S/o - what should caring white people do?

Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:Sorry, but I find the white girl savior thing to be kind of cringe inducing and patronizing.


I’m Jewish, and although I don’t compare being Jewish in America today to being black...I am well aware that’s not a comparison...when acts of anti-semitism happen, I find it comforting to hear non Jewish people condemn those acts.

I don’t think I’m anyone’s savior. But I do hope if I make it clear that I don’t support racism, it makes it more uncomfortable for other people to be racist.

Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:Sorry, but I find the white girl savior thing to be kind of cringe inducing and patronizing.


Except that’s not what that was. It was white people showing up for black people and taking action at the request of black people. The protests have been organized that way.

White saviors show up unannounced and unwanted to save the poor minorities from the fresh hells of white imagination. White allies show up when invited and follow without trying to lead or center themselves.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:Sorry, but I find the white girl savior thing to be kind of cringe inducing and patronizing.


There's real racism, and a need for everyone to try to fight it, and for black people to take charge in confronting whoever or whatever is really causing the problems, when that's possible.

And there are also people of all types, including black people, who are arrogant, entitled, mean people, and who use racist oppression as an excuse to be as mean as they probably would be if they were rich white people, or middle-income Asian people.

You think you're speaking up for black people and opposing The Man and saying your say, or whatever, but you're also really mean.

You're probably as mean to the black people around you as you are to the white people. You may not even know that, because you've terrorized them into silence by being really mean.

If you ever get real power, you'll be very mean, and you'll create a mean power structure that happens to be led by you, instead of by a white person.

I think a lot of us are trying to accommodate you, because we want for the world to be better. But accommodating you is actually as wrong as accommodating a toxic white racist. You're just two sides of the same cruel coin.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Sorry, but I find the white girl savior thing to be kind of cringe inducing and patronizing.


Except that’s not what that was. It was white people showing up for black people and taking action at the request of black people. The protests have been organized that way.

White saviors show up unannounced and unwanted to save the poor minorities from the fresh hells of white imagination. White allies show up when invited and follow without trying to lead or center themselves.


Yeah, the white savior label seems to be a better fit for the evangelical types who think they need to go to parts of the world they consider "uncivilized" and convert them to Christianity. At the end of the day it is self-serving. I think a lot of white people genuinely want to do the right thing right now, and don't care if they receive attention or adulation from it. They are realizing that none of this changes if they don't get involved because they are the ones who have upheld it, not because they think they need to "save" black people.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Sorry, but I find the white girl savior thing to be kind of cringe inducing and patronizing.


I’m Jewish, and although I don’t compare being Jewish in America today to being black...I am well aware that’s not a comparison...when acts of anti-semitism happen, I find it comforting to hear non Jewish people condemn those acts.

I don’t think I’m anyone’s savior. But I do hope if I make it clear that I don’t support racism, it makes it more uncomfortable for other people to be racist.



Agreed. As a Muslim-American I appreciate words of solidarity from non-Muslims when islamophobic events happen (think: New Zealand mosque massacre and the like). We must all unite and show solidarity.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Show up. Join the marchers. Be peaceful. Put your body between the police and people of color. Speak up when people make racists comments. Don't just be passive. Write letters to your representatives that you want reforms to ensure the safety and well being of ALL citizens during police interactions. Support affirmative action.


Didnt you post this earlier?

Lady, you are crazy and stubborn as hell.

Nobody is going to be a human shield for you!


vice versa man.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Sorry, but I find the white girl savior thing to be kind of cringe inducing and patronizing.


Except that’s not what that was. It was white people showing up for black people and taking action at the request of black people. The protests have been organized that way.

White saviors show up unannounced and unwanted to save the poor minorities from the fresh hells of white imagination. White allies show up when invited and follow without trying to lead or center themselves.


+ every one of the hundreds of Black relative, peer, colleague, friend, i know. If I think to everyone at my wedding, no one would be so proud as to not welcome a champion from a white woman. That is a strong voice of influence that has been studied and written about since slavery was abolished.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Start reading. Start understanding just what white privilege is, how white supremacy is baked into the cake of America. Listen to black people talk about their experiences without getting defensive. Support black owned businesses and restaurants. Don’t center yourself. I’m tired and listening to the eerie silence (but blessed) in my curfewed neighborhood, so I’ll just say, of all things, Estee Laundry had a great post on this today.

I’m sure our friendly white supremacist posters will helpfully tell me I’m speaking gibberish, and I still consider myself a neophyte about this, but it’s up to us to change things. It’s not up to black people to fix the power structure they didn’t build and still have no comparative power in. If you and I have no influence or power, statistically speaking we still have more than the average black citizen.


Yes, get to work. If you have kids you should really be doing what you can to learn about racism in America--its been part of our country since the beginning and we need to do our part to eradicate it. Here are some books to help: White Fragility by DiAngelo, So

If you have kids make sure you buys books about people of color. If you don't know where to start look up books by Jason Reynolds, Kwame Alexander, Kekla Magoon, Jacqueline Woodson, and Angie Thomas. My kids (and I) have enjoyed their books.
Books that might help you, How to Be an Antiracist by Ibram X. Kendi as well as his book Stamped From The Beginning are both excellent (for kids or you try Stamped: Racism, Antiracism and You by Jason Reynolds and Ibram X. Kendi). So You Want to Talk About Race by Ijeoma Oluo is incredibly helpful. Michael Eric Dyson's Tears We Cannot Stop: A Sermon to White America. Dyson wrote the foreward to White Fragility: Why It's So Hard for White People to Talk About Racism by Robin DiAngelo which is excellent and I think a must read for white people. Another helpful book for white people who are ready to do something constructive is Waking Up White by Debby Irving.

Explore your own implicit or unconscious bias at https://implicit.harvard.edu/implicit/education.html

I would also say seek out Black Media and voices. Twitter makes that easier these days. Support Black institutions like historically black colleges and universities, black businesses, black writers. Those are some things you can do to start. Above all as you do this, be humble, be curious, be willing to challenge yourself and be uncomfortable. That is where real growth happens. Thank you for caring. If you do the work, you will never regret it.


Suppose she has already done this. Suppose she has already read the literature, the studies. Supposed she owns the implicit bias in herself. And now she wants to do something active. Something to make things better. Besides vote, is there nothing she can do besides sit and feel good that she has educated herself?


As Malcolm X said to an earnest white woman in Spike Lee’s film, “Nothing.”

Stop making it all about you, even when you’re “trying to help.” Thinking that it’s your fight or you have anything to contribute is arrogant white privilege in and of it itself. That you cannot see that is ironic and troubling.


Fine. I'll just sit home then.


Not the PP to you whom you are responding but will try a different tact. The onus on us white folks is educate ourselves and reduce harm - there is so much harm reduction that needs to be done in white communities - you will never run out of things to do.
Anonymous
Go out and peacefully protest. On Wednesday at 5pm go to your town center, busy intersection and take a knee. Then do what many of you do best, post on social media lines and lines of regular white people taking the knee.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:Sorry, but I find the white girl savior thing to be kind of cringe inducing and patronizing.

Of course you do and of course it is. Regardless, white people are a majority(still? are they still?) in the United States. And hold the political and economic power and the military in their hands. So, minorities do need help of some white people to see the change happen. I'd rather see white people join against racists. When kids of racists start joining anti racist protest changes can happen in many racist families.
Anonymous
I think hispanics are now the "minorty majority" in the U.S.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:Once again, Asian businesses are bearing the brunt of sociopathic looters taking advantage of police misconduct. They were already struggling due to COVID-19, and their situation is far worse now. If you believe we have an obligation to give space to looters and rioters, then you have an obligation to help the businesses they destroy recover.

https://www.gofundme.com/f/welcome-to-chinatown

https://www.gofundme.com/f/heart-of-dinner

https://www.dumplingsagainsthate.com


Indian bodyshops are very racist. No one should be helping them
Anonymous
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:Sorry, but I find the white girl savior thing to be kind of cringe inducing and patronizing.


Except that’s not what that was. It was white people showing up for black people and taking action at the request of black people. The protests have been organized that way.

White saviors show up unannounced and unwanted to save the poor minorities from the fresh hells of white imagination. White allies show up when invited and follow without trying to lead or center themselves.


Except she was centering herself, no? I get it. It’s tough fur whites to figure out how to “help.”
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:I think hispanics are now the "minorty majority" in the U.S.


Even still, white people have the most powerful, unchallenged voice. You have the security of safety and respect to protect you when people disagree.
post reply Forum Index » Political Discussion
Message Quick Reply
Go to: