Nannies would you take a job in this situation? Parents, have you had a successful experience with FT child care for twin infants + 3 y/o?
I would if the pay was right and there was a nanny car for use on the job.
But what to do about the 3 year old?
IMO, that depends on what you and the child will be happiest with. If he would be happy at home with preschool half days a few time a week, go with that. If he'd be happier with full day preschool closer to home, go with that. BTW, even if he is dropping naps at that time, institute "quiet time", for your sanity and the sanity of your nanny. With 3 under 4 anyone with the kids all day will NEED an hour to relax!
If he goes to a preschool near our house, it is reasonable to ask a nanny to care for infant twins and a 3 year old every afternoon?
Yes, as long as there is a way for nanny to do pick-up and drop-off in any sort of weather.
Is it reasonable to ask the nanny to pick him up from preschool, or will that throw off the schedule with the twins?
2nd and 3rd kids have to accommodate their older siblings schedules - that's just a fact of life! If you hire a nanny with lots of experience, she will be able to juggle the needs of all 3 kids.
Does it matter if the preschool is w/in easy walking distance of our house?
No, because walking with infant twins and a preschooler in any sport of bad weather will be a turn-off. Would you do the walk to school in rain/snow/heat with 3 under 4?
Or would we need to find another arrangement (maybe college student) to transport DS home from preschool. Or leave him in FT daycare?
As I said above, a nanny car makes the most sense in this situation. That will allow nanny to both transport your older child to school and back, and allow her to go out with your twins when they are old enough to do playgroups, activities, etc.
What's reasonable to pay a nanny in this situation? We have a BR suite in the basement to do a live-in option.
I would shy away from live-in unless your BR suite is an apartment with a kitchen/kitchenette and living area, as well as a bedroom and private bath, located away from the family living/play areas.
Reasonable pay depends on the experience level and education of the nanny. You might want to consider making a "dream nanny" description, and then asking local agencies what your dream nanny would cost you. You also need to take into account what you want from nanny beyond childcare and the related household tasks. With 20 years experience, and extensive newborn experience, I'd expect $22/hour for the job with basic childcare expectations and basic benefits. A nanny with 5 years experience might be willing to take $16/hour with the same package.
You need to determine your budget, how long you want to keep the nanny, and how much experience the nanny has to have to get a good read on costs. If you can spend up to $25/hour does that include room for bonuses and raises, as well as your share of the taxes? Or do you expect to pay $25/hour PLUS the above items?