South Mountain Creamery delivery--what's good?

[Anonymous]

The chocolate milk is incredible.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:The coffee cake is delicious

Just about to say this! We get it on Tuesday and it barely makes it to Wednesday! I had a long time ago their canned peaches that were really good ( not sure if it was made by them though) Haven't seen it since but, it might because of the season.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:The chocolate milk is incredible.

My kids didn't like it. They got used to Horizon chocolate milk. So, not universal love

[Anonymous]

We use the chocolate milk to make freezer pops - tastes just like the fudgsicles I remember as a kid! So easy and the kids love them. Tell Tale dark roast coffee, American cheese (great for grilled cheese and cheesy broccoli), and of course milk and eggs.

[Anonymous]

We love the milk, half and half, and chocolate milk. Great idea about the freezer pops! Will have to try it

[Anonymous]

Cream top milk and banana chocolate chunk bread. Mmmmm.

[Anonymous]

So how long does it take to move off waiting list?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Don’t get the cheese.

What ice cream flavors do you like? I’ve only had two, but they were waaaay too sweet.

+1 My kids like the ice cream, but DH and I can't eat due to the sweetness. I wish they'd make a lower sugar option, same with the yogurt.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:So how long does it take to move off waiting list?

I tried to sign up in the beginning of Covid when I was trying out various food delivery options. They weren't taking any new customers at that time. I received an email about two weeks ago saying I had been added.
I am enjoying it, and now that I have a few more recommendations, will branch out a little more and try some different things. Currently, options are limited--they may offer produce boxes one week, meat boxes the next. That works fine for me, but every single thing is not available every single week.
That milk though....I don't even like milk and it is so much better than buying it at the grocery store. Adding that half & half to my coffee takes it to a whole new level!

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Tipping is a new construct but I give $5/week now that it's an option (we did it at the holidays before)

Dairy, especially half and half and american cheese (and I use the instant pot to turn their whole milk into yogurt). We get bread too. Got a box of grilling stuff around the 4th that was incredible. You can't really go wrong, but the dairy and meat especially are divine. We've gotten salads and meals too when the hometown harvest stuff sounds appealing and they are also excellent.

The selection right now is a fraction of what they had pre-pandemic

+1

Does the tip go right to the driver?

anyone know this? Do you tip each week or just when you have a fussy assortment of stuff?

[Anonymous]

The milk is lovely. But having a supply of farmer's market eggs has been so so good -- they are so much fresher than supermarket eggs.

[Anonymous]

Eggs and milk have been great. We’ve enjoyed the beef and chicken. DH loves the beef jerky. The ice cream is delicious.

We tip $5 each week.

[Anonymous]

Coffee cake delivered at 5 am and gone by noon.

[Anonymous]

Love the milk, butter, eggs, and cheeses. Cinnamon bread is great, and we have been happy with the meat we've ordered.

Did not like the ice cream. Have not heard great things about the meals, but haven't tried them.

[Anonymous]

Love the milk, choco milk, lemonade, coffee cake, and eggs. We order that weekly. The pizza crusts and cheeses have been good too. We tried the ice cream. It was good but I’m still a fan of talenti. We did order ice cream this week as box 2 had diff flavors than last time. We haven’t tried the produce yet as I’m already getting a weekly CSA box. We’ve been tipping $5 a week.