not my family Dad came in '47 with a trade, and he learned English in a year AND joined the military. He started three businesses, too, and built a nice lifestyle for the family. Not all immigrants are the same. |
Not true. This administration started from day one to implement tighter border security. Again. What are your brilliant ideas to address this crisis? I haven't seen a single one. |
+1 In addition just because we did things in a certain way in the past doesn't mean we have to continue those things if they don't make sense. |
Things are very different today as compared to 1947. |
False. Dems support more of those things than you claim. Dems have been supportive of more judges, more tech at the border, et cetera. But instead we just got this Trumpian stuff about a big shiny wall without tech, no judges, et cetera. Republicans had an opportunity to do good and get a lot of things that both sides could support, but instead squandered it by just mindlessly tribally rallying behind Trump's nonsense. |
This is an understatement. In 1947, the US determined who was granted entry in the US. That is not the case today. Estimates are there are upward of 16 million illegal aliens in the US. Some estimates are as high as 22 million. Of course, with our laws the way they are.... we aren't even able to come up with a reasonable, accurate estimate. |
This is such a BS statement. The plan has ALWAYS been to include technology, personnel, and more space for detentions. Where is the world are you getting your information? |
In 1947 my Asian family would not have been allowed to immigrate here due to quotas from "undesirable" countries. Lots of Trump supporters seem to want to go back to the quota system. |
DP, no... that was not *ALWAYS* the plan. Trump only *ever* mentioned the wall, and that MX would pay for it. After much derision from even his own party members about MX paying for the wall, and other border security experts and Dems stating that we need high tech and more personnel, that is when Trump's tune changed. |
You are uninformed if you think the wall is the only thing Republicans/this administration has tried since 2017 to address border security. Read a newspaper people! |
Exactly. This is the line that CNN and MSNBC have been pushing. "The wall" is all they talk about even though tech and personnel have been included from the beginning. January, 2018:
https://www.cnn.com/2018/01/05/politics/border-security-billions-trump-wall/index.html |
You are uninformed if you think Trump originally talked about anything other than the wall or that he wanted funding for anything else other than the wall originally. I never mentioned Rs in general. |
Again, his message morphed after much derision over the wall. |
You should study how the US immigration system works. There are now per-country ceilings for how many immigrants are allowed in. This is a de facto quota system as many of the countries like India hit their ceiling fairly easily due to the large number of immigrants. There is also the diversity visa program which grants visas at random to countries that are under-represented in US immigrant demographics, again a pure quota system. So quotas already exist in the US immigration system, you now need to decide whether you are for or against quotas that are not based on merit but the home country of the immigrant. As a Trump supporter I don't want quotas like these, I prefer a more purely merit based system. |
DP. You seem to be talking only about his campaign rhetoric. That is not what we're talking about. Beyond his words on the campaign trail, it has always been about an all encompassing fix. |