The players earned selection |
sure sounds good. Maybe explain what the requirements are at the beginning of the season. Lmao such a dumb ass question to ask. Everyone on every team would love to know these things. Otherwise it’s not transparent and you get comments on here screaming nepotism, money under the table, favoritism etc etc etc. Dont coaches have to do mid/.end of season idps anyway? Fit it in there. Just hope the tale of the tape matches up. Parents will probably call bullshyt to your face. 🤣 the audacity for a team to ask for feedback from a coach. I can only imagine what team you are in charge of. They must be in greaaaat shape. Side note my kid hasn’t gotten selected. And isn’t sweating it. So far it hasn’t worked out for her peers. With that said?! Im sure whe would love to hear her coaches feedback past and present. Most players would. |
case in pt… transparency shuts this right up. Parents will always feel slighted w/o it. Especially if the players they send aren’t really carrying on the teams. |
im sure you and coach they did. And im sure you will have parents that disagree w/o transparency. Just hope that player is leaps and bounds better than her peers in that position. If not expect some angry sideline vibes. |
There is nothing to bite but your tongue or maybe a lip… or two. We appreciate the sensible response staffer. Keep the prayers flowing. They need it. |
But do we think even with the player feedback, parents still won’t think there’s transparency because the coach is only going to talk to you about your kid and no one else. And this is subjective and if your kid who you think should have gotten selected didnt, you will still say no transparency and politic etc Truth is it’s a combo of a lot of things why kids get selected. Club sure submit a list but the scouts also come out and watch them and still may or may not cut your kid off the list. The point is everyone will have different opinion on who should get selected. |
danger will Robinson. Don’t put it on the scouts and simultaneously have those same girls at the showcase the team didn’t go to. I guarantee if you lay your cards out with player feedback w the notes provided about the players (u did remember to send notes right? Not just names with no context). It will be consumed by parents a lot easier. Sorry your argument as to why its done behind the scenes falls flat. The truth is giving the girls measurable goals pre season in a group setting leaves only accountability. The coach and club would be accountable to send names of players and players would be accountable to the coach and team to meet and exceed the ecnl/usynt standards. If its done in the light its truly earned. Behind the scenes… and you get the naysayers and or kids not selected repeatedly. Cant force a square in a circle. |
|
it will be on the parents to argue back with facts/video on your feedback btw. And if they win that argument it is what it is. Lol YOU will have you own that and make changes. Its a competition for playing time and everything else. It should be a safe place to point out where players fall short compared to others. If you cant do that then you are lying to yourself and the players and parents. Perfect time for that honest feedback idps or pre ID. |
It’s a slippery slope if all coaches allow parents to argue on the feedback. Any good coach also shouldn’t compare your kid with any of her teammate and only talk about your kids in those feedback meeting. Everyone is going to have a different opinion. I’m not saying politics and nepotism don’t exist - but it’s a subjective topic. To be honest, the process is always going to be flawed and the right players don’t always get identified. If you feel like your club/ coach aren’t doing right by your kid - it’s time to leave. Why stay? |
doesnt have to be subjective if it’s transparent. Coaches and clubs are allergic to it however. There is nothing subjective about nepotism and favoritism. Just call em out and keep it moving. In college however your DD will be compared and told why they aren’t starting. They will either thrive in that competitive mom and dad free environment or hit the portal. Coaches at that level dont hold their tongue as it relates to competition. Why do it now? Its ok to set a standard/bar. What is scary is coaches having to stand by any measurements of success. As far as leaving clubs. Would rather let my DD question her coach directly before following up. Would be cowardly not to air out grievances face to face. Also extreme to run over an ID session. There are much more important things to go scorched earth over. Lmao at letting parents argue on feedback. You must be a joy to be around. Parents are free to challenge you on feedback if they think you are wrong and can factually prove it. If you choose to take it out on DD … after getting called out well thats the slippery slope. |