It was at least largely true according to my observation. |
| My TJ DC with a 4.4, 1550+, very good EC’s got deferred. DC’s friend with a 4.31 got deferred as well. |
This year has been really tough. IMO it all started with top colleges for not requiring standardized scores, leading to a huge increase in the number of applications and randomness of the process. Top students who typically get into top colleges got deferred and needed to apply to/ stay in the applications for more schools to be safe. This effect propagates down to the UVA level and below. |
Please. Yield protection is not that hard. You waitlist or defer applicants with stats higher than your average admit on the assumption that they'll get into another more selective school and go there. UVA's admissions office is plenty sophisticated and capable of doing that. That's what I meant when I asked if you knew what yield protection actually was. All you're doing is talking out your a$$. |
That's not yield protection. That's tracking demonstrated interest. Which of course UVA could do to at least some degree if it wanted to. The bottom line is UVA doesn't have to do any of that -- and they don't. |
| Pretty darn glad we did ED to UVA! I guess that’s the lesson for next year! |
Same here. Had the stats for Ivies but no hooks and understanding actual statistics, lol, chose not to go for ‘em. |
Not TJ, and her gpa is 4.2 |
ED works, for the university. Takes otherwise qualified top students away from superior schools and forces them to attend. |
It’s a shame. You’ll never know if you were good enough. |
It’s fine. Being “good enough” and getting in are separate things. Very happy with UVA . |
But that's what a university has to do if it is going to engage in yield protection. You can't take the student's word that they are going to show up - so you have to invest resources to ascertain demonstrated interest. |
|
If the university is going to eliminate more qualified applicants to yield protect, why even bother calling it EA in the first place?
Why don't they all call it RD and have it in the fall, put a lot of people on the waitlist and allow plenty of time for people to get pulled off waitlists in multiple rounds? Seems like that would increase the caliber of the applicant pool. |
I agree, my son could’ve gotten in somewhere else maybe better, but we wouldn’t be able to afford it. He’s happy and so are we, always time for those other schools for graduate degrees. |
| All I want to know is the percentage of acceptances who chose not to submit test scores. |