This Is Us -- Season 2

[Anonymous]

My guess is it is Beth (cancer) or Rebecca dying (cancer/something related to being older)

They said something like “I’m not ready,” and “it’s time.”
.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I just have one observation about who the "her" is in the Tess/Randall future scene. I feel confident that it is someone they are both angry at/hurt by. Some people are speculating it's Beth, who is sick, or something like that - no, I don't think it's Beth that they need to see. It's someone who has done something unforgivable, IMO.

This!

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:
Something happens to Beth and Annie - why do we only see Tess and Randall in the flash forwards?

There have only been two, right? For all we know, Beth is having a superstar career* and Annie lives a thousand miles away.*

I agree with the PP that the show loves to expectations on their head, so I don't think this is as simple as Deja smashes windows and ruins her life. Maybe her biomom comes back into her life after Deja is grown, and Randall and Beth's family tries to rally round, but it's miserable?



*Is anyone else bugged by how Beth just went zoop! back into a career in a couple of weeks after being out of the workforce for years? Not to turn this into a battle about the merits of SAH vs WOH, because circumstances change and careers come and go, but the speed just blew my mind.

I don't think she just went back to the workforce when Randall quit. When she had the pregnancy scare in Season 1, she said something about having just gone back full time. I think that until Annie was in 1st grade that Beth worked part time and then went full time.

[Anonymous]

Was that the finale? I really want to find out who Randall and Tess were referring to.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Was that the finale? I really want to find out who Randall and Tess were referring to.

Season finale, not series finale.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I just have one observation about who the "her" is in the Tess/Randall future scene. I feel confident that it is someone they are both angry at/hurt by. Some people are speculating it's Beth, who is sick, or something like that - no, I don't think it's Beth that they need to see. It's someone who has done something unforgivable, IMO.

This!

I'm here too

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I just have one observation about who the "her" is in the Tess/Randall future scene. I feel confident that it is someone they are both angry at/hurt by. Some people are speculating it's Beth, who is sick, or something like that - no, I don't think it's Beth that they need to see. It's someone who has done something unforgivable, IMO.

This!

I'm here too

My guess is they are going to see Deja in jail.

[Anonymous]

http://bit.ly/2HApdv4

This is interesting. Apparently Deja doesn’t kill Beth or Annie at the wedding, or ever, like so many people online have speculated. Whatever is going on with Randall’s family in the flash forward will start to develop next season, according to this. I’m guessing it has to do with Annie. I think she gets overlooked because if Deja, the apartment building, and whatever else her parents take on over the next few years. Tess fits into their world better since we know she becomes a social worker. Maybe she gets more involved so doesn’t end up ignored. All of this philanthropy is not Annie’s thing so she starts to rebel. Perhaps Randall and Tess are going to see her in rehab or prison. Maybe she can only have two visitors at a time and Beth and Deja might have gone in first and now it’s Randall and Tess’s turn to go see her. I just hope they don’t make it seem like Deja’s fault that she turned bad. I don’t want them to paint foster kids in a bad light.

[Anonymous]

Also, I didn’t understand why Deja got so mad when Toby’s mom said she looks like Randall. She was fine when she referred to the three of them as their girls, so she wasn’t upset about being seen as part of the family. So why did that comment trigger her? She immediately glared at Randall and then bashed their car. I get that it would be difficult for a nonbio kid to hear that they look like a parent, but why take it out on Randall and Beth? Did I miss something?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:http://bit.ly/2HApdv4

Good stuff. I didn’t know the creator/writer is married to Madison, Kate’s “maid of honor.” Paraphrasing: Kevin and Madison are not going to happen!

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Also, I didn’t understand why Deja got so mad when Toby’s mom said she looks like Randall. She was fine when she referred to the three of them as their girls, so she wasn’t upset about being seen as part of the family. So why did that comment trigger her? She immediately glared at Randall and then bashed their car. I get that it would be difficult for a nonbio kid to hear that they look like a parent, but why take it out on Randall and Beth? Did I miss something?

Her biomom had, in her eyes, rejected her (by seeking to terminate parental rights) and her biodad had never been in the picture, so I assumed she felt as though this was one more way of erasing her actual origins. It's one thing to have people wanting to include you in their family and quite another to feel as though they're saying your original family never existed.

Think of all the people om DCUM who are outraged that their ILs want to be called Mom & Dad.

[Anonymous]

I was wondering if a fire was somehow involved in the injury -- somebody sets the tenement on fire and Beth runs in to save the residents. Kind of like a repeat of what happened to their dad.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I don't think this is Deja doing something horrible. This show is pro-adoption/foster and I can't imagine them bringing in that narrative.

I agree. I think her fit of anger in this episode is a red herring.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I found a few scenes from the most recent episode touching, but overall I was a little bored with it. I wanted to see more of the rest of the Pearson clan and instead, it was 99% about Deja and her mom. The other story lines following Jack's death weren't advanced at all.

+ 1 The imaginary vows renewal was OTT and just plain dumb.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:http://bit.ly/2HApdv4

Good stuff. I didn’t know the creator/writer is married to Madison, Kate’s “maid of honor.” Paraphrasing: Kevin and Madison are not going to happen!

It occurred to me as I was reading this that the writers have a limited amount of time to add any backstory from the kids' childhood. The child actors are going to grow and change so fast, especially the youngest ones, that there is a short window to film those scenes.