Okay. However, I still don't 'get' why you can't just sit there and do what they want to do. You're a guest in their house. You are visiting. Can't you flex a little and go along to get along? Why does it have to be your way or the highway? I don't understand people like you, so caught up in being you that you don't see that you're part of a larger framework. There is something wrong with you if you can't show your husband's parents a little grace while you're visiting them. |
OP here. When it comes to us visiting their home, These are multi-day visits in a very small house in a small town. We do lots of things with them--go for walks, go to the playground, go to the little shops on the main street, go out for lunch, go to church, etc. And we do literally sit and talk with them for hours. But after spending all day together, it simply is not rude for me to allow my oldest daughter to call her friend back, or allow my youngest daughter to read a book, or for me to finally have 20 minutes to look through a cooking magazine. It's just not. We do--we honestly do--spend 90% of the day with them. Are you so rigid with your guests? If so, you should know that guests value downtime, a few minutes to relax, a few minutes on their own. Expecting 100% togetherness all the time during a visit is...exhausting, frankly. Do you do this to your guests? And when it comes to being in our home, we do of course spend the majority of the day with them, but again, I'm not going to tell my daughters they can't play with their Christmas gifts or go ride their bikes/scooters, because it is objectively not rude to not spend literally every second with houseguests. And when we share vacation rentals with them: it's our vacation, too. If DD1 wants to go to the kite shop with my husband, they shouldn't have to stay home because grandma and grandpa aren't interested in that particular activity. |
Okay. However, I still don't 'get' why you can't just let someone have some time to themself and do what they want to do. They're a guest in your house. You are hosting them. Can't you flex a little and go along to get along? Why does it have to be your way or the highway? I don't understand people like you, so caught up in controlling everyone that you don't see that you are part of a larger framework. There is something wrong with you if you can't show your guests a little grace when they are visiting you. |
|
Ugh I have no idea but my ILs are like this and it is awful. I grew up in an active family with a mix of introverts and extroverts- grandparents had a big beach house where extended family would come and go, everyone doing different activities or relaxing on their own. So nice.
With my ILs all they want to do is sit around and talk. At least now we have little kids who go stir crazy after 30 minutes of that so we have an excuse to do something other than sit there. When we would visit them I felt like we had no choice because I didn't want to be rude, but that was also their expectation when they would visit us- God forbid we get some fresh air and go for a walk (together even!) or go somewhere else. The only explanation I can come up with is that they do not like to be active and they need us to give them maximum attention which is less likely to happen if there is an activity going on. |
|
Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on me. If no one is willing to speak up and tell them they're complete jerks... then you get what you deserve, OP. |
Your DH needs to answer "she's resting". And then if his mother calls you rude, he needs to say "no, it is not rude to rest on vacation or during a visit". Then, move on. DONE. He also needs to not tell you about this exchange later and to run interference if his mother tries to go find you or the like. |
| I have no idea, OP, but visiting your ILs sounds absolutely miserable. I love my family and we all love to talk but even so I definitely need breaks and alone time with them! I guess extroverts...? I can't imagine not understanding that someone might need to not be constantly engaging with other people. |
I would see them less and let your DH go visit on his own. Or I would just work on NOT caring that they seem to think this is "rude" when it's normal behavior. |
|
This thread is interesting. My mom is like this. She's 100% extrovert, loves family gatherings, is full of energy, somewhat controlling, and can't understand why others would want a break. She's terrific, but it took me a long time to understand that she really, really doesn't understand introverts...which is particularly funny because my dad is an introvert. He loves social gatherings and can be the life of the party, but he definitely needs his recharge time.
I've finally learned to either hide out in my room having a long afternoon "nap" (for some reason, afternoon napping is acceptable, but sleeping in late in the mornings is considered lazy), or to excuse myself to another room saying, "gotta recharge my introvert batteries, mom!" She still doesn't get it, I don't think, but it's better now. |
Nailed it! I see what you did there. And I love it.
|
You see, this is why people don't like you and why you don't have friends. You sound like a complete pill. Frankly, if I were your inlaws, I would gladly let you and your kids go elsewhere. You don't sound like a very nice person and certainly you don't have any manners.
DP |
|
My mother is this way; demands all eyes on her and that there be zero silence. She is beyond annoying and very controlling. We stopped taking family vacations with her but she displays this self focused behavior during visits to her house and car trips.
Will not stop talking. Will hand me magazines to take home but tells me to read them later. She then gets out a hand written list which prompts her to tell me everything on the list-usually about neighbors and relatives and people she knows. Exhaustively detailed information. I mentioned to her long ago about how when one of my friends vacationed with her ILs, she loved nothing more than sitting on their back porch and reading, alone. My mom proclaimed that the height of rudeness. |
|
I think it depends on the length of the visit.
A 2 hour visit: everyone hangs out together or in smaller groups An all day visit or several day visit: yeah, people can go and do their own thing |
This person is a pill because all of the points you made can easily be made another way? You sound like a crotchety old loon. Are you feeling alright, grandma? |
| If you are only visiting for a couple hours, pulling out a book or magazine or phone is rude. If you are there for a day or more, people need a break sometime! |