I’ve heard the PP’s message before- that it’s better to try alcohol in high school than college. And absolutely there were kids who went wild with the freedom. But lots and lots kids drink heavily in college and I’ve seen no evidence that trying alcohol in HS minimizes college binge drinking. |
I disagree. I grew up in a super conservative Baptist school/church community. When my classmates graduated and went to college they all lost their minds: it was drinking, drugs and sex 24/7. Heck, they even went gambling. If there was a vice to be had, they through themselves into it. It's 100% made me parent with more moderation. I know my kids have had alcohol (11th grade twins). I'm completely okay with this. My son has been drunk. He was miserable. That was 6 months ago (age 16.5) at a party. He hasn't had more than a single beer once or twice since. I wait up for when he gets home (believe me, when a teenager has had alcohol you can tell). We talk about drinking, sex, etc all the time. |
This is an extreme environment. |
I also grew up in a super conservative, Baptist area. My city was a dry city, so they only sold alcohol at bars (no stores within city limits). My friends did not all go crazy when they went off to college - a few did, most didn’t. I certainly didn’t. My DH’s parents looked the other way when he drank on HS. He still drank to excess in college regularly. My parents were super strict in HS and I only drank too much twice in college. I can’t believe you think your parenting approach on drinking is working when your child got drunk at 16.5 years. |
LMAO! Right! The evidence of the fallacy in her logic is staring at her plainly in the face, meanwhile, she's patting herself on the back for not being a "strict parent," as she's convinced that since her kid got drunk in high school under her watch, there's no way he'll do that and more once he goes to college. That's some seriously pretzel-like logic. |
Do you all have some stats, or any expertise on the subject, or are we just proffering competing anecdotes and declaring ourselves right and superior? Because we ALL have the anecdotes. Yours doesn't mean that you are right and the other PP wrong, or vice versa. |
Yes, yes, and yes to all this. Although I might strike "borderline." |
This is good news, indeed! Please let this go viral and serve as an example to any other degenerate like-minded "parents"! |
If you care to Google the subject, you'll find a wealth of material on the subject. Here's a quick one for you, since you can't be bothered:
https://www.niaaa.nih.gov/publications/brochures-and-fact-sheets/underage-drinking#:~:text=Increases%20the%20risk%20of%20alcohol,(AUD)%20later%20in%20life. |
NP. Your line of thinking is just as illogical as the parent who hosted the party. A college freshman is still underage but with even less of a scaffold while at college. I don’t support my child drinking, but I’d rather we have conversations about how to handle this and they have a beer every once in awhile than start in college. You’re just one other side of the spectrum in the gradient of extremes. |
Sorry, but you DO support teen drinking if your conversations are along the lines of your post. Tell yourself whatever you want but you are setting them up for a struggle with substance abuse for their whole life. |
I "can't be bothered" b/c I'm not making the assertion. This is one set of stats, which is helpful, for sure. But doesn't translate into "if you drink in HS you will binge in college." |
|
2218x PP
It’s also the mindset that HS is the new college. HS students now behave similar to college students and are encouraged by parents. Look at the pregaming before HS football games (parents and students), how proms and dances are as elaborate and as expensive as sorority and fraternity functions (party bus, sleepovers, after parties). Even HS graduation parties are boozy with parents and families combining forces and throwing huge backyard catered parties for multiple graduates. These parties always include an open bar and coolers of beer and wine seltzer. Don’t get me started on Beach Week. Parents provide alcohol, stock fridges and even stay nearby to “chaperone” and then look the other way and drive kids to the ER, pay lost security deposits, intervene w/ landlords, rent the house in their names. All done in the name of “preparation for college.” The parents think they are doing their kids huge favors! The adults get to relive their crazy college days alongside their kids! |
NP. It’s really not. This is our household, too. |
Bless your heart. My stance is very moderate. I do not support teen drinking, especially not in excess. I do not support drunk driving. Your response is also extreme. Things are not black and white. You’re setting yourself up for a very strained relationship with your child, very likely when they’re an adult. |