
Agree. This is better than before but could use some fine tuning. |
Ironically, not a single kid on the math count team at our DC's middle school received an offer. How could they have known who is and is not proficient? |
Being in just math count team is not really that special. That team is a large team in certain MS, unless you won state or national level. Beside, TJ is not all about math. My kid who is get in, is not in any kind of math club. DC is just typical laid back all A geometry kid, but his verbal IQ is very high. Maybe you need to redefining who is the “most deserving and truly gifted”, that statement is very broad, and really you don’t know personally one by one who gets in. |
Proficient in what? math? Alot of TJ kid end up pursuing medical, bio, neuroscience degree and etc (non math). I doubt it math is the only consideration. |
How is there not a way? They'd be shining in a variety of math and science activities, and their application would reflect that. |
Just put back the SHSAT. Keep the 1.5%. Keep the "experience factors" Then watch closely to see if we are helping or hurting the kids that are getting preferences. |
DP here. This kid is at woodson instead of TJ https://www.washingtonian.com/2024/08/15/time-magazines-kid-of-the-year-is-a-fairfax-high-schooler-trying-to-cure-skin-cancer/ The best honors math students (as judged by the math teachers) from frost last year are not at TJ. Frost give s an award to the best honors geometry and honors algebra 8th graders at a private awards ceremony. |
Your kid might deserve to be there but we do know on average the students aren't as smart as they used to be. It's an average. |
Not necessarily. Not all of them do math/science ECs (and not all MSs even offer these). Yes they will have As but so will just the run of the mill very bright kids. Teacher recc’s really are essential to tease out the true outliers. |
There is handfull of smart kid in every high school (and this is good), and not all of them interesting in TJ. I personally know some of my kid’s friends who is very smart and decline the offer. Reason? Commute, pressure, friendships, want to stay in base school sports team, and it can be anything else. Not to mention kids who wrote in essay that they apply because of parents pressure and they actually don’t want to go to TJ. |
Calc AB is required to graduate, even for those at the bottom of the class. Top three hundred students take at least one to three levels of math above that, with significant number among them going into medical and life sciences. So math is important, and there is no escape but to face the calculus music. Sob essay cant come to the rescue. |
All the declined offers from bottom schools go back to the top three or four middle schools with stem hungry and math proficient students, more than willing to take on the TJ rigor. |
The commute didn't change, friendships didn't change, sports didn't change, the academic ability of the students did. |
I don't know how the waitlist works but I thought they tried to meet the 1.5% threshhold first before they released the spot to the rest of FCPS. |
There is no way that kid's parent is just a nobody. Gaurenteed it's a scientist, doctor or engineer. |