Realistically, they can't be in band, orchestra, etc. Those are during the school day and it doesn't really work to get over to the other school. We investigated it when DD, who wanted to continue band, was looking at HS options. |
Occasionally some students drive, but the scheduling would have to work out. So you’re right it’s not a realistic option for many if not most students, even if technically feasible. |
They can do marching band but not concert band, as far as I understand. |
It’s just motions because the outcome (lowest ESL at the smallest school, both percentage and absolute numbers). It’s a coveted program that ESL students aren’t benefiting from, something is broken (or working if you are cynical about the real goals). |
Right so the lottery accepts 100 students. The ESL obv has a limit too; they aren’t adjusting the lottery size based on ESL applications. So the ESL had a max quota by nature of the second process. Otherwise in theory it could be higher if many more applied in general lottery. |
do you know this for sure or are you just assuming this? |
That is a fact. Arlington’s programs operate as schools but that’s it. Students in these programs are official members of their home schools, where they are eligible to join classes or extracurriculars when feasible, walk at graduation and receive a diploma. That’s widely known. |
[img]
Hence HBW is so popular, you get small private school classes but enjoy resources and sports of a much larger school. |
But it gets out so late that it doesn’t work in middle school. |
Okay? Middle school sports are kind of nothingburger anyways. |
While most all sports are at the home schools, HB can host certain non-VHSL sports like Ultimate Frisbee. |
HBW has their own theater program. Don't know about band and orchestra. But things like chorus, band, orchestra are electives that meet during the school day so doubt that's really occurring a whole lot. I've never heard of a HBW kid joining their main high school's theater production. I guess they could. It's logistically annoying for them to join their home high school sports team and a lot of them end up feeling like outsiders when they do. Some of them still do it for sure. It's just not quite as rosy as an option as what PP is portraying. |
I'm an HB parent and I've never heard of an HB kid taking a class at a high school other than the career center. Never heard of them joining an extracurricular either other than a sports team. Are you sure this is a thing? Which classes have HB kids taken at the neighborhood high schools? |
Having an entire high school smaller than a single GRADE at WL is pretty good trade of being an “outsider” on your team, from many parents eyes |
The actual number of students in an average class is not any smaller than at the other schools. Just the overall size of each grade cohort is smaller. It is not like private school at all. |