
National champs? Or the one that keeps getting beat by its lower counterpart in the same club? |
Hhhhhhwhat? Specifics of stfu |
Who says they don't know? But no club, especially a large one, is going to turn away players that are interested in joining. A large club will easily find a team that matches their talent. At U11, which I believe you are heading into, is a year clubs add players because the rules go up from 7v7. |
No I am not afraid. Here is little known secret about travel soccer. Clubs never cut kids. Kids may get moved up or down but once in the club they don't get cut. So, going to other teams practices is the best way to see how the other coach is and how your kids gets along with their actual team. This way you make the tryout period less stressful. If you determine the other team is not for you, no need to waste time at their tryouts. |
^my club cuts kids all the time. generally in the lower age groups but sometimes in the older ones, too.
Frankly, moving a kid from an A to a B team once they are U15 or older is effectively cutting them. It's social suicide for the kids. Most of the kids are smart enough to see it coming, though, and move themselves to another club. |
DCU Academy is decent. Look at where the kids from there are going to be next year. |
It might be passive aggressive or it might be an honest assessment, but I said "Clubs" don't cut kids. Teams? Yes, but clubs don't. I also said large clubs. Small clubs may not have a choice if they just don't have enough kids to make another team. But that is a rare problem for larger clubs. |
Really? Most of the "kids"? The only frenzied moving I've seen happening from our club by kids whose fortunes are waning is being steered by the parents. |
^i can only speak for my club. I've seen plenty of kids in the older age groups (u15 and up) move clubs. 16 year olds know when they are getting 10 min of playing time per game that it isn't a good fit and they don't want to move to the B team so they switch clubs.
But your point is also a good one. the parents are also completely batshit in most cases and are constantly on the lookout for a better club for little lionel |
large clubs definitely do. Maybe they just dont publicize it. The parents are probably embarrassed and the club doesn't want that kind of publicity. I agree clubs are all about the $, but if they can get the spot filled by someone else, they will do it. At some point, no matter how big your club is, you run out of roster space. I also have seen clubs in recent years cut kids (and parents) with attitude problem. Last year, came right out at tryouts, told the kid they didn't like their attitude and said there was no place for them in the club. (kid had been with the club for years, but the coach hadn't been) |
I'm gonna lawyer up a bit on my point. ![]() ![]() I jest a bit here, but parents don't quite understand the negative role that they play in their kids future. At a certain point your kids talent may not be enough to overcome obnoxious parents. And, with the apple not falling far from the tree it is more likely that the kid themselves will turn into a problem as well. And this doesn't just play out on the soccer field either, teachers don't really have patience for it, and I have even seen parents contact their kids employer. |
^agreed! |
I dont think you can make the blanket statement that clubs don't cut kids. Big clubs with 6 or 7 teams in the younger age groups will make cuts to ensure that they have no more than 2 or 3 strong teams at the 11v11 age groups. I've also frequently seen kids cut at smaller clubs when a second team implodes and the coach wants to bring in a few of those players, or players from outside the club, and drop kids from the first team they see as underperforming. Generally speaking, a well run club is not going to punish kids for trying out elsewhere, and rarely will any club cut a top player even if the people in charge are vindictive. We certainly have run across clubs with vindictive coaches and technical directors though. My son left one club for another 4 years ago (at the end of a season, in a very civil fashion), and we gather that the board and TD are still talking trash about our family to this day. |
At the younger ages kids are added because the game grows from 7v7>8v8>9v9>11v11. That timeline will change now due to US Soccer mandates but generally, no, kids at young ages are not cut from the club simply because roster sizes have to grow. They may be assigned a different team, and if as a parent, you feel that is a "cut", well, that is on you but a "demotion" during a development phase is not a "cut", not even close. And, if a club does cut kids at U9-U12, you should run, not walk from that club. |
Exactly. During this McLean game, I heard one of the McLean players actually say 'Why can't we just have one normal game?" Think about that. A 9-year-old boy frustrated with his own adult coach's behavior. I would pull my kid from that team/club in a heartbeat. |