Just curious what you mean by a "weaker offer". Does that mean, for example, he's currently on a club's B team but is being offered a spot on the new club's C team?
This is actually a very good point. If the club is larger and has more teams or play at a higher level, the weaker team ( possibly lower level) may be right for his level. A team 2 player for one club will often equate to a team 3 or 4 player at a larger more skilled club. I would see which league and division the team plays in to decide if its actually weaker.
Thanks, it is actually weaker.
We've since learned from some of his buddies at the club where he wanted to be that there was fair downward movement from the team above, so this may have been the outcome no matter what - he seemed like a good fit for the team based on the current composition, but the outcome makes sense in light of the new information. We will still take the suggestions here up and give it another shot next year. Its always worth giving it his best attempt.