If it a required part of the IB diploma curriculum, then it’s not really an extracurricular, isn’t it? Agree with the previous poster that CAS sucks out any joy of doing something outside the school that you have a passion for. I’m amazed at the extent at which IB cheerleaders will go to spin every crappy feature of the program into something amazing, all while assuming every is too dumb to see right through it. |
AP has more offerings/is better known for science classes and math classes. So it's more likely to capture the typical high stats, advanced in math kids. The effect isn't created after going through the curriculum, it's a result of what type of kid chooses what curriculum for high school. IB is much more liberal-artsy. |
Aren’t those the richest schools in the county? I would think it has more to do with income vs program. |
If students are assigned randomly at AP and IB schools and AP kids outperform IB ones, then you can conclude it’s the curriculum that’s causing the lower performance. |
Sorry but that's very much an attitude and perspective issue on your part. CAS is simply an opportunity to document a passion project (ifa kid has one - admittedly not all kids do) while being given support, networking, and mentorship resources through the school as needed. As said previously, kids get what they put in. Most kids will see it as a chore and do fluff for it. That's fine, it's an easy way out anyway. But some kids seize it and accomplish significant service for their community, and they're the ones rewarded with acceptance to the Ivies. I've seen Habitat for Humanity abroad, getting involved at the Smithsonian museums, and a musical performance set up for a community event where they first tutored young kids how to play their instruments. Not everything should be interpreted as an annoying assignment just to check the box. With that attitude, doesn't matter if it's AP or IB or college or work, you'll just be looking to check boxes in everything you do. |
In both cases the IB program has nothing to do with the substance of the activity. The first one only happens because of Habitat for Humanity. The musical performance is the result of investing time in an actual extracurricular. The IB part is just checking the box, these students would do it regardless, and there’s nothing that IB does to support them in their extracurriculars. Then you’re turning around and claim the credit for CAS. Seems quite dishonest to me. Curious to know where your perspective comes from, you don’t seem to be a student or a parent so maybe an administrator? That would explain the shameless plug. |
CAS is incredibly pointless. If students have a passion project, why document it and even more important, why assign a grade? There’s very little support the school provides and in the end it will favor the students from families with lots of resources. This is so elitist, at least AP seems more egalitarian. |
Np. From personal experience, having been both, a student from a poor family and an IB student, it’s not elitist. The ideas pp posted make it seem that way, but there are so many other options that don’t necessitate family resources. And, in fact, as one of the students who “seized” the opportunity, pp is spot on. It was a great experience, and in some ways, life changing. |
some schools weigh IB SL classes out of 4.5, some weight them out of 5.0, so that's a reason to take the SL over regular/honors |
How does IB help with sports? |
But the students are not assigned randomly, are they? Good point whoever brought up school catchment area HHI, that obviously could impact it. I'm from out of state. The top-ranked schools where I'm from are magnet IBs. |
How did the IB CAS help in your case, specifically? Apparently it was so great that it changed your life, but omit to to say what exactly it was. Seems like a made up point. In our experience the school is not supporting its students in any way, there’s only a coordinator that takes in the write up of the activities. Why grade them? The quality of outside of school extracurriculars will correlate strongly with family income. |
If the gpa boost is the goal, it’s better to take AP or HL in a subject the student is capable. If that particular area is not a strong suit, then it makes more sense to take a regular class then save the time and effort for another AP. IB curriculum in math and sciences is not very good and it is even worse in SL. Math SL in particular is disastrous because it covers topics from algebra, geometry, precalculus, trigonometry, and calculus in one year, with a very superficial treatment. You can get the 0.5 gpa boost, but you’re taking a poorly organized class that going to be a huge time sink, and in the end you still don’t have a good understanding of the content. |
Robinson parent here. I don’t know of anyone in real life who has buyer’s regret. This is a highly sought-out pyramid, with many high-achieving students. The IB program isn’t a deterrent.
|
At Robinson it's a boost. Strangely, I went to a school system where the IB school was like TJ. You had to apply in 8th grade and people clamored for acceptance. And those were the kids who had the best outcomes (i.e. ivy admissions, etc). It was intense, competitive, and in some ways, a series of steps to end up at a elite school as much as a program. I did do well there (I am a physician) and I found the writing to actually be the most useful even in my science classes where the labs were killer. When we moved here, my kids went to Robinson and it was almost identical except there wasn't the toxic competitiveness. The kids were...nice? But the program structurally was the same and the substance was the same and my ended up at a elite private and UVA and are doing well. I found the project to basically set up my college essays. That and the TOK paper helped me learn how to write well. |