secret lesbian lifestyle. She seemed to be free to go out without her husband and everything. Not sure many women would walk away from a dual doctor income life, which includes going out and dropping money at Century 21, to live as an arty lesbian with no more contact with a family that you're close to....?

They didn't have a dual income b/c she was fired. Substance abuse problems could have eventually lost her license.

Why would you stay married to any man if you didn't want to have sex with them?

Shopping doesn't lead to happiness.

P.S. not all lesbians are "arty."

[Anonymous]

I agree it is odd when it became a public mystery that no one came forward to say where she was on the night of 9/10. Even if it was a woman she was having shady dealing with (sex/drugs/whatever), couldn't she say they had become friends and Sanha knew her husband was getting back late from work at the hospital, so she offered to have her stay over?

Is the 9/11 lobby video online anywhere?

[Anonymous]

I wonder if she was with another woman when shopping and they both left the evening of 9/10 to start a new life somewhere (maybe the other woman got them IDs) and she actually was no where near NYC on 9/11.

They could be living a new life anywhere. Canada was easy to get into in those days.

She could have even heard of her own missing person story and be somewhat comforted that her family thinks she died a hero. It also would mean no one would be looking for her, a good thing if you want to start a new life.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Totally makes sense that she would walk away from all that time invested in med school and her marriage to live a secret lesbian lifestyle. She seemed to be free to go out without her husband and everything. Not sure many women would walk away from a dual doctor income life, which includes going out and dropping money at Century 21, to live as an arty lesbian with no more contact with a family that you're close to....?

No offense, but your post is pretty dumb. For one thing, she probably wouldn't be able to enjoy that sweet, sweet "dual doctor income" for much longer because (in addition to her marriage possibly falling apart) she seemed to have trouble holding onto her jobs.

But people lose jobs and get divorced everyday. These are way more normal to deal with then starting a new life in a strange place under a new ID with zero support. From what we know, her parents seem very supportive given she was texting for 2 hrs and had a cousin visiting soon.

So either foul play from family or 'friends'. More likely she walked out to check the plane noises and was killed.

[Anonymous]

I'm starting to think more and more about the husband.

I definitely believe she is dead, I think it's highly likely she was killed on the 10th. Most murders are not random. The only person going through all those hours of tapes was the husband. He's the one that put the narrative together.

For all we know, she went shopping and went home. Who says she went out after that? Only the husband. There are no credit card charges after Century 21. He could have killed her that evening. How hard would it have been for him to dump the shopping bags in dumpster? Right along with her body maybe, or over a bridge.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I agree it is odd when it became a public mystery that no one came forward to say where she was on the night of 9/10. Even if it was a woman she was having shady dealing with (sex/drugs/whatever), couldn't she say they had become friends and Sanha knew her husband was getting back late from work at the hospital, so she offered to have her stay over?

Is the 9/11 lobby video online anywhere?

If it was sex or drugs, it is likely the other person was already facing scrutiny from her/his family, or had a past with her that they did not want investigated. And risk becoming a suspect themselves. Even if they were completely unrelated to her disappearance, the shady dealings would still ruin their reputation. Saying we became friends won't suffice when she is missing.

[Anonymous]

Where was Sneha's father? I recall mention of her mother but no mention of her dad.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Totally makes sense that she would walk away from all that time invested in med school and her marriage to live a secret lesbian lifestyle. She seemed to be free to go out without her husband and everything. Not sure many women would walk away from a dual doctor income life, which includes going out and dropping money at Century 21, to live as an arty lesbian with no more contact with a family that you're close to....?

No offense, but your post is pretty dumb. For one thing, she probably wouldn't be able to enjoy that sweet, sweet "dual doctor income" for much longer because (in addition to her marriage possibly falling apart) she seemed to have trouble holding onto her jobs.

But people lose jobs and get divorced everyday. These are way more normal to deal with then starting a new life in a strange place under a new ID with zero support. From what we know, her parents seem very supportive given she was texting for 2 hrs and had a cousin visiting soon.

So either foul play from family or 'friends'. More likely she walked out to check the plane noises and was killed.

True. Sorry I said that post was dumb.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Where was Sneha's father? I recall mention of her mother but no mention of her dad.

He is in the picture.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I'm starting to think more and more about the husband.

I definitely believe she is dead, I think it's highly likely she was killed on the 10th. Most murders are not random. The only person going through all those hours of tapes was the husband. He's the one that put the narrative together.

For all we know, she went shopping and went home. Who says she went out after that? Only the husband. There are no credit card charges after Century 21. He could have killed her that evening. How hard would it have been for him to dump the shopping bags in dumpster? Right along with her body maybe, or over a bridge.

I don't think it was the husband. The police had their hands full and were ready to say that Sneha had died at the Trade Center because that was her family's best guest as to what had happened to her. But the husband was the one who hired investigators to dig deeper. The husband is the one who searched hours of store security footage until he found video of Sneha shopping. The husband is the one who insisted that Sneha had never come home on Sept 10th. Why didn't he just play along and say that he last saw her on Sept 11 and let everyone assume that she rushed off to the Trade Center to help out?

I think that the guy was holding out hope that she might be found alive.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I'm starting to think more and more about the husband.

I definitely believe she is dead, I think it's highly likely she was killed on the 10th. Most murders are not random. The only person going through all those hours of tapes was the husband. He's the one that put the narrative together.

For all we know, she went shopping and went home. Who says she went out after that? Only the husband. There are no credit card charges after Century 21. He could have killed her that evening. How hard would it have been for him to dump the shopping bags in dumpster? Right along with her body maybe, or over a bridge.

I don't think it was the husband. The police had their hands full and were ready to say that Sneha had died at the Trade Center because that was her family's best guest as to what had happened to her. But the husband was the one who hired investigators to dig deeper. The husband is the one who searched hours of store security footage until he found video of Sneha shopping. The husband is the one who insisted that Sneha had never come home on Sept 10th. Why didn't he just play along and say that he last saw her on Sept 11 and let everyone assume that she rushed off to the Trade Center to help out?

I think that the guy was holding out hope that she might be found alive.

I'm the OP. I agree with this.

[Anonymous]

He wanted proof of her being alive on 9/11 because then he could collect the fund money. They ruled that she went missing 9/10 and wound not be eligible for the fund.