SATC New Season - And Just Like That...

[Anonymous]

I mean... you all realize these aren't real people, right? The plan was to kill him off. Carrie could have called 911 and done CPR until the cows came home and the man would still be dead, because the writers wanted him dead. He could have stepped into an empty elevator shaft instead but the heart attack would provide a bit more drama. It's a TV show, not a PSA.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I always found it far-fetched that Big was longing for messy and broke (and let's be frank, not very pretty) Carrie so much that he divorced his wealthy heir young wife played by Bridget Moynahan. Bridget would have called 911.

Huh. I did not know my husband posted on this site.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I always found it far-fetched that Big was longing for messy and broke (and let's be frank, not very pretty) Carrie so much that he divorced his wealthy heir young wife played by Bridget Moynahan. Bridget would have called 911.

Natasha was perfect on paper but cool whereas Carrie and Big had heat. Heat usually wins.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:A cardiologist weighs in
https://www.vulture.com/article/and-just-like-that-big-death-carrie-911-call.html?utm_source=fb&utm_medium=s1&utm_campaign=nym&fbclid=IwAR3jciAiXLQo3Olnh-Sc3BlxNoApS-4hHGezqogpDqd67xM6kyMsCeturn0

In conclusion, if Carrie had called 911 or started CPR, Big would have lived. Dating (and marrying) an idiot can have fatal consequences.

Holy cow. I mean, she should've -- absolutely -- but the success rate for CPR "range from an average of 12% for out-of-hospital cardiac arrests to 24–40% for in-hospital arrests." He had maybe a little bit better than a 1 in 10 chance of surviving.

https://www.bmj.com/company/newsroom/patients-overestimate-the-success-of-cpr/

You misunderstood. The first article is talking specifically about the medication that Big mentioned taking on the show, his lifestyle and the timing from when he first sent the text, to what is going on if he is still awake when she arrives. The conclusion that he would have lived is based on proximity to a hospital and that any EMT on the scene could have saved him. If Carrie had rushed to the medicine cabinet and given him one of his pills, she would have bought even more time for the EMTs to be successful but that’s a level of knowledge that’s unreasonable to expect.

Seriously, all she had to do was call 911 instead of stare lovingly into his eyes as he died.

It's paywalled, and it's not something I value enough to pay for. CPR *WITHIN* a hospital with advanced trained providers would be 24-40% survival, with the meds ready in a crash cart.

Sorry to disagree with the cardiologist who writes for -- what, Vulture? -- but this was no guarantee.

She still should have reacted better. Sometimes people don't do what they are supposed to, and sometimes shock and grief is debilitating.

The Vulture writer is interviewing a cardiologist. And Vulture is New York Magazine.

[Anonymous]

I'm supposed to be impressed by that?

[Anonymous]

I am kind of hoping there is a secret Big baby somewhere. Maybe with Natasha?

[Anonymous]

Are people really arguing about 911 and CPR? This isn't reality. Have you guys never seen a TV show or movie before?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I always found it far-fetched that Big was longing for messy and broke (and let's be frank, not very pretty) Carrie so much that he divorced his wealthy heir young wife played by Bridget Moynahan. Bridget would have called 911.

Natasha was perfect on paper but cool whereas Carrie and Big had heat. Heat usually wins.

Exhibit A:

Prince Charles preferred Camilla over Diana

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:A cardiologist weighs in
https://www.vulture.com/article/and-just-like-that-big-death-carrie-911-call.html?utm_source=fb&utm_medium=s1&utm_campaign=nym&fbclid=IwAR3jciAiXLQo3Olnh-Sc3BlxNoApS-4hHGezqogpDqd67xM6kyMsCeturn0

In conclusion, if Carrie had called 911 or started CPR, Big would have lived. Dating (and marrying) an idiot can have fatal consequences.

Holy cow. I mean, she should've -- absolutely -- but the success rate for CPR "range from an average of 12% for out-of-hospital cardiac arrests to 24–40% for in-hospital arrests." He had maybe a little bit better than a 1 in 10 chance of surviving.

https://www.bmj.com/company/newsroom/patients-overestimate-the-success-of-cpr/

If Big were a real person, he wouldn't want you to exert yourself for a 10% chance of saving his life.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:A cardiologist weighs in
https://www.vulture.com/article/and-just-like-that-big-death-carrie-911-call.html?utm_source=fb&utm_medium=s1&utm_campaign=nym&fbclid=IwAR3jciAiXLQo3Olnh-Sc3BlxNoApS-4hHGezqogpDqd67xM6kyMsCeturn0

In conclusion, if Carrie had called 911 or started CPR, Big would have lived. Dating (and marrying) an idiot can have fatal consequences.

Holy cow. I mean, she should've -- absolutely -- but the success rate for CPR "range from an average of 12% for out-of-hospital cardiac arrests to 24–40% for in-hospital arrests." He had maybe a little bit better than a 1 in 10 chance of surviving.

https://www.bmj.com/company/newsroom/patients-overestimate-the-success-of-cpr/

If Big were a real person, he wouldn't want you to exert yourself for a 10% chance of saving his life.

You people are nuts! It’s wasn’t an off chance of saving his life— it was a sure thing! Considering he was alive when she got there and they live less than 10 minutes from a world class hospital, a 911 call would have certainly saved his life. Any EMT on site could have stabilized him.

It’s crazy that people are clinging so hard to the idea that a fictional character has some redeeming values that they’re willing to ignore the obvious. Calling 911 saves lives. In 2021 a heart attack is not a death sentence—especially when your penthouse is less than 10 minutes from a hospital.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I'm supposed to be impressed by that?

A lot of fans are impressed that Carrie chose to let Big die instead of calling 911. It’s definitely more romantic to be so in love you lose yourself in each other’s eyes instead of having a bunch of people traipsing through your perfect apartment and rushing to the hospital.

I’m not impressed either

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Well this thread sure did blow up considering all of the people who swore they weren’t interested in the reboot! I just caught the first 2 episodes. Maybe my expectations were low, but I actually enjoyed it. They definitely surpassed the 2 movies (a low bar, I know) and possibly the tail end of Season 6. Kim Cattrall would have been a nice addition, but I wouldn’t say I missed Samantha’s character. I surprisingly found myself liking the new characters, especially Miranda’s professor. I’ll definitely be tuning in for the remaining episodes. Til next week

Tell us you're an HBO Max™ intern without telling us you're an HBO Max™ intern.

100%

[Anonymous]

I’m just over here wondering what’s going on with Miranda’s drinking.

Also Bigs secretary?

And liking the return of Susan Sharon

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I mean... you all realize these aren't real people, right? The plan was to kill him off. Carrie could have called 911 and done CPR until the cows came home and the man would still be dead, because the writers wanted him dead. He could have stepped into an empty elevator shaft instead but the heart attack would provide a bit more drama. It's a TV show, not a PSA.

100%

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Well this thread sure did blow up considering all of the people who swore they weren’t interested in the reboot! I just caught the first 2 episodes. Maybe my expectations were low, but I actually enjoyed it. They definitely surpassed the 2 movies (a low bar, I know) and possibly the tail end of Season 6. Kim Cattrall would have been a nice addition, but I wouldn’t say I missed Samantha’s character. I surprisingly found myself liking the new characters, especially Miranda’s professor. I’ll definitely be tuning in for the remaining episodes. Til next week

Tell us you're an HBO Max™ intern without telling us you're an HBO Max™ intern.

100%

Ok Kim