Let me guess, you're 17 and in high school? Or maybe 23 and a nonprofit intern? |
I do "keep think" this is true, because it comports with my experience - but I'm glad you're happy where you are, too. No need for everyone to want the same thing. |
No, I’m in my 40s and from a smaller city. Having lived in a few large cities, the difference is astounding. Large cities like NY, LA, dc, Boston etc still attract most of the strong talent in the US. Yes, there are exceptions but overall, people here are more educated and successful. |
thank you for posting this list. I don't think this is about liberal/progressive at all, I think it is about people not realizing that are major cities in the US that are NOT SF, NYC, LA or DC. It is more like just completely blind to the other significant cities. There was a poster up above who made it sound like there was only one major company in every other city in the US that wasn't SF, NYC, LA or DC. LMAO!!! |
| Also the idea of "all the talent and intellect is in big cities" is laughable. OMG so funny!!! |
I would not dispute that certain cities attract a quality of talent and in high numbers, for reasons both to do with lifestyle and opportunities. New York, Boston, DC, SF, LA top the list. And you're probably right that to fast track to "success" it can be easier to remain in those cities. They have a dynamism that not many other cities have. But it is absolutely not true that those are the only places that have talent and intellect. Let's take Baltimore. No one is going to consider Baltimore a major city. But would you claim that the talent at Johns Hopkins hospital or medical school or public health (which are tops in their field) isn't as good as the talent you find in comparable roles in DC? Or SF? Or LA? All American cities have their cohort of highly educated and successful and intelligent people. All of them. It is arrogant to assume that only in places like DC you can find like-minded people. I went to a highly regarded Ivy for both undergrad and graduate and judging from the alum notes, many of my classmates did start out in the prestige cities and then later migrated to the provincial cities, taking senior roles locally and by all accounts they are having a happy life. I grew up in a provincial city and my parents' circle was highly educated, deeply engaged in local affairs and arts & culture and well traveled and accomplished in their professions. And this is a city you would probably sneer at. And you know what, not all "accomplished" people want a rat race life. They don't need to be in DC or New York. They don't benefit being in those places. Or they live elsewhere and come into New York when they need to for whatever reason. Best of both worlds. Last but not least, the "talent and intellect" in New York laugh at DC..... |
Omg. No, it’s not. It’s not legally part of Washington, dc. Saying you live in dc when you live in ashburn is LYING |
Only someone from a flyover city would actually think being a Fortune 500 company means something. It doesn’t. Working for a Fortune 500 company is the dream for someone in Dallas. |
The more you talk the more you clearly reveal you're a kid. "OMG" and "LYING". Really? Wow. I'm impressed. Ashburn is part of metropolitan DC. It is firmly part of the "DC" area and perfectly justifiable to refer to if talking about moving from DC to a lower cost area even if it is Ashburn to a lower cost suburb of another city. |
Yes, Ashburn is part of the DC metro. No, Ashburn is not part of DC. The residents don’t live in DC, don’t pay DC taxes, can’t attend DC public schools, and can’t vote in DC elections. |
LOL, as opposed to what? The "policy analyst" in DC? |
This is a good point. |
Have you ever worked for the federal government? Yeah, I would agree that it'd be impossible for many of those folks to succeed in the private sector. |
Not sure why it disturbs you or upsets you. I cannot see why you would care at all. If someone wants to live somewhere with people that are more progressive, what is wrong with that? I surely do not care if conservatives want to live in conservative areas. I actually prefer it that way. So, as an professional AA, I can avoid those areas!
|
Yes, I did for 8 years. Now, I work in the private sector and am quite successful there. |