Is stating that Gaza is a genocide antisemitism?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:and apparently they aren't allowed to go to the same high schools as jewish students. completely segregated. Universities are not segregated BUT the kids are all segregated from one. another probably so that the jewish kids don't actually become friends with the Arabs while they are innocent and young and open minded or become "infected' with non-Jewish ideas.

Do you have a cite for this?

[Anonymous]

Israeli government pretends it is not, citing how they provide humanitarian aid to civilians on the other side, which nations at war never do.

But from what I can tell, any ordinary person who supports Israel's actions will say right out that every last Palestinian needs to be killed.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:If Israel wanted to commit genocide they would have done it already. Perhaps the Palestinians shouldn’t have elected Hamas to lead them.

Could they have? Are we know cIaiming that the absence of a past genocide is proof that that a current genocide has no intent?

That's a weird argument to make for a variety of reasons. It also ignores the very relevent change in Israeli politics and society since the assasination of Rabin and the political rise of the Kahanists.

Clearly Hamas and the Palestinians (they elected them) didn’t think this through very well when they decided to commit the atrocities of October 7th such as tying Israeli kids up in front of their parents and setting them on fire or slitting their throats.

Let’s see just how full of shit you are …

Of the approx. 2,100,000 individuals in Gaza on 10/8/2023, how many voted for Hamas. Accepting a number within 100,000 of the actual number.

And then when you’re done facing the fact that less than 1/15th of that 2,100,000 population ever cast a vote for Hamas (that’s less than 1 in 15, or less than 7% for those scoring at home), explain to us what the West Bsnk Palestinians did to warrant the unending attacks from the settlers and the IDF.

And what kept the non-voters from voting? They are complicit, and responsible.

They weren't born yet.

And apparently have been impotent since birth to change their regime?

Well, Israeli citizens seem to be.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:If Israel wanted to commit genocide they would have done it already. Perhaps the Palestinians shouldn’t have elected Hamas to lead them.

Could they have? Are we know cIaiming that the absence of a past genocide is proof that that a current genocide has no intent?

That's a weird argument to make for a variety of reasons. It also ignores the very relevent change in Israeli politics and society since the assasination of Rabin and the political rise of the Kahanists.

Clearly Hamas and the Palestinians (they elected them) didn’t think this through very well when they decided to commit the atrocities of October 7th such as tying Israeli kids up in front of their parents and setting them on fire or slitting their throats.

It's your turn to provide the cite.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:If Israel wanted to commit genocide they would have done it already. Perhaps the Palestinians shouldn’t have elected Hamas to lead them.

Could they have? Are we know cIaiming that the absence of a past genocide is proof that that a current genocide has no intent?

That's a weird argument to make for a variety of reasons. It also ignores the very relevent change in Israeli politics and society since the assasination of Rabin and the political rise of the Kahanists.

Clearly Hamas and the Palestinians (they elected them) didn’t think this through very well when they decided to commit the atrocities of October 7th such as tying Israeli kids up in front of their parents and setting them on fire or slitting their throats.

Let’s see just how full of shit you are …

Of the approx. 2,100,000 individuals in Gaza on 10/8/2023, how many voted for Hamas. Accepting a number within 100,000 of the actual number.

And then when you’re done facing the fact that less than 1/15th of that 2,100,000 population ever cast a vote for Hamas (that’s less than 1 in 15, or less than 7% for those scoring at home), explain to us what the West Bsnk Palestinians did to warrant the unending attacks from the settlers and the IDF.

And what kept the non-voters from voting? They are complicit, and responsible.

They weren't born yet.

And apparently have been impotent since birth to change their regime?

Well, Israeli citizens seem to be.

Israeli citizens may or may not avidly support their current government, but they are pretty well united in what they want from it and that is the neutralization of Palestinian terrorists. How best to go about that is up for debate, but the goal is uniform. Regime change is not what the Israelis want, despite the active and healthy debate over government policies around how best to ensure national security.