Don't waste your time. It will take losses to Spain (and other countries) at the senior team level. That won't happen quite yet, as both sides are still represented by teams that are the product of soccer 5-10 years ago. It's already happening at the youth level, so the time is coming. As the youth teams graduate into the senior teams, that's when people will see. It will be too late by then, but it will be undeniable. |
| So. If I had to do it all over, I’d likely have my kid play Barca at the pee wee to early middle school ages then switch over to more established competitive DA/ECNL club. Provide a solid fundamental base before going to clubs with more visibility, competitive leagues, and athletes. My kid does well (ECNL) but did miss out on some early 3rd party coaching (i.e no parent dynamics) of proper techniques, spacing and ball movement that would be second nature if ingrained by coaches early on. She’s catching up and still does great but could be closer to her potential I think if the better base had been established. |
Probably one of the most honest and sensible admissions in this entire thread. Good post. |
I asked for what would be an apples to apples comparison in your eyes. If Barca dragged our U15 national team would that convince you? Or would you say “not apples because the Barca team trains together constantly.”? Is there another goal post you would like to move? Barca kicked the ass of one our nations best teams from one of our most respected youth clubs. Ask any youth soccer coach, high level player or players parent to name five top clubs in the country and PDA will ALWAYS be in that list. And frankly, if it wasn’t as apples to apples as you can get, then why did PDA apply, get accepted and play PDA in the FINALS of the same tournament? If it wasn’t “apples to apples” then why the hell was PDA doing there in the first place? They went, THEY MADE THE FINALS and they got humiliated. |
Yes. Barca Spain, not the Sporting Global knock off. Good luck getting in and bon voyage! |
The kid following this path will most likely have never make a DA/ECNL team in the US. The training and playing competition there is not comparable to the environments you see on the top teams at high level clubs. Outside of a few outliers, they will suffer as a result of the lack of good internal competition and being wed to a playing style (tiki taka) that isn't in favor in the DA/ECNL. Dead end unless they are good enough to play for Barcelona in Spain, because they don't mesh well with players who don't play in that exact scheme. |
Looks like someone needs a drink... |
| No, claiming that two teams who meet in the finals of the same tournament is not “apples to apples” is claimed by someone who is clearly drinking. |
How will they suffer? By seeing the field well and finding open teammates in the scheme that they are playing. I swear to God the mental gymnastics on this board. A good, smart, well trained soccer player can flourish in any environment. |
Nailed it early on page 2—impressive!! |
Only if there is something wrong with the DA/ECNL style. There are players who come up through Barcelona in Spain, and they move to teams playing a different style regularly without there being an issue. It's not just about tiki take. It's about being tactical and technical. You can use those skills in a Barcelona style. You can use them in a Klopp style. |
They can't help it. It has been happening since they started a year and a half ago. It used to be in one overt thread, but now they use various sneaky ways the try to work in in, all based on the play of teams not affiliated in any way with Sporting Global's enterprise in the US. |
You’ve mentioned the academy more in this thread than anyone else. The topic has pretty much been on the different styles of play. |
I’m sorry nobody earlier in the thread asked where can I take my kid to learn how to play like PDA. Perhaps if PDA won AND looked good they would have though. |
LOL Barca NOVA didn't even qualify to play in this bracket, they'd have been crushed. As was stated earlier, enjoy your trip to Spain in the hopes your kid will be able to play like the team that beat this one PDA team. It's not happening here.
|