Zohran Mamdani...

[Anonymous]

If a sitting president can openly muse about arresting and disappearing someone who is likely to become mayor of the country's largest city, while also getting the funding for a massive secret police, it'd be hard to find sufficient evidence to qualify that country as a democracy.

[Anonymous]

New Yorkers always hate the mayor and blame the mayor for "New York not being the same" or "crime and homelessness". Issues that go together with NYC like peanut butter and jelly.

To slander him in advance just will increase his popularity with the youth

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Mamdami learned from the Democratic party failures in the 2024 presidential election. You have to listen to the young people.

The young people told Biden and Harris that if they didn't speak out against Israel, they wouldn't vote for them...and they did not vote for them.

Also, if you get on BlueSky and TikTok where most Gen Z and Millennials are communicating, you'll realize the young people have learned a valuable lesson: there are more of us than old people. If we band together and vote, we can get the candidate we want who will enact the policies we want. Older generations roll their eyes at millennials, but we are the most educated generation and also the generation with the least (in terms of wealth, real estate holdings, and kids). We are also one of the most well-traveled generations. We've been to other places in the world and seen how the citizens of other countries live better than us because of proper taxation of the wealthy and corporations. We have learned that we could have all that in the US if our government simply taxed the rich and corporations at appropriate rates.

Also, just for reference, because for some reason reason people on DCUM have it perpetually stuck in their heads that Gen Z are teenagers and Millennials are 20-somethings, here are the official age breakdowns:

Baby Boomers: 1946-1964 (ages 79-61)
Gen X: 1965-1980 (ages 60-45)
Millennials: 1981-1996 (ages 44-29)
Gen Z: 1997-2012 (ages 28-13)

I'm 43. I make more right now than both of my parents did combined at this age. I don't own a house. I live with a partner, but we are not married. We do not want kids because of the cost of everything. My parents owned a house, 2 cars, and took 3 kids on 2-3 vacations each year when they were in their 40s and they did that on the salaries of a tow truck driver and an office admin.

43 is not “young”. You are middle aged (as am I, also 43).

Your observations are generally correct and applicable to millennials (but not universal; I enjoy a much better standard of living than my parents did, I am married and I have 3 kids). ZM is not going to deliver a standard of living you seek, and, if his policy proposals are actually implemented, it will make your problems worse.

NP here. Do you not think there is an affordability and housing crisis in our country? That fact seems undeniable to me and should not be surprising given the energy of the occupy wall street movement over a decade ago and the growing inequality since then. So if there are problems with affordability/housing, why not try to some ideas? What I find refreshing about Mamdani is that he does not seem wed to ideology - listen to him talk about his grocery stores. It's one in each borough (which can be funded through existing city food programs) and he outright says if it doesn't work, then he will close them. Food deserts are a huge issue that the private sector has not tried so why not experiment with a public sector solution?

PP.

Yes, there is a housing/affordability crisis. The problem with “trying ideas” is that it can make problems much worse and destroy capital, making the road to recovery that much harder. Look at California: they’ve tried many ideas for making housing affordable and it’s only gotten worse and they are in a deeper hole. Most of ZM’s proposals will make the problems worse. The answer is and will continue to be more supply, but ZM isn’t going near that. Instead he’s proposing ideas that have been proven to fail.

To be fair, as much as I disagree with him about most things, his idea to let property tax valuations float to be more aligned with market value is a correct position.

The grocery store issue does highlight how he can make problems worse as well as the incoherence of his positions.

There is no such thing as just trying changes to an economic ecosystem. Once you introduce the government stores it will be extremely difficult to get rid of them and they will destabilize the economic system. Whoever runs them will be incentivized to expand their footprint/mandate. While the bodegas are a real problem, grocery stores have notoriously thin margins and undercutting them on price will be destabilizing.

ZM simultaneously believes that greedy capitalists will exploit everyone but for some reason food deserts exist where capitalists don’t go do business. Perhaps his mental model is off….

How does 5 grocery stores (one in each burrough in food desserts where there are no private grocery stores operating) risk “destabilizing the economic system”?

And, why might there be food deserts in the city? Is it because crime drove businesses that used to be there out? If so, how do you think these government run grocery stores will fare?

And, as to your question.....

Economists and business leaders are sounding alarms over New York City mayoral candidate Zohran Mamdani’s plan to roll out city-owned grocery stores that he says will lower food costs.

"You don’t lower grocery bills by having government-run stores," Ryan Bourne, a top economist at the libertarian leaning Cato Institute think tank, told Fox Business. "Government-run entities have no market discipline — no need to earn profits, compete, or serve customers efficiently. That leads to bloated costs, empty shelves, and zero accountability."

Bourne called Mamdani's city-run grocery stores "the height of political hubris" by failing to acknowledge that grocers operate in competitive arenas and on razor-thin profit margins.

"If we just do the simple math here, there's no way you can sell these products at lower prices and still make money," said E.J. Antoni, chief economist at the conservative leaning Heritage Foundation think tank.

"The other problem is that if he (Mamdani) is selling things substantially less than the private market, who is going to want to go to the private market? Everyone is going to want to go to these grocery stores," Antoni told Fox Business, adding that the city-run grocery stores have the potential to exacerbate food shortages in New York City.

"If the government is going to make it impossible for the private market to compete, then the private market will stop competing. If you make it unprofitable for a grocer to do business in Manhattan, then people like John Catsimatidis are going to pull the plug," Antoni said, referencing the billionaire supermarket magnate.

In an interview with Fox Business, Catsimatidis said retail food was the toughest company in his Red Apple Group portfolio, which also includes real estate, energy and insurance assets.

"If the city of New York is going socialist, I will definitely close, or sell, or move or franchise the Gristedes locations," he said. Catsimatidis, a high-profile political donor in conservative circles, operates more than 15 Gristedes and nearly a dozen D'Agostino grocery stores in Manhattan.

"It’s going to hurt New York," Catsimatidis said of Mamdani's economic agenda should he win the November general election. He added that he is considering moving his corporate offices to New Jersey if that happens.

https://www.foxbusiness.com/politics/mamdanis-public-grocery-stores-may-have-devastating-effects-citys-food-supply

I live in Manhattan and didn’t vote for Mamdani, but… have you ever been to a Gristedes or D’Agostino? It would not be a loss if they all shut down. They are all extortionately priced and somehow still gross. Even Whole Foods is at least 25-40% cheaper. I would love for the free market to deal with them.

This news actually makes me like Mamdani more.

This was just an example. You think Whole Foods will stay? It will soon be like those pictures of the Soviet grocery stores with a scale and empty counters and a line of babushkas waiting for that one type of meat that is available today.

I actually live in Manhattan. You think one little city grocery in each borough will cause WF to leave? lol. You have no clue about NYC

Why are we as Americans so programmed against helping the poor but ok with helping the rich?

Because entitlements make recipients demand more entitlements. No end in sight. To the dependency, lack of accountability, lack of work ethic.

The poor already get tons of help in America. They are net recipients of tons of welfare, housing, snap food, smartphones, Medicaid healthcare, donations, public assistance and don’t pay federal taxes. The bottom 40% of incomes don’t pay in. And if you work off the books or make nothing, obviously you don’t either.

It pales in comparison to the money we pour out for corporations, the military industrial complex, and rich people. It's also an embarrassment compared to social services in every other western democracy.

Interesting how you think social services make poor people lazy, unmotivated, and entitled, but it somehow doesn't work that way for the wealthy. 🤔

Most people know entitlements (something for nothing) breeds more spoiled entitled attitudes.

Great example is illegal immigrants. Break immigration laws by crossing the border, buy fraudulent IDs, get cash pay jobs and avoid income taxes, shove your illiterate kids at the public schools mid year as baby sitters, demand welfare for your anchor babies, remit billions for more illegal chain migration of our cousins, demand more and more from USA. Entitlement attitude.
Best is how they trash rock creek park and MoCo parks every weekend with their 50 people cook outs and leave all the garbage out.

Agreed. Foreign invaders with ENTITLEMENT ATTITUDE need to go home. Come back the legal way our parents did, and you work to get whatever you want, just like our parents did.

You so obviously have never stepped foot in NYC

Used to live there. My parents did work for everything they had. They expected no handouts from the government.

Did you go to public school for any point in K-12? That's a handout from the government!

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:If a sitting president can openly muse about arresting and disappearing someone who is likely to become mayor of the country's largest city, while also getting the funding for a massive secret police, it'd be hard to find sufficient evidence to qualify that country as a democracy.

Mamdani's win is proof of democracy.

[Anonymous]

https://www.nytimes.com/2025/07/01/nyregion/mamdani-wins-mayor-primary-nyc.html

From the article:
“In the end, Mr. Mamdani won primarily thanks to first-place rankings among white, Hispanic, and Asian voters, as well as middle- and higher-income voters. Mr. Cuomo won among Black and lower-income voters.”

For all those people who think Mamdani won by fooling the youth and getting votes from people who want freebies.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:The current system is broken, and the quality of life, work/life balance and financial security is just not there for many Americans.

Thank gawd for nail salons, hair extensions, iphones, social media, and Tier III colleges! Otherwise I might do something.

Yet another example for why millennials and Gen Z hate Gen X and boomers.
They are doing more than you by knocking on doors and voting in record numbers for a candidate the dinosaurs and establishment media trashed.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Not surprised and to be fair be fair, the other candidates are running for Mayor of Tel Aviv.

As for Cuomo, hope his victims get justice. Justice for the more-than-a-dozen women he sexually assaulted

Justice for the 15,000 seniors who were killed because Cuomo forced COVID-positive patients to move back to nursing homes and infect other seniors

Justice for NYers, who deserve a mayor who will prioritize affordability, instead of a mayor bought by DoorDash, big real estate, and billlionaires - who want to take more money out of people's pockets

I hope Mamdani wins and:

dismantles the police
turns empty stores in the subway into homeless shelters
opens state run grocery stores that will run other chains (like Gristede's) out of NYC
taxes the rich so they move to Florida, depleting the city's tax base

As long as he hates Israel, who cares, amirite?

Obviously, he wants to DISMANTLE the ENTIRE New York City. His base never lived under Communism, so how would they know anything?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Here is what I don't understand about Mamdani's vision. I love his charisma, but when socialist leaders come into power, it is usually for an entire nation, not just one city. And they have the backing of the military to force the country to go along with socialism. Without that type of force, the educated and successful people in the private sector would leave. If Mamdani makes NYC socialist, but the rest of the country remains free, I don't understand why the 1% would choose to stay in NY to support free child care, free bus fare, etc. for everyone else. what is their incentive to stay?

No hedge fund manager or trust fund baby - the core of Manhattan - is moving because of a minor increase in local taxes. Mamdani's policies are much more impactful for the MC and UMC. Rent control - that is a very big deal in NYC. That's the local government choosing winners and losers. And that's been pretty disastrous overall for most people. When you take all those apartments off the market rate, it vastly increases the costs for new renters. Getting rid of rent control and building new housing is much more effective, but progressives don't like that for lots of reasons. And defunding the police is obviously very consequential. NYC toys with out of control violence from time to time - and that is very impactful for everyone. Obviously there needs to be a balance between addressing social, mental health, and addiction issues and dealing with violent crime. But that's not a straightforward thing. Social workers will get murdered if that's the first response. You can't legislate these things.

My sense of Mamdani is that he is a very privileged young man with an enormous ego. He's never had a 9-5 job in his life, so he doesn't get that struggle at all. He seems like a TikTok guy - hate the Jews, be performative about everything. Not a serious man. Even for a 33 year old, which these days are generally big babies with an extended adolescence that goes on and on. I really don't think a guy like this is going to win Staten Island, Queens, most of Brooklyn, or the Bronx. Mamdani has zero connection with the working and middle class - which is the norm for Democrats these days and why they continue to lose.

[Anonymous]

We routinely get threads here about people with HHI's of 250k or higher complaining about life being unaffordable. Imagine how a family with a HHI of 100k or 60k feels.

Mamdani spoke directly to the kitchen table issues/concerns people are worried about and it's not LGBT, abortion, and saving our democracy like Democrats think: price of childcare, price of groceries, price of transportation, raising the minimum wage. He didn't just acknowledge the pain, he brought solutions to the table that everyone is talking about. If we are talking about it, that means New Yorkers certainly knew and were fired up about it as well. THIS is how you run a campaign that is engaging.

[Anonymous]

Will the Democrats take note? Of course not.

[Anonymous]

16:46 wins the most insightful post of the day.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:16:46 wins the most insightful post of the day.

Correction: 15:46.

[Anonymous]

If you made 100k every day for 2,000 years, you would still fall short from Elon.

Spare the tears for the billionaires.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:It's already imploded. Everybody decamped to Miami.

NYC is already drowning in debt, while Florida has zero debt. Why?

Of course Mamdani isn’t showing anyone exactly how his communist agenda will be funded. His voters are too stupid to see he’s a complete FRAUD.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:It's already imploded. Everybody decamped to Miami.

NYC is already drowning in debt, while Florida has zero debt. Why?

Of course Mamdani isn’t showing anyone exactly how his communist agenda will be funded. His voters are too stupid to see he’s a complete FRAUD.

Florida is a sh!thole.