DP here. VA students routinely use UVA as a safety. Why is that a surprise? |
Routinely? Maybe the top .01%. You must live in a bubble. Good for you. Down here, in the trenches, admission to UVA is never a given, much the contrary. I am not saying UVA is the BEST school, but many parents seem to be quite disappointed when their kids do not get in. We were jumping with joy when our kid got in, and grateful for the in-state tuition, which is still a lot for our family. |
+1. Thanks so much for sharing that experience! This type of post is what keeps me on DCUM when so much of it has become uninformed trolly posts. |
+1 |
My W&M kid was accepted at both--I think when he applied UVA had early action only not early decision. So he did early action UVA and RD W&M (or something like that) and then had to decide. My UVA kid did not want to go to school where his older brother was at and applied only to UVA -I think early decision, but maybe it was early action? I'm just guessing he would have gotten in at W&M though also since UVA is generally a harder admit and the naviance at his school showed only green checks where his scores were at. I think now that ED is even more firmly established at both schools, people choose which school is their ED so it's less common to have people get accepted at both--they choose one to ED and then if they don't get in, go for the other. |
|
Back in the day I had two daughters accepted at UVA but both were only waitlisted at W&M. It was fine because UVA was the first choice for both so whatever.
Also, I laugh at the implication that W&M is better because it either is or is perceived to be more “rigorous” (god I hate that word, which is so overused on DCUM). Even if it is, that’s not necessarily a good thing. |
This board is pathological where UVA is concerned. I attended UNC OOS, had no interest in the school, and didn’t love the people I met when our pledge class visited the UVA chapter. Neither my kid nor any of his friends (as far as I know) applied. BUT - it is undoubtedly a great school with a very strong alumni community. UVA grads can be a little tiresome in their pride in their alma mater, but so what - UNC fans are the same way, and UNC is a school that caps OOS admissions and treated academics for student athletes with utter contempt for many years (an incredible disservice to both the school’s reputation and the athletes). If tarheel alums can be proud, UVA alums have much more of a right to be. |
|
My daughter is a third year at UVA. Neither my husband or myself attended there (both went to other colleges not in VA). My daughter likes it just fine, but it's definitely not an ideal school for everyone. Academically, I think it's pretty challenging, but she went to an academically challenging private high school so she's handling the workload just fine. But, it is a tough place to socially adjust.
I do think it gets a lot of hate on here and other DC chat boards for a variety of reasons: maybe you've met someone who seems "too proud" of their UVA alumni status (although for me some of the nicest people I know went to UVA), maybe you're upset your kid didn't get in (I would have been perfectly fine with my daughter at a different school but some people do seem to be very bitter that UVA didn't take their kid), maybe you hate the colors navy and orange together..... It's a great school at a great value to in-state residents (although we are very fortunate that we could afford to send our daughter anywhere in the country), but there are a lot of great schools. The best school is the one your child fits in best academically and socially. |
I'm the PP who wrote about my two kids at UVA and W&M. I wasn't claiming at all that W&M is "better" because the classes are more rigorous--just that my kids when comparing it found that to be the case in their personal experience (and other posters seemed to agree). I'm sure my eldest found the rigor frustrating at times because he had to do more work than his brother. I personally value having tough classes with supportive professors--as long as the toughness isn't pointless or arbitrary and is helping you build meaningful skills. But I can also see that it can get stressful when you have too many of those in one semester, so you need balance too. And sometimes it was frustrating for my W&M kid to have a class that he was taking outside of his major area to be one of the core requirements end up being a really killer workload. (One good thing to note about W&M, is that while they are tough graders, they will let you retroactively decide a couple of courses over your four years to be pass/fail if you bombed them--this helps them keep the standards high without totally killing everyone's GPA). |
Maybe a tiny percentage of students once did (who are opting for Ivies or top SLACs) but that certainly isn't the case anymore. It's now a very tough admit. |
Whoa. you are clearly new to college admissions. Many passed $90K last year (USC is $92). My own mid-level slac is now $86K and definitely not worth it. |
|
UVa is a safety for good students. |
because it can mean a savings of $50K+ a year if you comparing to SLACs at $92K. For in-state parents, it's like winning a financial lottery of sorts. UVA College of Arts & Sciences, all-in, is $37K. We were facing that so thrilled when DC got in. We invested the difference and can now afford grad school/law school for DC. |
Okay, troll. How do you define (quantitatively) "good students"? |