Why are you being so defensive? I never said that kids who go to JMU don't love it. In fact, I know they do. I know a million kids who went to JMU and have no regrets. It's a great school. What I said is that, for many kids who attend Yorktown/McLean/Langley, having their college acceptances top out at JMU is a disappointment AT THE TIME. We are talking about competitive high schools with pushy parents and high achieving kids, with many gunning for highly ranked colleges. Yes, in the end they will all discover that it doesn't really matter and that a few years down the road nobody will care where you went to college. But that's not what many kids and parents are thinking AT THE TIME. I remain convinced that that is the primary driver behind OP's daughter not being "excited" about her college options. They're not instagram worthy. But, again, she'll get over it. |
Sounds like miserable schools and parents. |
| 3.5 gpa doesn't mean much, is it weighted , all aps, no aps , de etc |
Those are some great options. Have her pick the one she likes best and odds are a year from now she will be happy and loving life. None of this matters once the kids start college in the fall. |
Maybe. Maybe not. But you're clearly just another poster from outside the area who doesn't really understand the dynamics and can't really offer informed advice. |
Not relevant. |
USNWR ranking started this mess. Parents become obsessed with it and then it trickles down to the kids. The best thing the OP should do is reassure their kid that she is loved and that they believe in her. The rankings are bullshXX! |
This is very true. DS did not get into UVA. Got in at VT, IU, and JMU. Almost picked IU and loans because of the perceived what will people say factor. Did not like VT. In the end picked JMU and being loan free. Now that he is there and thriving and making friends from everywhere (other than high school) that worry is long gone. Go to admitted students day at the 3 colleges she likes best. Tell her to make a choice and not to look back |
DP. And which of the above three schools do your kids actually attend? The PP is right. You are clearly making up a lot of nonsense. You stated: “There's a lot of disappointment and feeling like a failure if you're not UVA, W&M, or a top private.” That’s just utter BS and if you had kids at these schools, you’d know that. |
More like a troll making up a narrative about schools she has no firsthand knowledge of. |
|
Indiana University is a wonderful school and has the most beautiful campus. Top business, music school, liberal arts.. However, it's BIG so if she is not into that, the school won't be for her.
Nothing wrong with any of the schools she gained entry to. |
Can we stop with the misogynistic put downs? Thanks. |
|
not reading this whole thing, but my advice is go to Indiana and if she's a kid who looks back at high school thinking, I coulda/shoulda done a lot better, tell her if she crushes Indiana, she has very good odds to transfer to Vandy or ND, both with very good transfer rates and both like Indiana kids.
odds are she ends up loving Indiana |
If your kid's only expectation is JMU, I'm sure they will be happy. |
You missed the whole point of the conversation. |